Lord of the Rings Mafia - Town wins

[ARay]

I'm not playing any further games with AP. What an effing end for me! I'm pretty frustrated. On top of that, all his other posts.

Doesn't mean you have to play stupid if you don't have any power. I'll feel I've done my job taking you out.

You should not have claimed atleast in my opinion. But yeah, i feel your frustration.

 

[barmyarmy]

@ARay - how would you have played it?

 

[BKB1991]

Well atleast a non townie is dead. If hes cult leader it helps us alot, because only the cult leader can recruit, but with him dying theres a possibility of his power to recruit being transferred. Maney should be looked at, and if night writeups indicate that someone is recruiting then we should be safer lynching him.

Cant say AP played pathetically, he isnt town so its understandable that he doesnt think of our benefits, but AP for your own personal safety you shouldnt have roleclaimed Sam.

Callum your defence came just at the right time, you seem pro-town

Lol the fellowship is in trouble.

 

[ARay]

@ARay - how would you have played it?

I probably would have not pressured it if I saw people not following through. While in a way it might have been bad, I would have waited to link up more people with AP (this is going with the assumption that he is mafia) later on in the days. I don't necessarily agree with a 1 for 1 trade especially if the townie has a power role.

Though thinking about it, it could definitely be possible that Sam has no power role which is why he decided to role claim early on. I guess such a possibility cannot be ignored.

 

[MaD]

Well after research, I discover that Boromir and Denethor were quite close? Not sure though.

 

[Varun]

Meh, every interesting thing in this game occurs only when I'm off.

AP, you aren't meant to reveal everything about you once you're lynched. Roles are not being revealed on death, so we might even wouldn't have known you were cult. Just *something* aligned. And this isn't to be looked upon as me defending myself or something. It's just that he's hammered and it's against the rules.

 

[barmyarmy]

I see Sam as quite possibly vanilla - he's pretty useless in the books. User2010 obviously wanted to avoid dying though.

 

[Varun]

Coincidentally, this is the third time someone has claimed what role/character User2010 is. Pokemon mafia, Smurfs mafia and then this.

 

[Spoobir]

I see Sam as quite possibly vanilla - he's pretty useless in the books. User2010 obviously wanted to avoid dying though.

Lol, don't hate on Sam. He's the only reason they succeed in destroying the ring at all! Frodo is more useless than Sam...

 

[barmyarmy]

Well after research, I discover that Boromir and Denethor were quite close? Not sure though.

As someone else said already. He's his son and sends him to the Council of Elrond to claim (or steal if required) the ring for Gondor.

----------

Lol, don't hate on Sam. He's the only reason they succeed in destroying the ring at all! Frodo is more useless than Sam...

He's got a universal backup feel to him if he's anything.

 

[Gaurav_7]

User2010 obviously wanted to avoid dying though.

Of course, only way I could win as I've never won a mafia game. *Wipes tears off his eyes*

But, I thought getting an early anti town (assumed he's a mafia) would be useful. I don't mind dying now, can't get any worse for the town, the current situation.

 

[Varun]

Well it's often a bad start for us, doesn't mean we can't pull it off. Town has been winning this for like, 4 games now.

 

[treva]

End of Day 1

It was a long day within the walls of Minas Tirith with very little substantial claims. Roleclaims had been forced but it seemed as if all the discussion would end with a no lynch. But as the day drew to a close a lier was revealed amongst the ranks. AngryPixel was attacked from all angles, he had no escape. Hedger decided to deal the hammer blow, throwing him over the large walls that scaled the city.

AngryPixel was:

Denethor, Steward of Gondor, Cult-aligned.

However, amidst all the discussion one character decided to take matters into his own hands. Whilst no one was looking he crept up behind a lone figure and slit his throat, before returning to the pack. Nobody had noticed either of them disappear.

It wasn't until night fell that the body was discovered by barmyarmy. The body was that of MaD.

MaD was:

Gothmog, Leader of the Armies, Mafia-aligned.

It is now Night. Please send in your roles via PM to myself and PSquared.​

 

[barmyarmy]

Wow. Either AP had a one kill when lynched or we have a daytime SK. Either way brilliant news for the town.

 

[Zohaib]

Awesome a mafia died