"See how many we get" mafia - Endgame. BKB1991, mafia, wins

[puddleduck]

We could really do with one of User or BKB being online. I am not sold on Bkb's claim at all and I'm worried Themer will be taking me out if he's lynched, but I've had a hunch he's mafia even when he was Mark.

So I guess we either go to 4 with Sim and find out if his claim is genuine or we wait, accept a no lynch and hopefully make progress tomorrow?

 

[Sedition]

If Sim will put his lynch on Themer and someone turns up to hammer it, I'm obviously all for it. Since it doesn't seem likely, it's better to lynch Sim than no-one.

Lynch: Themer obviously unless day is ending like right now.

 

[simsanta123]

The only reason I still think Themer might not be mafia is because he once pointed out that Manly had used the Beloved Princess claim twice as mafia. Not a very strong point, but it stuck..kind of. And he even defended me a bit.
Sigh I should really stop supporting my supposed enemy.
Unlynch : User2010
Lynch : Themer

 

[puddleduck]

Lynch: Themer I guess. If he's town though, we'll be losing two town aligned people

 

[Sedition]

No one who claims that badly could be town.

 

[Themer]

Haha, I am town.

 

[barmyarmy]

Vote count

Simsanta123 - 1 (Zhuorb)
Puddleduck - 1 (Themer)
Themer - 4 (Sedition, Puddleduck, Varun, Simsanta)

5 needed to lynch.

 

[Varun]

I'd be pretty outraged if it turns out that BKB and User are mafia indeed and we have simply been wasting our time....

 

[simsanta123]

I'd be pretty outraged if it turns out that BKB and User are mafia indeed and we have simply been wasting our time....

Yeah that would be frickin bad. Somehow I feel we have reached a stage where we are just lynching for the sake of it.

----------

Its been such a long day and I guess its seeming waste to end lynchless...

 

[puddleduck]

I think that might be the case to be fair. I'm not sold on Themer or Sim being mafia.

I still think the most sensible lynch out of Themer and Sim is Sim. The fact it only takes 4 to confirm whether his role is correct or not. As well as the fact Zhuorb jailkept him makes him the logical choice.

 

[simsanta123]

How much time is left Colin?

 

[barmyarmy]

I'm getting some dinner so I'll give you til 8pm BST. About an hour.

 

[Sedition]

You just passed up the opportunity to hammer the lynch on Sim, PD. Are you not allowed to hammer or something?

 

[Varun]

I'm going off to sleep then. If Zhuorb/BKB/User come on, they can lynch Themer, else if you guys decide to go for Sim, three of you (including Themer) will suffice.

----------

You just passed up the opportunity to hammer the lynch on Sim, PD. Are you not allowed to hammer or something?

Yes, yes. How weird!

 

[simsanta123]

I still think the most sensible lynch out of Themer and Sim is Sim. The fact it only takes 4 to confirm whether his role is correct or not. As well as the fact Zhuorb jailkept him makes him the logical choice.

I honestly don't know why my jail keeping didn't lead to a kill.
I honestly am pretty surprised that you didn't hammer me PD. I really thought you were mafia.
And I honestly must put it out to you : Do you really think if I wanted to fake claim, I would have chosen Hated Townie? A role which itself implies a sort of discontent with the town. And a role which can always give rise to the temptation for a quick lynch.