Scooby Doo Mafia - ARay Wins!
- Thread starter Gaurav_7
- Start date
Wow, because I was hoping you'd come to your senses. All of us townies find lots of people suspicious right now. You picked me to put your lynch on. Whatever!
And if you're not a townie, then it's hardly surprising you put your lynch on one.
----------
I don't have any privileged info (or any way of getting some), but thanks for the vote of confidence in me being town.
The previous mafia game run by User2010 was PlanetCricket mafia. In post #877 of that thread (on page 59), you will find a description of how the 'bus driver' role worked. Scroll down to the role description of the character called "MaD". Yes to make it even more confusing, the characters in that game were users here on PlanetCricket.
Okay, I will have to disagree with this. The reason being, the bus driver could have possible switched two innocent targets and the kill got switched OR it could be that one of the target is the godfather and one innocent target (power role), in that case the kill gets switched as well. And I believe its next to impossible for a bus driver to figure out which it is i.e the first situation or the second situation.
wth Yudi
I don't see why he would play like that...
----------
On second thought, could he have been forced to do it?
Although in games where there's the forced lynch thing, aren't the members still allowed to say other stuff?
----------
Actually just checked Harry Potter Mafia and the players were silent except for saying what the curser wanted them to say.
----------
But they could say more than a lynch so I 'unno, shall I hammer?
An interesting quote by maD. Does this mean he is mafia since he defended a mafia? Perhaps. It definitely is a suspicious quote. However, it was also a sort of bold outright defense which most mafia members would shy away from.
Lynch:MaD
I want to hear what he as to say.
Another thing which I found out while reading the entire thread again is how quickly sachinfan is completely out of the picture.
I noticed that he defended himself while he was under pressure and then stopped posting once he was out of it.
Another mafia maybe?
Actually you know what, Yudi was quite inactive like sachinfan is.
Unlynch:MaD
Lynch SachinFan
This does not mean MaD is innocent but i feel like the inactivity of sachinfan is more of a concern. I want to hear him post more, he has also so far been useless in this game and once had major suspicion on him.
Dr. Pepper
Chairman of Selectors
Zohaib, sachinfan and MaD are the ones I'm suspicious of at the moment. Sachinfan is posting occasionally but he's slipping under the radar a bit. I'm going to join in with the pressure on him for now.
Lynch: Sachinfan
Lynch: Sachinfan
It seems most likely that the bus driver (who must be town) would swap the most useful pro-town player (in his opinion) with the player least useful to the town as he sees it. The writeup doesn't specify whether or not the godfather was going for the same target both nights. Anyway, most likely scenario is that the godfather and the bus driver have the same idea about who the most useful pro-town player is, and both targeted him both nights. Note that the bus driver can target the same people every night without restriction (unless they're dead of course).
So I'm agreeing with ARay, although it is of course possible that (and would be helpful to the town if) the bus driver had swapped the godfather, and thus knew/suspected his identity.
Near
Club Cricketer
Hmm, tbh I'm not sure on MaD. I just don't get the point to stall the votes for someone like Yudi who pretty much hammered on himself.
And, the busdriver thing, the time when I was a busdriver I could pick two people and the actions done to them would be reversed, not the action they're doin lol. But again, this is a diff game so the busdriver this time might be double or reverse.
Also, from the night writeup I kinda have the feeling that the 'duo-guests' are third party for the 'their target' in the writeup
Also, it's kinda surprisin that the killer isn't mentioned in this writeup, lol what could've happened to him?
And, right now I think Sachinfan is a better lynch than MaD, it's like he only comes here to defend himself and nothing else. Also, I want to see what he thinks about MaD. So,
Lynch: Sachinfan98
Reason: Pressurizin him to post
lol, but the only thing Sachinfan's done uptil now is defend himself, I don't really remember him doing anything else.@hedger - Just statin' the facts, Sachinfan has been fairly active, more then you in fact
And, the busdriver thing, the time when I was a busdriver I could pick two people and the actions done to them would be reversed, not the action they're doin lol. But again, this is a diff game so the busdriver this time might be double or reverse.
Also, from the night writeup I kinda have the feeling that the 'duo-guests' are third party for the 'their target' in the writeup
Also, it's kinda surprisin that the killer isn't mentioned in this writeup, lol what could've happened to him?
And, right now I think Sachinfan is a better lynch than MaD, it's like he only comes here to defend himself and nothing else. Also, I want to see what he thinks about MaD. So,
Lynch: Sachinfan98
Reason: Pressurizin him to post
Here is the problem though. The bus driver has to be smart about his role. Like honestly he could do harm because the cop will never be able to be sure of his results. Nothing is more frustrating than trying to investigate someone and realise that you are not sure if the investigation is right.
hedger_14
ICC Chairman
I'm with Spoobir, I was meant to bring that post up as well but I couldn't find it and I couldn't be bothered going to the post count things and seeing his posts. Just trying to put some doubt into others minds about Yudi.
