Lord of the Rings Mafia - Town wins

[Spoobir]

Well I guess we should wait for the accused to post.

Unlych: CG123
(So Chewie can't hammer him)

----------

Unlynch: CG123
(In case people want to get nitpicky about typos :P)

----------

Unlynch: CG123
(So I failed at unlynching twice, shut up! )

 

[BKB1991]

Smurf it could be that the roles were copied from wikipedia itself so thats not saying much imo

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Smurf it could be that the roles were copied from wikipedia itself so thats not saying much imo

I know, but Chewie's the most suspicous for me. If I'm wrong, then it's Callum.

Unless we're all way ofcourse and it turns out it was Colin all along, abusing his mod powers to make it seem like he's dead

 

[6ry4nj]

Isn't Chewie just as likely to be Gollum? He could even be town, and Gollum be a figment of the imagination of the imaginary Shelob...

Chewie hasn't helped us one tiny bit - in fact he's hardly been here - and deserves to be dead, but Callum has dug himself a hole and been caught doing so. I'd like to be sure I was getting Saruman today, so if you have any evidence that paints Chewie as the scummier one, please post it.

Elrond is strengthened considerably as a claim by Arwen being in the game.

 

[barmyarmy]

Now, for the night. I just wish that the mafia kill me and not some experienced player. It would help a lot.

With the Dark Lord dead, he was carrying out his former master's duty tonight. Slowly he crept up behind the man who was responsible for the deaths of friend and foe alike, and killed him.

Sachinfan98 was -

Aragorn, Strider, Town-aligned

Gah... WTH? Just cursed my luck I think.

Ghost Post

Just to say that I find this hilarious.

 

[CG123]

Yes I'm Gollum, my win condition is to survive. I had a one time lie-detector as well as the one time roleblock I mentioned earlier, and I used the lie-detector on one of Zohaib's posts when he said he was town, and it came back false.

I didn't really want to claim Gollum because of the SK accusations, so I decided to claim Shelob and say Zohaib was Gollum in order to get rid of Zohaib because I knew he'd need to die in order for the town (and me) to win.

Yes I've dug myself into somewhat of a hole, but I struggle to see why you're lynching my off ahead of someone who's pretty much confirmed cult (Zohaib), and someone who's pretty much confirmed mafia (Chewie).

Is all Chewie's really done is jumped on bandwagons the whole game, he hasn't been any help to you guys, and he's given off no pro-town vibes. Again his latest post fits this bill.

I only hope you guys make the right call. I'm not going to be any harm to the town if you wait another day to kill me (which you don't even need to do to win), while you could be giving Chewie more kills, and possibly Zohaib a chance to do something. Not to mention I've actually tried to help the town with some of my analysis, while both Chewie and Zohaib have done nothing towards your cause.

You even said it yourself 6ry4nj; "Chewie hasn't helped us one tiny bit - in fact he's hardly been here - and deserves to be dead", so I'm not sure why you're going after me so much when it seems clear that he's the final mafia member.

Lynch: Chewie

We can then go after Zohaib tomorrow, and then we'll all win, except maybe Hedger unless someone heals him because I assume he got poisoned last night going on the write-up.

And may I add Zohaib's been posting crap the whole last few pages which BKB has confirmed, so I'm not sure why you're using what I said against him as a reason to lynch me.

 

[Chewie]

I would like to point out that much of everyone's reasoning on me is simply because I haven't been active or contributing, or that I have been jumping on bandwagons, which is pretty untrue.

I didn't jump on the day 1 bandwagon, and I started the bandwagon on day 2 for Zohaib, but that didn't get too far. I did kinda bandwagon jump for Tom and Varun, but I believe I was one of the first to vote for Varun.

@Spoobir, you're unlynch Callum because you're scared of me hammering him when I've already voted to lynch him...

Simple rule of mafia games is lynch all liars. I'm still not convinced by Callum, and he still is going on about Zohaib not being townie even though it's been shown he's Faramir.

