Lord of the Rings Mafia - Town wins

[Manly]

@ Varun 1101 - I changed my claim because I said I was losing interest in the game. You'll all have to take my word for the final, one-kill cult claim.

@ Varun 1118 - That's my thing, lynching the bandwagon-starter, that's not the role that dictates that.


Still intensely suspicious of you, why shouldn't the town lynch you? I reckon you're mafia, and because I said to you that you're on my list, you unlynched me, probably on the advice of your mafia mates.

 

[Varun]

Still intensely suspicious of you, why shouldn't the town lynch you? I reckon you're mafia, and because I said to you that you're on my list, you unlynched me, probably on the advice of your mafia mates.

Err no I believe you are 'suspicious' of me, just to save yourself. It's a cult/Sk/mafia tactic. I've faced it earlier with Tom and Treva as well, and your play is similar to them. If one out of all is intensely suspicious of you, be suspicious of him.

I wasn't going to unlynch you, but for the obvious reasons, and have to agree, on Colin's invitation, changed my lynch.

Bolded lines - Appears purely rhetorical to me, no meaning in it.

 

[Manly]

I was just trying to stir a bit of conversation lad, don't take it personally.

We've established I can't win, so I'm just trying to help the town out as much as possible.

 

[Varun]

I was just trying to stir a bit of conversation lad,

Ironical, haha.

 

[Spoobir]

I not going to have a ton of time to be active this week but ill try to get on as much as I can. Is this list of claims to players correct?

Alive
Zohaib - Faramir (?)
barmyarmy - Gandalf
Mark - Pippen
BKB1991 - Merry
Maney2k9 - Boromir
Culli - Theoden (?)
Chewie - Elrond (?)
Spoobir - Gimli
6ry4nj - Frodo
CG123 - Shelob (?)
Hedger 14 - Eowyn
Varun - Eomer (?)
SachinFan98 - ?


Dead
AngryPixel - Denethor, Steward of Gondor, Cult-aligned - Lynched Day 1
MaD - Gothmog, Leader of the Armies, Mafia-aligned - Killed Day 1
ARay - Bilbo Baggins, Retired Hobbit, Town-aligned - Killed Night 1
Yudi - Arwen, Lady of Rivendell, Town-aligned - Lynched Day 2
Highlander999 - Treebeard, Ent, Town-aligned - Lynched Day 3
User2010 - Samwise Gamgee, The Gardener, Town-aligned - Killed Day 3
Aditya - Legolas, Archer, Town-aligned - Killed Night 3

Again I feel Eomer is a weak claim by Varun but I'm wary about lynching based on that again after Tom...

 

[barmyarmy]

I'm just trying to help the town out as much as possible.

Lynch Chewie then.

----------

@Spoobir - that is correct with the dodgier claims identified...
As you say we don't want to rely on that too much though; best to go back to basics and look for scummy play.

----------

I'm ?omer, town aligned, and vanilla townie

Just a formatting point here. Everyone else's claim has had a "role" of sorts after it as in Spoobir's post. Your's appears to be missing it which makes me a bit suspicious.

 

[Varun]

Yeah, I have it. I manually typed in my role rather than copying it from the PM so I guess I missed it.

From the PM, it is, ?omer, Eighteenth King of Rohan, Town-aligned.

 

[Spoobir]

Yeah, I have it. I manually typed in my role rather than copying it from the PM so I guess I missed it.

From the PM, it is, ?omer, Eighteenth King of Rohan, Town-aligned.

Wait so if Eomer is king, doesn't that mean Theoden is already dead?

 

[Manly]

Uh-Oh...spaghetti-o!

Wheels are falling off Varun's game!

 

[barmyarmy]

Eomer becomes King at the end of TROTK after Theoden's death at Pelennor Fields.
He's just Thoeden's nephew before that (he become his heir when Saruman's forces kill Theoden's son).

 

[Varun]

Wait so if Eomer is king, doesn't that mean Theoden is already dead?

What? Can you explain?

----------

Alright, if Theoden was the king, the Culli is lying or he is dead (his character? Like Harry's parents in HP mafia).

I have stated my character in PM exactly as it is. Culli has as well?

 

[barmyarmy]

We can't have two Kings of Rohan at the same time...

 

[Varun]

Then Culli is lying as far as I'm concerned.

Unlynch: Chewie
Lynch: Culli

 

[barmyarmy]

Alright. We're going to get one of you so if Culli turns up townie we can lynch you tomorrow:

Unlynch: chewie
Lynch: Culli

 

[Manly]

Jumping on the bandwagon

Lynch: Culli