Day Dethy Whatever the number day 2

[Till Valhalla]

NIGHT 0

@Manish. @Yash. @RUDI @asprin @Ashutosh.
Roles sent, if you can confirm then we start, maybe even sent your investigations.

 

[Ashutosh.]

Role received

 

[Manish.]

Role received.

 

[RUDI]

• Role
• Received

 

[asprin]

Role received

 

[Yash.]

Received

 

[Till Valhalla]

Day 1
@Manish. @Yash. @asprin @RUDI @Ashutosh.
Day 1
Begins
5 alive 3 to lynch

 

[Ashutosh.]

Yash - mafia

 

[RUDI]

Yash - Town

 

[Manish.]

Yash - mafia

Okay, things look simple but complex.

Visited Yash and received Mafia.

But the real problem is all the cops are of 4 types.
Sane - get the correct result
Insane - gets the opposite result to suppose a player is a town it will show mafia to him and vice versa
Naive - will always get results as the town
Paranoid - will always get results as a mafia

Edit - Once everyone posts, I'll try to add my comments on above 4 categories.

 

[Yash.]

Lol everyone's investigating me

I investigated Rudi and got town.

 

[asprin]

Rudi - Town

Will do the analysis soon. Didn't want to stop proceedings hence posting the result right away.

By the look of things, 3 results on Yash should clear things a bit corbus.

 

[RUDI]

If Yash is scum: Not cleared
Ashutosh - Mafia: Sane / Insane / Paranoid
RUDI - Town: Sane / Insane / Naive
Manish - Mafia: Sane / Insane / Paranoid

If RUDI is scum:
Yash - Town: Sane / Insane / Naive
asprin - Town: Sane / Insane / Naive

By assuming one person is Scum and analyzing each player's inspection, you can clear that person if three people would have to assume only two roles. Assume John is scum. Therefore:

• Dave = Insane/Paranoid
• Mike = Sane/Naive
• Nick = Sane/Paranoid
• Tony = Sane/Naive

 

[Yash.]

If Yash is scum: Not cleared
Ashutosh - Mafia: Sane / Insane / Paranoid
RUDI - Town: Sane / Insane / Naive
Manish - Mafia: Sane / Insane / Paranoid

If RUDI is scum:
Yash - Town: Sane / Insane / Naive
asprin - Town: Sane / Insane / Naive

I think your analysis is wrong in both cases... Maybe you wrote Sane mistakenly in all the entries.

If I am scum
Ashutosh - Mafia -> Sane / Paranoid
Rudi - Town -> Insane / Naive
Manish - Mafia -> Sane / Paranoid

If Rudi is scum
Yash - Town -> Insane / Naive
asprin - Town -> Insane / Naive

 

[Manish.]

Okay, things look simple but complex.

Visited Yash and received Mafia.

But the real problem is all the cops are of 4 types.
Sane - get the correct result
Insane - gets the opposite result to suppose a player is a town it will show mafia to him and vice versa
Naive - will always get results as the town
Paranoid - will always get results as a mafia

Edit - Once everyone posts, I'll try to add my comments on above 4 categories.

Yash

Rudi got town - Yash must be Sane/Insane/Naive
AK and Me got Mafia - Yash must be Sane/Insane/Paranoid.

RUDI

Asprin and Yash got town - Rudi must be a Sane/Insane/Naive

If Asprin might have visited Yash then the possibilities would have broken down to a smaller number. We should at least know the representation of one cop.