 

[CG123]

I would like to point out that much of everyone's reasoning on me is simply because I haven't been active or contributing, or that I have been jumping on bandwagons, which is pretty untrue.

I didn't jump on the day 1 bandwagon, and I started the bandwagon on day 2 for Zohaib, but that didn't get too far. I did kinda bandwagon jump for Tom and Varun, but I believe I was one of the first to vote for Varun.

Two townies have been lynched in this game, Yudi and Tom. You lynched them 6th and 4th respectively, I didn't lynch either of them.

Simple rule of mafia games is lynch all liars.

It was only time before someone brought up that stupid rule. I also lied in Pokemon mafia which set-up the game for the town, because we went on to kill five mafia in a row.

I'm still not convinced by Callum, and he still is going on about Zohaib not being townie even though it's been shown he's Faramir.

You're obviously not following this game at all, BKB said; "Zohaib is related to the cult, exact words of PSquared." I knew he was lying all along which is why I've been saying what I have for the past day and a half, so that's why I'm; "going on about Zohaib not being townie".....

 

[Zohaib]

Two townies have been lynched in this game, Yudi and Tom. You lynched them 6th and 4th respectively, I didn't lynch either of them.

mate if you playing it that way, I havent lynched anyone except mafias, it doesnt work like that

Assuming you're Gollum and you should have killing powers, right?

Kill either one of Hedger or chewie if they arent lynched today, you said you were trying to help the town right, so why not help us and kil them

----------

Yes I'm Gollum, my win condition is to survive. I had a one time lie-detector as well as the one time roleblock I mentioned earlier, and I used the lie-detector on one of Zohaib's posts when he said he was town, and it came back false.

Anyone have a lie detector for this post?

Mate how come you are only going after me know when I had role claimed quite a few nights ago, if you used the lie-detector, you would be constantly after me from the time I role claimed but it wasnt the case, you're just going after me to kill an innocent townie hence you can win, you're not trying to help the town

And you just made that up like chewie said BKB confirmed I am a townie


I say lynch callum then that leaves us with 2 mafia's or rather one if we go back and look at the write up where it says that they were 2 left and one has died already

 

[6ry4nj]

It was only time before someone brought up that stupid rule. I also lied in Pokemon mafia which set-up the game for the town, because we went on to kill five mafia in a row.

More anti-town misdirection. How can you compare lying to help the town with the lying and evasion that you are continuing to do here?

Does anyone have actual evidence that Callum is not Saruman? If not, it's a choice between the helpful non-town liar and the unhelpful might-be-town keeping below the radar. In which case surely Callum has more telling strikes against him.

----------

BKB said; "Zohaib is related to the cult, exact words of PSquared."

Zohaib has claimed as Faramir, and this has been confirmed. He is Boromir's brother and Denethor's son, thus 'related to the cult'. It is only weak and ambiguous evidence against him being a townie.

 

[CG123]

Meh, I misunderstood what BKB meant. It went straight over me that they actually are "related", I was thinking they were related as in he was cult like they were.

Tbh I'm fighting a lost cause, I'm mafia.

FTR I'm not Saruman as well.

I take it the edit doesn't really matter at this stage, I just rewrote the top part to make more sense.

 

[Zohaib]

Ok so you're mafia, and then that leaves Chewie or Hedger to be Gollum and one mafia

Town well on their way to winning

 

[6ry4nj]

FTR I'm not Saruman as well.

If that's true (big if!), you're still the other and more potent mafia killer (Sauron's backup). And should be our first target, town.

 

[CG123]

If that's true (big if!), you're still the other and more potent mafia killer (Sauron's backup). And should be our first target, town.

So you still think I'm lying, wow...
Why would I lie about my character when it's going to get revealed when I get lynched?

----------

Ok so you're mafia

No I'm not, I just claimed mafia because I thought it would be fun.

 

[Zohaib]

Nah still you're anti town, you're not trying to help the town in anyway, like you're coming after me after I was a confirmed townie