PC Graphics Maker Championship Season 8 | Final Round - R#10 Results + Season Summary!

[Meet]

Congrats Apsamrit and all those who have participated
Hey KBC- few total errors, not few actually many:P

Send2yaari:
Entry 1:
Ava: 1.5
Sig: 4
Total: 5.5/10

__
KBC:
entry 1:
avatar: 1/3
signature: 3/7
total: 4/7

OVERALL: 17.5

Overall-9.5

Send2yaari:
Entry 4:
Ava: 2.5
Sig: 6.6 6.5
Total: 9/10
Comment: Only deducted points because of too much blurring otherwise a perfect entry.
__

KBC:
Entry 4:
avatar: 2.5/3
signature: 4.5/7
total: 7/10

OVERALL: 16

Send2yaari:
Entry 17:
Ava: 2.5
Sig: 6
Total: 8.5/10

__

KBC:
entry 17:
avatar: 2.5/3
signature: 5/7
Total: 7.5
comment: All great stuff put in place in there. You can consider excused for the bland blending near the render but nothing to worry. Keep it cool next time. Watch every bit of your work. Well done.

OVERALL: 15.5

Overall- 16

Send2yaari:
Entry 13:
Ava: 2
Sig: 4.5
Total: 6.5/10

__

KBC:
entry 13:
avatar: 2/3
signature: 4.5/7
Total: 6.5
comment: Great concept, great elements, balanced colors. Few bits have gone out of sight that should've been masked properly but overall good work. Nice stuff.

OVERALL: 12.5

Overall-13

 

[APS]

Congrats to everyone who participated.Hey kbc i got total 16 points 7.5+8.5=16

 

[Monzi]

I am really disappointed with ratings,poor judgement from the judges.

 

[Dipak]

Wohhoooo!!!
Though I didn't come first I am elated that the judges chose my Entry over VViral's and Monzi's. I never expected that I would get good marks for the siggie, but expected more from the avatar

 

[Viral Shah]

I am really disappointed with ratings,poor judgement from the judges.

Have to say but i agree with Monzi here.

 

[Gaurav_7]

I didn't think my entry was that poor. Seems people like more amount of flair and stuff rather than simplicity and basics.

 

[Monzi]

I didn't think my entry was that poor. Seems people like more amount of flair and stuff rather than simplicity and basics.

Hmm...I agree with you,Even Cheapest Piece of art got better ratings.,If that is the case then everyone should do graphics in simplicity,then rather than trying to things.

 

[Dipak]

User's entry was good IMO. What's the time limit for submitting our entry

 

[Viral Shah]

I didn't think my entry was that poor. Seems people like more amount of flair and stuff rather than simplicity and basics.

If they like that flair stuff than they should have given me and monzi more points.

On a serious note i think some entries which are ahead of me in points are really not that good in basics and than also got points. Anyways congrats to top 5.

 

[puneet28]

I am last

Btw... Do some editing on first page.... Its Puneet not Punnet

I don't know the basis of judgement..... A entry too simple, just brush used got more points than me... don't know what they wanted.... simplicity or fanciness ?

 

[Aoun13]

Congrats Apsamrit and all those who have participated
Hey KBC- few total errors, not few actually many:P

Overall-9.5


Overall- 16
Overall-13

Actually he accidentally put entry 1 marks instead of entry 7 as Apsamrit entry was entry 7.

 

[Gaurav_7]

S2Y - Do you like Yuvraj Singh?

 

[KBC]

ah bull.. Expected that. Off i go in a blink.

In the immortal words of Virat kolhi. Shaite happens.

 

[Aoun13]

S2Y - Do you like Yuvraj Singh?

Well yes when he is not against Pakistan. By the way I do not judge any entry on my personal likeness.
I judged all the entries on the basis of these basic points.

1. Art looks more fresh and cool to eyes. I mean first impression is always last impression.
2. Use of Photoshop tools.
3. Concept.
4. Implementation of concept and PS tools.
5. Whether he tried something original or tried to copy an already created signature.
6. Although there are also other points like text and inbuilt typography, render blending, use of colors etc etc but above are pretty basic.

------------------------------
Now specific to your entry. Actually you tried something to implement on the art but what it was I am not sure. Your entry was not very fresh to eyes, it was like you have burned your signature way too much plus if you are going to make a signature with that kind of effect then you must have to put lots of textures and effects so that it all blends well into the bg. You have sharpened your signature way too much plus BG is too empty. There is no light effects which is necessary with this kind of art. Text in Avatar is just random and face is not as clear as it should be.

I guess if you instead criticizing the judgment, try to get positives from this competition then you can improve a lot. I am not going to give a bias judgment but I'll always give points on what I feel about the entry.

If you want further help about your art work you are most welcome to PM me.
Hope it will satisfy you.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Actually you tried something to implement on the art but what it was I am not sure. Your entry was not very fresh to eyes, it was like you have burned your signature way too much plus if you are going to make a signature with that kind of effect then you must have to put lots of textures and effects so that it all blends well into the bg. You have sharpened your signature way too much plus BG is too empty. There is no light effects which is necessary with this kind of art. Text in Avatar is just random and face is not as clear as it should be.

1)I didn't use the 'burn' tool even once.
2)If you think using many textures is what it takes to blend a render into a bg, I'm afraid you're wrong.
3)Again, I never sharpened the sig.
4)I've used lighting effects all the way.

Whatever you said is exactly the opposite of what I did. I don't care about the points and stuff but, I just said my entry was better.