FIFA 06 vs Pro Evolution Soccer 5

[Shoaib87]

My vote goes to Pro Evolution Soccer 5.After playing FIFA 06 for about 8 weeks & Pro Evo 5 for about 6 weeks ,here r my ratings(based on PS2 version).

Pro Evolution Soccer 5

Graphics:9/10
Gameplay:10/10
Sound/Commentary:8/10

Overall:9/10


FIFA 06

Graphics:8/10
Gameplay:8/10
Sound/Commentary:8/10

Overall:8/10

 

[.::Stevo::.]

you gave pretty high scores for both games, particuly commentary!

Gameplay - PES is the clear winner, so much more fun and realistic to play!.

Realism - in terms of gamplay its PES, but the atmosphere in PES is pathetic, this where FIFA kills them, also, FIFA has all the licences, but with the Option file you can get them all in PES.

With the PES Option file, PES5 is a clear winner.

Oh and Commentary on both games is crapola!!

 

[sachin]

Why oh why can't we be spared such threads?They always end up with fights,plus we already discuss it on the Game specific threads.

 

[gold639]

PES 5 = Amazing gameplay, decent graphics, fun master league.

Fifa 06 = Great Graphics, interesting unlockables, fun manager mode.

PES 5 wins it with the better gameplay.

 

[hassan]

pes 5 gets me votes

I like PES 5 coz of
Gameplay and better contracts negotians and off-season

Fifa 2006 is better

Licences,Graphics(Amazing), more modes and features and scouting and staff upgrades

 

[m_vaughan]

Id prefer Fifa 06. Have enjoyed playing it so far.

 

[Yorkshire_No1]

PES gets my vote because the gameplay is absolute quality

 

[sachin]

PES 5 = Amazing gameplay, decent graphics, fun master league.

Fifa 06 = Great Graphics, interesting unlockables, fun manager mode.

PES 5 wins it with the better gameplay.

I can't believe you'd get involved in such a stupid debate :
I thought you wanted to be made a Staff Member?

 

[hassan]

how come thats stupid, only coz u like fifa and know that pes is better it doesnt make this a stupid debate

 

[themuel1]

you gave pretty high scores for both games, particuly commentary!

Gameplay - PES is the clear winner, so much more fun and realistic to play!.

Realism - in terms of gamplay its PES, but the atmosphere in PES is pathetic, this where FIFA kills them, also, FIFA has all the licences, but with the Option file you can get them all in PES.

With the PES Option file, PES5 is a clear winner.

Oh and Commentary on both games is crapola!!

Fifa's commentary is amazing compared to the shambolic dialogue whoever makes PES created. Theres just somthing that feels wrong with PES. Also, look at replays when players kick the ball (shoot). They don't actually touch it, it's about 1 metre away from there foot!!!

 

[hassan]

ya there graphics sucks i admit and commentary i can do better than that but the gameplay just cancels out everything

 

[kamrandahir]

Pro Evolution Soccer 5 is the world best football game
ny points
pes 10/9.0
fifa 10/8.8

 

[sachin]

how come thats stupid, only coz u like fifa and know that pes is better it doesnt make this a stupid debate

It does,cause we start getting abusive,well, you start getting abusive :
I was just playing with Gold.

Pro Evolution Soccer 5 is the world best football game
ny points
pes 10/9.0
fifa 10/8.8

I definetely wouldn't put FIFA as 8.8!More like7.5

 

[.::Stevo::.]

I gave my vote to FIFA, although PES's gameplay is more real, i find FIFA just a better game to play.....

In PES i can only sit and probaly play 1-2 matches, its just FIFA's atmosphere +licencese+the awsome career mode can get me playing for ages!

 

[gold639]

It does,cause we start getting abusive,well, you start getting abusive :
I was just playing with Gold.

I did want to become a staff member yeah...then I realized its a pointless burden

I can't believe you'd get involved in such a stupid debate.

I'm Senior Replay Reviewer on GameReplays.org so....I've got kinda used to answering in these type of threads...how much time does it take to type it out anyway?