Scooby Doo Mafia - ARay Wins!

[Gaurav_7]

Vote Count

Dr. Pepper (3) - CG123, hedger_14, Spoobir
Spoobir (2) - Varun, MaD
Chewie (2) - Zohaib, ARay

With 14 alive, it takes 8 for a lynch.

 

[6ry4nj]

Finally some pressure on someone I think deserves it. No way I'm following Zohaib and ARay on a bandwagon, and I hesitated re Varun's too. But

Lynch: Dr. Pepper

He was on my latest 'watch list', and I agree that Brendon gives very pro-town vibes.

 

[hedger_14]

I agree that Brendon gives very pro-town vibes

Can I ask who you're agreeing with, lol?

 

[6ry4nj]

Can I ask who you're agreeing with, lol?

I don't wish to reinforce that statement any further - especially as it sounds like you yourself are inclined to disagree You don't have to check back very far to find what I'm referring to.

 

[Chewie]

I for one don't think Dr Pepper's given off scummy vibes. Yes he was on the bandwagons but I feel that they were perfectly valid reasons for doing so.

 

[6ry4nj]

I for one don't think Dr Pepper's given off scummy vibes. Yes he was on the bandwagons but I feel that they were perfectly valid reasons for doing so.

There were valid reasons for being on those bandwagons. It was a bit suspicious, however, that his initial response to being called on it was basically "yes I suppose that does make me look guilty doesn't it". He only came up with the good reasons after I had.

Still, I'm not entirely comfortable on this bandwagon. Why not start one of your own - I may join you. Particularly if it's on one of my prime suspects...

 

[Dr. Pepper]

Did I lynch Zohaib?

No.

Why?



You FOSed me with false information, while you infact were one of only two players to lynch both Sachinfan and Zohaib.

That's the first scummy thing I've picked up, so I think you deserve a lynch. I'm not really sure if you're mafia, but the day's fast running out and I don't really have anything else to go on.

Lynch: Dr. Pepper

IIRC I didn't lynch Yudi because of the timezones and my inactivity. For obvious reasons I assume would have lynched him if I was online at the time when everyone else started doing so. Since I'm only coming on once a day atm, I might have not lynched him straightway because there was still plenty of time left in the day, and when I next came on I think he'd just been hammered.

And as I said before I was the first person to lynch Sachinfan yesterday, so I didn't really jump on the bandwagon considering I was one of the first ones who really brought him up (yesterday). Yes that was an oversight on my perspective, but his poor play had many of you thinking he was mafia as well, so that can't really count against me.

Sorry about that. When I was reading the vote count from that page, for some reason I read your name on it. No idea why.

Not really sure how to respond to this. I gave my reasons for lynching sachinfan and Zohaib, and I thought they were legit. Not really sure what else to say.

----------

Yeah that makes me look pretty bad.

I took a chance on both and unfortunately neither paid off, but at least it's stimulated a lot more discussion. Zohaib didn't really help himself though with his posting, put a lot of suspicion on himself by just making strange posts.

That was my initial response. I don't see how it wasn't a valid reason, it was basically what I put afterwards, just went into more depth afterwards.

 

[ARay]

ARay and Callum, what are your thoughts on Spoobir's play?

For me personally, I think Spoobir is playing aright. I really dont feel like any of his posts stand out as much. But I feel like he is nudging everyone in his own way. The problem with smart players is that its hard to decipher them early on in the game.

I see a bandwagon growing for Dr pepper.
So here is my question for all of you guys pressuring him? What if he role claims another power role? What is your next course of action going to be?
Go for another lynch on someone else? Until you find out every single role?
What are your plans if a proposed power role decides to fake claim- So you end up in a situation where you are not sure if he mafia or a power role in hiding? How do you plan on going about? Do you lynch because he lied about his role?

I am interested to know a few of these things and I would like you guys to be as detailed as possible.

I am quite interested to know

 

[Spoobir]

For me personally, I think Spoobir is playing aright. I really dont feel like any of his posts stand out as much. But I feel like he is nudging everyone in his own way. The problem with smart players is that its hard to decipher them early on in the game.

I see a bandwagon growing for Dr pepper.
So here is my question for all of you guys pressuring him? What if he role claims another power role? What is your next course of action going to be?
Go for another lynch on someone else? Until you find out every single role?
What are your plans if a proposed power role decides to fake claim- So you end up in a situation where you are not sure if he mafia or a power role in hiding? How do you plan on going about? Do you lynch because he lied about his role?

I am interested to know a few of these things and I would like you guys to be as detailed as possible.

I am quite interested to know

Or, too look at it another way, I'm interested to know what you think we should be doing instead of lynching and pressurising people? Maybe sit around and wait for the mafia to come forward and admit it?

 

[6ry4nj]

In case any townies are getting discouraged (constant negativity from 'Uncle' ARay while posing as our mentor can't be helping), consider this. In the last game (LOTR), by day 3, town had lynched two vanilla townies and killed their own doctor. And town won! We're not doing badly at all!

Also in that game, Frodo (the major character) was forced to character-claim early - but he was only a Commuter, so not a power role in the sense of a prime target for the mafia.

----------

Unlynch: Dr. Pepper
Lynch: ARay

I'm told he's a smart player, but instead of analysis, we get "biryani", then the anti-town rant, followed by this attempt to gather info useful to the mafia.

 

[Chewie]

I actually agree with 6ry4nj's analysis of ARay. In all games I've played with him, he seems to take the Colin stance in that he kinda directs the flow of play as he pleases, and by doing so takes attention away from himself. It should be remembered that he is normally one of the first to be killed by the mafia, yet he is still around...

FOS: ARay

 

[barmyarmy]

I think it would be more accurate to say that I took the ARay stance rather than vice versa

 

[MaD]

Yeah but you wanna keep in mind that the Mafia's kills have been busdrivered.
I agree with your point Ray, but there's nothing else we can really do, so we have to keep pushing on...
Dr Pepper hasn't seemed scummy to me, but its not like I'm god...

 

[ARay]

Or, too look at it another way, I'm interested to know what you think we should be doing instead of lynching and pressurising people? Maybe sit around and wait for the mafia to come forward and admit it?

By all means do what you have to, I am more interested in what answers you give to my posts. Its all a part of the discussion I am trying to develop here. The reason for doing so is because the more people post, the more it helps people later on in the game.
I know I wont be here for sure by the end of the game. However the points I raise and peoples' response for the issue will be there for everyone to see.
That is what I am trying to achieve.

[/COLOR]Unlynch: Dr. Pepper
Lynch: ARay

I'm told he's a smart player, but instead of analysis, we get "biryani", then the anti-town rant, followed by this attempt to gather info useful to the mafia.

I really do not know what sort of analysis you are looking for. I have already settled on my lynch for today. Perhaps you should read all of my posts before coming up with such meaningless posts.
I shall play how I always play, because I feel discussing all opinions in this game is the key to winning. If I have to face the wrath of the town, so be it.

----------

I think it would be more accurate to say that I took the ARay stance rather than vice versa

I should say though, you played extremely well for the fact that it was your first game

 

[CG123]

Well I might as well unlynch Dr. Pepper since no one else is really suspicious of him. I mainly lynched him because of his false accusations on me, but none of you have even mentioned that after me.

Unlynch: Dr. Pepper