I am trying really hard with my story to get the storyline, presentation and graphics all up there! And Surendar (if, like me, he could keep regularly updating) is doing a terrific story! But yes, I agree- way too many leagues. I remember as a story-reader, I used to decide which stories to read first out of those done by Highlander999, MWaugh, Shantanu_Rooney, Jarl/Jaarl (I think?!), gamerkid, Pakistani Army- the list went on. Now there are too many Cricsim/ICC stories with little substance as you say. While graphics aren't as important, there is still a real lack of quality graphics, and the writing, presentation has surely decreased in quality.
Unfortunately, all the 'greats' seemed to have moved on, although there are a couple of stories out there that might just step up.
Speaking for myself, I know my story will take some months to complete, the way I have it mapped out. Hopefully I will continue to have the time and patience to keep improving!