Article - Best Indian XI to take on Pakistan

Cricketman

ICC Chairman
Joined
Jul 27, 2005
Location
USA
There is nothing in the world like an India-Pakistan series. It's no longer a game of cricket, it's a war. The prize of victory is what the teams crave for, and they will stop at nothing to achieve it.
To prevail in such a chaotic battle, we must use the best weapons possible. In the case of cricket, the weapons are our players. Which eleven weapons will win us this important contest?

The Opening Pair
An integral part to any ODI innings is getting off to a 'flier'. What this means is to not only score runs at a good rate, but also keeping wickets in tact. The Openers must be solid in technique, have the ability to both hit to long ball and to see through tough periods. His goal must be to bat through to the end whilst scoring at a strike rate at about 85.
With five opening batsman in the wings, who is best suited for the job?

Sachin Tendulkar-34 & Sourav Ganguly-34
With over 25,000 runs between them, Tendulkar and Ganguly have the experience to face, well, anything. Recent form for the pair has been unmatchable. Dominance against anything marginally loose is shown by Tendulkar, while Ganguly thrives on his Cover-drives and footwork. The only point going against them is age. Ganguly is slow in between the wickets, but his partner is still going strong. The case is similar in the field as well. Ganguly seems to be the weak-link when not padded up, but Tendulkar still has that youthful exuberance and electric attitude to justify his spot in the side.

The Middle Order


Gautam Ghambir-26 After popping in and out of the side for four years, Ghambir has peaked. After accumulating the second highest runs in the ICC World Twenty20, Ghambir's career has rocketed. 70's and 80's before the twenty over mark seem to now be commonplace for him. His technique has improved and he mixes control with aggression. He plays both spin and pace equally well. He's alert in the field and has taken some truly spectacular catches in his 32-match career.

Mahendra Singh Dhoni+* -26 The Indian Captain averages a solid 83.80 coming in at number four. He bats at an awesome strike rate of 95, perfect for the ODI game. I always felt he batted too far down the order to make a real impact. Usually batting at around 6 or 7, he doesn't have time to really lay into the opposition as much as he could up higher in the line up.
He has a thing for Pakistan, too- averaging a whopping 60 against them.

Yuvraj Singh-25 Experienced and naturally gifted, Yuvraj is the meat of the middle order. Like many others in the Indian Team, Yuvraj is rising up to the top of his career. Averaging 53 in 2006 and 42 in 2007, he has come of age. Big scores backed up by consistent performances have really defined him as a cricketer. Hitting clean, long sixes has been his trademark off late, and his Six Sixes against England in the World T20 was the best example of that. Yuvraj is also India's prime fielder, securing the cover region with his diving stops. His bowling is pretty handy too- he's picked up 51 wickets with his loopy left-arm spin.

Robin Uthappa-21 One of the young generation members of the Indian side, Uthappa has already played some masterclass innings. He bats at a rate higher then a run-a-ball, and averages 52 batting at 6. He showed composure and resistance even when the odds were heavily stacked against him against Australia, batting with the tail. He, along with some luck, scripted a great win.
Another talented fielder, he puts his heart into stopping every single run he can.


Bowlers

Irfan Pathan-23 Irfan plays the allrounder's role.
After being dropped from the side due to a severe drop in pace, Pathan has bounced back quite well. A successfully World T20 has refueled the fire inside of him, and he will be hungry to rip into Pakistan.
He averages a handy 23 with the bat, hitting at almost 80 runs per hundred balls.
With the ball, Irfan averages 26 runs per wicket, at an economy of 5.
Irfan must bowl with the new ball, he averages 22 with it. When bowling anything else, he averages in excess of 44.

Harbhajan Singh- 27 Variations are the key to Harbhajan Singh. His off-break, arm ball, doosra, and the newly formed spinning Yorker. He too found his game once again. No longer does he fire every ball in the block-hole. He's prepared to toss it up, beat the batsman in flight. Ricky Ponting was clueless against him, and he'll hope he can carry his form over against Pakistan.

Murali Kartik-31 The Comeback King was on fire against the Aussies. After a brilliant county season, where he snapped up 51 wickets with his wily left arm spin, Kartik ripped into Australia with awesome figures of 6/27 at the Wankhade.
It was a tough decision between Kartik and Chawla, but on current form the offspinner won the battle.

