Gilchrist vs Dhoni

[Akash00]

mmm...This isn't a joke. Gilly can't even come close to Dhoni's captaincy. But he is the best keeper. And at batting they both are equal. Gilly is an attacking batsman whereas Dhoni is a moderate hitter.

 

[WORLD CHAMPIONS]

Dhoni is better than Gilly in ODIs and perhaps T20s.
Gilchrist is way way ahead of Dhoni in test matches that it not funny.

Since I give more weightage to Test cricket, It is Gilly.

Really ? : How many time Dhoni had lead from the front ? See IPL.. Gilly got 100 . How many 50's dhoni made in IPL ? Gilly played around 11 nad half years, Dhoni has not even crossed 5 yrs of cricket. Dhonis average 24 in T20, and you telling his a better T20 player ? Gilly is miles ahead of Dhoni in all form.

 

[Highlander999]

I'm with WC on this. Dhoni is a good captain, but Gilly was miles ahead of Dhoni, technically with his keeping and batting (and that's a Brit praising an Aussie) Remember Gilly was at the top of the order against the new ball, as well

 

[mukund_nadkarni]

And what does Agent 47 play?!

 

[WORLD CHAMPIONS]

And what does Agent 47 play?!

He is Hitman

 

[mukund_nadkarni]

Yeah I know, in fact's it's my favourite game. But I never saw him play!!

 

[Dare]

Dhoni is better than Gilly in ODIs and perhaps T20s.

Gilchrist is way way ahead of Dhoni in test matches that it not funny.

Since I give more weightage to Test cricket, It is Gilly.

wow man you really are full of bs. and allot of bias too.

Gilly is one of the best ODI openers of all time.

 

[Highlander999]

wow man you really are full of bs. and allot of bias too.

I would have said that but I know certain members don't like it when I put the words "Indian" and "bias" in the same sentence

 

[SciD]

Gilly is best ever wk. Dhoni will be close second.

 

[sohum]

Gilly by a lot. Dhoni needs to keep performing at his current level for 5 more years to even warrant comparisons.

 

[.Mob]

I would have said that but I know certain members don't like it when I put the words "Indian" and "bias" in the same sentence

HAHAHAHAHAHAHA. HAHAHAHAHA. HAHAHAHAHA. HAHAHA. HA. HA.


Unfair comparison to make.

 

[deerkick]

Umm yeah, doesn't even need to be said

 

[aussie1st]

I don't know how people are judging Gilly captaincy seeing he hardly did it. But he has done what very few captains in the history of the game have done and that is win a Test series in India.

As for the question Gilly right now. His keeping was underrated, he took some awesome catches and because of his height he was able to get to balls that shorter keepers would have let through. Towards the end of his career he started dropping some but that is to be expected. His batting was not only explosive but also he had the ability to rescue Australia from a bad position.

 

[srikarr12]

he had the ability to rescue Australia from a bad position.

Or sink them, to me he used to be those batsmen who guaranteed to get 30 odd but after that anything could happen.

 

[Highlander999]

I think you and me are watching different Gilchrists.