Lynch: MaD
Lynch: MaD
Well tbh I said I wasn't going to be very active when I reluctantly (
) replaced whoever I did. I've only come on PC once on each of the last three days, so there's not really much I can do. I have however posted every time I've come on, which has been one post a day since I joined the game.Like I said yesterday Sachinfan98 is going to be the least help imo, so I'm going to lynch him. Yes it appears I'm jumping on the bandwagon, but I was the first one to lynch him yesterday.
Lynch: Sachinfan98
I'm not sure what to make of MaD. He's normally quite an aggressive player, so I don't really have a problem with him lynching me. I'm not sure why he would have tried to rally with Yudi so late in the piece though if they are teammates. Yudi was useless anyway, so it would seem stupid of MaD to try and save him when he's not going to be any help to the mafia.
Zohaib's posting is just what it (along with some others) normally is. It's hard to make sense of what they're saying, and while they know the gist of the game they continue to struggle to make sense of stuff. At least he's making an effort to contribute, and because of that I'm not really suspicious of him.
P Squared's and Zohaib's lycnhes on 6ry4nj and Chewie respectively just seem to be for random reasons, so I don't really have anything to say on either of them.
MaD
Chairman of Selectors
- Joined
- Dec 19, 2008
- Location
- Sydney, Australia
I'm not one to rush any lynches, especially if we've got heaps of time.
I didn't really see why Yudi would just pretend to be silenced, it seemed most probable that he was actually silenced, he was going to be lynched anyway and I wasn't going to hammer that early.
And I don't really see why we're going for Sachinfan, he hasn't seemed scummy to me, he's been fairly active, he's at least trying to make posts and really he's had pointless accusations on him the whole game, unless I missed something, which I think I did, in which case someone should point it out to me.
I didn't really see why Yudi would just pretend to be silenced, it seemed most probable that he was actually silenced, he was going to be lynched anyway and I wasn't going to hammer that early.
And I don't really see why we're going for Sachinfan, he hasn't seemed scummy to me, he's been fairly active, he's at least trying to make posts and really he's had pointless accusations on him the whole game, unless I missed something, which I think I did, in which case someone should point it out to me.
Could you please point out one useful post made by him MaD?
Infact while you are at it, I would like you to tell me. What do you think of the game situation so far?
I would like your views on Zohaib, Papa smurf and Chewie?
Is there anyone besides CG who is under your radar?
Quite interested to know your opinion.
MaD
Chairman of Selectors
- Joined
- Dec 19, 2008
- Location
- Sydney, Australia
He hasn't really helped, but he is being fairly serious, not many people have helped anyway.
Do you guys want a roleclaim from him or what?
He's been lynched since the beginning and that's annoyed him I believe.
And CG is not 'under my radar' I pressure lynched him because he was inactive and apparently that's why people were lynching Sachinfan, which isn't really a fair accusation since he has been fairly more active than other people. I'm not ruling him out being Mafia, I'm just looking for a reason to why people are sus of him.
Smurf is giving me pro-town vibes
Chewie can be hard to read although I do agree with Zohaib that that post of his seems like he's pissed at the bus driver, when the bus driver is making things harder for the Mafia. I myself have posted a post like Chewie's when I was Mafia since I was annoyed at the bus driver.
Not sure about Zohaib he doesn't seem too scummy and I think he is trying to get some discussion going and has been fairly active so right now he seems pro-town.
Do you guys want a roleclaim from him or what?
He's been lynched since the beginning and that's annoyed him I believe.
And CG is not 'under my radar' I pressure lynched him because he was inactive and apparently that's why people were lynching Sachinfan, which isn't really a fair accusation since he has been fairly more active than other people. I'm not ruling him out being Mafia, I'm just looking for a reason to why people are sus of him.
Smurf is giving me pro-town vibes
Chewie can be hard to read although I do agree with Zohaib that that post of his seems like he's pissed at the bus driver, when the bus driver is making things harder for the Mafia. I myself have posted a post like Chewie's when I was Mafia since I was annoyed at the bus driver.
Not sure about Zohaib he doesn't seem too scummy and I think he is trying to get some discussion going and has been fairly active so right now he seems pro-town.
Sachinfan98
School Cricketer
Gah ... It becomes really hard to defend yourself once everyone is just convinced that you am not of any use. Actually, I don't even think I have to really defend in this situation. I see a mafia jumping on my bandwagon soon.
---
Didn't actually get time to post much, but I've been reading somewhat of the thread. All I can make out is that there are players even more inactive than me, and we haven't even noticed it. I definitely will not roleclaim right now. Its not just that every new player is useless.
---
The night write-up analysis is already posted by skilled players so I have nothing to add although I am really confused on this bus driver issue.
---
Didn't actually get time to post much, but I've been reading somewhat of the thread. All I can make out is that there are players even more inactive than me, and we haven't even noticed it. I definitely will not roleclaim right now. Its not just that every new player is useless.
---
The night write-up analysis is already posted by skilled players so I have nothing to add although I am really confused on this bus driver issue.
Similar threads