Zaheer Khan-29 An experienced candidate of 140 ODI's, Zaheer spearheads the Indian attack. Zaheer uses pace and good control to pick his scalps. After an awesome tour of England, Zaheer has taken over the helm as the go-to guy for the captain to provide a wicket. A mediocre average against Pakistan (45) is something he would like to improve apon, but if he bowled like he did in England, his success is almost inevitable.

Shanthakumaran Sreesanth-24 Aggressive, fast, and hugely talented, Sreesanth provides the extra dimension to the Indian bowling attack. The different angle, and speed. He may not have the best ODI record (Average 33, Economy 5.81) but he's a wicket taker. He believes in himself and fights fire with fire. He has a good slower delivery a pacey bouncer, which make him a vital asset to the Indian XI.

It can also be viewed here
 
Last edited:
best Indian 11 take on Pakistan ??
 
best Indian 11 take on Pakistan ??

Yes.
I write articles for my blog-bluecricketblog.blogspot.com-which is mainly about the Indian Cricket Team.
I thought it was obvious in the first sentence itself :p
 
yeah but i got surprised when i saw thread name.. good team btw,
 
i dont know to me that midle order seems kinda weak, i wouldnt have droped Dravid for the Pakistan series. he has been one of the best batsman in the world and one steady point in Indias midle order, after Ganguly left and Tendulkar started strugling Dravid was the one that steped it up.

also im a huge fan of players that realize when its time to retire and do it before they become and absolute shadow of them self and Tendulkar has been that for the last 2 years, his form hasnt been the best hes been injured way to often and for that reason i dont have as much respect for him.
 
i dont know to me that midle order seems kinda weak, i wouldnt have droped Dravid for the Pakistan series. he has been one of the best batsman in the world and one steady point in Indias midle order, after Ganguly left and Tendulkar started strugling Dravid was the one that steped it up.

also im a huge fan of players that realize when its time to retire and do it before they become and absolute shadow of them self and Tendulkar has been that for the last 2 years, his form hasnt been the best hes been injured way to often and for that reason i dont have as much respect for him.

Tendulkar's been in top form the last two years.
Code:
                    Mat    I  NO  Runs HS1  HS2  HS3     Ave 100  50   0
2006 (32y 252d)       16   16   2   628 141* 100   95   44.85   2   3   1
2007 (33y 252d)       28   27   2  1166 100*  99   99   46.64   1  11   3

Dravid wasn't included in the squad so I couldn't have selected him against Pakistan.
If he were, Ghambir, unfortunately, would get the butt while Dravid will take his spot at 3.
 
I reckon Tendulkar and Gangully should open in the one dayers but not the tests. Tendulkar at 4 and Dravid at 3. Presuming he finds some form. Also Uthappa would be a good contender opening the batting, seeing as he was not batting that high in the one dayers. This would be my Indian team for their first test against pakistan

Uthappa
Gangully
Dravid
Tendulkar
Singh
Ghambir
Dhoni
Pathan
Khan
H. Singh
Sreesanth

12th man Murali Kartik
 
This would be my Indian team for their first test against pakistan

Uthappa
Gangully

Dravid
Tendulkar
Singh
Ghambir
Dhoni
Pathan
Khan
H. Singh
Sreesanth

12th man Murali Kartik

I am sure, you have not watched much Indian test cricket! ;) Without Kumble in tests, it make no sense and damn weak in bowling.. and KKD Karthik/Jaffer are likely to open in Tests with their recent success in past and unless Sehwag does some magic.

Mat I NO Runs HS1 HS2 HS3 Ave 100 50 0
2006 (32y 252d) 16 16 2 628 141* 100 95 44.85 2 3 1
2007 (33y 252d) 28 27 2 1166 100* 99 99 46.64 1 11 3

There are some silly people who wants to throw Tendulkar off inspite of his dominant performances especially when he has crossed 1000 runs in 2007. Its simply because, may be, people have just got bored of getting a reply back from Tendulkar through his dominance whenever he gets criticised. :p

I really don't know whats wrong with so many people as well as so called experts when Tendulkar himself have said few months before, he is not going to retire sooner and no idea about it and still enjoying cricket! Cric info have twice published the wrong news that he is retiring.

