Melbourne Bitters 06/07 Team Thread

[brad352]

When it comes down to it, whos on top of carlton (apart from everyone) and geelong????? is it collingwood?? i think it is

And who's on top of everyone bar the team they've beaten twice?

 

[rickyp]

Adelaide?

 

[smssia0112]

is he still killing people? ok i know that was too far but i dont care

Actually that was too far and I do take offense to that one. And I am not joking. It is not a crime to get wasted, and he may be an idiot to have done it in the first place but so is she. It's stupid comments like that that set him back, when people stop him from getting on with his life.

 

[rickyp]

hes a drop kick of a person and quite frankly he doesnt deserve to be in the hall of fame with a life outside the game like that, granted it wasnt his fault, he was still in the situation

 

[smssia0112]

hes a drop kick of a person and quite frankly he doesnt deserve to be in the hall of fame with a life outside the game like that, granted it wasnt his fault, he was still in the situation

So the greatest player of the game shouldn't be let in the hall of fame because of incidents that do not involve his football? Do you think no one else has had a bad life? Footballers are put into the spotlight too much of their personal lives. The media should mind their own businesses.

 

[rickyp]

this isnt comparable to anything any other player has ever done

 

[Simbazz]

Sorry guys bout not posting much in here, :crying the topics i couldnt take part in purely because its about Aussie youngster, god i couldnt talk about English ones lol, anyways i thought id drop by and let you know im still around

 

[smssia0112]

this isnt comparable to anything any other player has ever done

Yes well it's also nothing to do with his footy. I'm saying let the guy work his own life and keep football where it belongs, at the football. His personal life should not be included in the Football Hall of Fame selection process.

 

[rickyp]

Without limiting clause 5.1, the Committee may consider a candidate?s individual record, ability, integrity, sportsmanship and character.

His personal life comes under the criteria for selection of Hall of Fame

 

[smssia0112]

His personal life comes under the criteria for selection of Hall of Fame

Most of which should be restricted to playing, and while it does make up some part of the selection, he is one of the greatest to ever play our game and if he played for collingwood you would want him in too.

 

[rickyp]

No I certainly wouldnt, he shouldnt be selected for the hall of fame simply because people in the hall of fame are role models, which is why there is that clause in the criteria to make sure people like him dont get in.

 

[Simbazz]

2 days till the first game of the season, when will we get to know the teams, hope i make it after my crap proformance in the last game!

 

[rickyp]

lol you will be in the team if you keep the posting up. Speaking of which guys, we are slowing down our chase on the Warriors, we were less than 50 away a few days ago now its 54!!!

CMON GUYS!!! lets beat them by the end of our first game

 

[smssia0112]

No I certainly wouldnt, he shouldnt be selected for the hall of fame simply because people in the hall of fame are role models, which is why there is that clause in the criteria to make sure people like him dont get in.

You don't know that, do you think Tarrant should have played after his late night brawl?

And anyway, we should probably shy away from this as it will go on forever, but it is using up posts Besides, he is in and that is that.

 

[rickyp]

gday everyone, just got back from my girls formal (packed it in early I know!) and i swear i saw a little duffman running around there! maybe a bit of verification is needed here duff?