I believe still, There is some cricket still left with Tendulkar.
 
Last edited:
r.p singh shud be in the team..he bowled well against them in recent 20 20 world cup...sreesanth is the one to be out..there is no wrong going wit 3 left arm pacers

my team if dravid is back ..no place for ganguly..he is slow runner and weakest link in the team..yes he hits runs..but he uses lots of balls ....and very bad fielder ..also selectors thought of dropping ganguly..but vengasarkar asked them to drop dravid..coz vengsarkar and dravid had some arguments during england tour

sachin
gambhir
dravid
yuvaraj
uthappa
dhoni
irfanpathan
murali karthik
harbjan singh
r.p singh
zaherr khan
sreesanth-12 th man

put dravid in slips..and u get a best fielding site...u get a team wit experience & youth...
 
Last edited:
nice article, but like someone said, we don't have a player who can come at 12/3 and build the innings. Dhoni definitely cannot, Uthappa hasn't showed that, Yuvraj ...may be, and Gambhir hasn't proven anything yet.

Only Tendulkar and to some extent, Ganguly, can build that innings under that pressure. Given the squad, the team's left with no choice. But if Dravid or Badrinath are selected for the last three ODIs, they might as well get the nod.

Considering SS's recent performance, i'd go for RP Singh. It might be 3-left armers but as long as they're effective, its fine. They are three different bowlers anyway.
 
A definite person who can come in at 12/3 and pace his innings very well was Badrinath, but he isn't in the squad as well as the obvious choice of Dravid.

Badri uses his head very well and is a very composed individual as well as player.
 
Before I start my constructive criticism, change the title to "My Best Indian XI to take on Pakistan in the First ODI" or something that implies that it is your choice and you are not imposing the choice,

There is nothing in the world like an India-Pakistan series. It's no longer a game of cricket, it's a war.

?!

The prize of victory is what the teams crave for, and they will stop at nothing to achieve it.
To prevail in such a chaotic battle, we must use the best weapons possible. In the case of cricket, the weapons are our players. Which eleven weapons will win us this important contest?

Maybe change prize to pride? If this is a blog entry 'us' is acceptable but not in an article.

The Opening Pair
An integral part to any ODI innings is getting off to a 'flier'. What this means is to not only score runs at a good rate, but also keeping wickets in tact. The Openers must be solid in technique, have the ability to both hit to long ball and to see through tough periods. His goal must be to bat through to the end whilst scoring at a strike rate at about 85.
With five opening batsman in the wings, who is best suited for the job?

"Have the ability to both hit to long ball"?!? TBH, the whole paragraph is awkwardly phrased. I also advise using a simply line break instead of the sorta half line break you use.

Sachin Tendulkar-34 & Sourav Ganguly-34
With over 25,000 runs between them, Tendulkar and Ganguly have the experience to face, well, anything. Recent form for the pair has been unmatchable. Dominance against anything marginally loose is shown by Tendulkar, while Ganguly thrives on his Cover-drives and footwork. The only point going against them is age. Ganguly is slow in between the wickets, but his partner is still going strong. The case is similar in the field as well. Ganguly seems to be the weak-link when not padded up, but Tendulkar still has that youthful exuberance and electric attitude to justify his spot in the side.

'experience to face, well, anything', stick to basic language and use informal language when you have more confidence with your writing. Add a 'The' for the beginning of the next sentence. 'Cover-drives' should not be capitalised. Tendulkar is not 'still going strong', he can't make it to 90 without cramping and his fielding is in unarguable decline.

The Middle Order

Gautam Ghambir-26 After popping in and out of the side for four years, Ghambir has peaked. After accumulating the second highest runs in the ICC World Twenty20, Ghambir's career has rocketed. 70's and 80's before the twenty over mark seem to now be commonplace for him. His technique has improved and he mixes control with aggression. He plays both spin and pace equally well. He's alert in the field and has taken some truly spectacular catches in his 32-match career.

Gambhir*. Put a semi-colon, comma or hyphen after the age. No hyphen needed after 32.

Mahendra Singh Dhoni+* -26 The Indian Captain averages a solid 83.80 coming in at number four. He bats at an awesome strike rate of 95, perfect for the ODI game. I always felt he batted too far down the order to make a real impact. Usually batting at around 6 or 7, he doesn't have time to really lay into the opposition as much as he could up higher in the line up.
He has a thing for Pakistan, too- averaging a whopping 60 against them.

Put (wk and capt.) or other words in brackets to the same effect. *+ just looking odd. Strike rates of 83.80 coming in at four in ODIs? Tests? T20s? 'He has a thing for Pakistan' is a bit strange phrasing and again, the hyphen is not needed.

Yuvraj Singh-25 Experienced and naturally gifted, Yuvraj is the meat of the middle order. Like many others in the Indian Team, Yuvraj is rising up to the top of his career. Averaging 53 in 2006 and 42 in 2007, he has come of age. Big scores backed up by consistent performances have really defined him as a cricketer. Hitting clean, long sixes has been his trademark off late, and his Six Sixes against England in the World T20 was the best example of that. Yuvraj is also India's prime fielder, securing the cover region with his diving stops. His bowling is pretty handy too- he's picked up 51 wickets with his loopy left-arm spin.

Instead of saying his average in 2006 and 2007, just say how he has averaged in the last three years. Much simpler. 'Six Sixes' should not be capitalised.

Robin Uthappa-21 One of the young generation members of the Indian side, Uthappa has already played some masterclass innings. He bats at a rate higher then a run-a-ball, and averages 52 batting at 6. He showed composure and resistance even when the odds were heavily stacked against him against Australia, batting with the tail. He, along with some luck, scripted a great win.
Another talented fielder, he puts his heart into stopping every single run he can.

That is a good paragraph. Talk about which ODI it was which he won though. in terms of first, second, third, forth...etc...

Bowlers

Irfan Pathan-23 Irfan plays the allrounder's role.
After being dropped from the side due to a severe drop in pace, Pathan has bounced back quite well. A successfully World T20 has refueled the fire inside of him, and he will be hungry to rip into Pakistan.
He averages a handy 23 with the bat, hitting at almost 80 runs per hundred balls.
With the ball, Irfan averages 26 runs per wicket, at an economy of 5.
Irfan must bowl with the new ball, he averages 22 with it. When bowling anything else, he averages in excess of 44.

'A successfully World T20' doesn't make sense. '80 runs per hundred balls', don't mix numbers and words during a phrase, just pick one for each phrase. Number overload there, keep numbers short and sweet, a maximum or two figures per paragraph as a rule of thumb.

Harbhajan Singh- 27 Variations are the key to Harbhajan Singh. His off-break, arm ball, doosra, and the newly formed spinning Yorker. He too found his game once again. No longer does he fire every ball in the block-hole. He's prepared to toss it up, beat the batsman in flight. Ricky Ponting was clueless against him, and he'll hope he can carry his form over against Pakistan.

Variation? He has just been bowling flat, quick off breaks with the odd tossed up one. Amongst fear over his action, I haven't seen him bowl a doosra in terms of the ball actually spinning away, in ages.

Murali Kartik-31 The Comeback King was on fire against the Aussies. After a brilliant county season, where he snapped up 51 wickets with his wily left arm spin, Kartik ripped into Australia with awesome figures of 6/27 at the Wankhade.
It was a tough decision between Kartik and Chawla, but on current form the offspinner won the battle.

Good paragraph but why Kartik over Chawla who was impressive in England? Not arguing, but you have to explain your opinions.

Zaheer Khan-29 An experienced candidate of 140 ODI's, Zaheer spearheads the Indian attack. Zaheer uses pace and good control to pick his scalps. After an awesome tour of England, Zaheer has taken over the helm as the go-to guy for the captain to provide a wicket. A mediocre average against Pakistan (45) is something he would like to improve apon, but if he bowled like he did in England, his success is almost inevitable.

Good.

Shanthakumaran Sreesanth-24 Aggressive, fast, and hugely talented, Sreesanth provides the extra dimension to the Indian bowling attack. The different angle, and speed. He may not have the best ODI record (Average 33, Economy 5.81) but he's a wicket taker. He believes in himself and fights fire with fire. He has a good slower delivery a pacey bouncer, which make him a vital asset to the Indian XI.

Might want to mention he was India's top wicket taker against Australia even though he did not play all the ODIs. 'He has a good slower delivery', he has two slower deliveries, a leg break and a back of the hand variation.[/QUOTE]

You are definately improving...well done!
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top