Survivor Mafia - End Game (Town Win)

[CG123]

@Callum: Can I please know your thoughts on Aditya, Spoobir and Abhas?

Aditya - As I've said before I haven't read too much into him. The stuff he's said I tend to agree with, like I wouldn't lynch an experienced player randomly on day one, but I'm more than happy to lynch a newer player on day one. In saying that though if someone makes a mistake or what not, I'm going to lynch then no matter who they are.

Spoobir - Tbh he never really seems to be that active early on. I don't think he's done that much analysis on the game, which always makes someone a possibility of being mafia. Like Aditya, he hasn't done enough for me to lynch him atm, as he could be of value later on.

Abhas - Again, similar to Spoobir. He normally tends to become more helpful later on, when he has more information to work with. In saying that though he hasn't really been that active this game, but I haven't really noticed in difference in how he plays when he's mafia and town anyway.

Not really sure on any of them though, I know that's not very helpful. I'd definitely want to keep Abhas around for the time being though, because of his late game value IF he is a townie. Aditya/Spoobir, I'm none the wiser on either them, I guess the value that Aditya brings to the table is he's showing a lot more activity than Spoobir is atm.

This game is just pissing me off tbh. Lack of discussion and poor play at its very best.

There's not much point on calling it poor play because some of us are lynching you atm, saying that if anything just draws more attention to yourself. I have to agree with you that there is a lack of discussion though.

For the time being:

Unlynch: Yudi

Just because he's got quite a few lynches atm.

 

[Aditya]

Aditya - As I've said before I haven't read too much into him. The stuff he's said I tend to agree with, like I wouldn't lynch an experienced player randomly on day one, but I'm more than happy to lynch a newer player on day one. In saying that though if someone makes a mistake or what not, I'm going to lynch then no matter who they are.

Who wont do that? That's what my point is, a mistake is enough to get you lynched and what mistake did I do to get lynched? Just said that it's better to lynch newbies on day 1 rather than experienced players. On day 1, you really don't expect to get much evidences and so lynching any experienced member can be dangerous, until and unless he has done something very suspicious.

----------

Unlynch : User

 

[Gaurav_7]

Anyone to enlighten me on what is going on? Last post of mine...

 

[MaD]

Just read the posts from the Night 1 write-up, it's hard to explain, you need to figure out for yourself what you want to believe

 

[ARay]

Anyone to enlighten me on what is going on? Last post of mine...

I have been away for a while and I come back to see we still have yet to arrive at conclusion.

So hear is the summary of what has happened.
So day 1, I decide to go with a random vote, few people follow me into random votes. No one decides to discuss anything at all. Aditya decides he wants a lynch on an inexperienced member like bevab rather than experienced member like Spoobir (My opinion it did looked like aditya was sort of defending spoobir)

Yudi says that he wants a no lynch since there is no evidence and he is willing to wait until it arrives (my opinion clearly lacking direction and if we follow his method this game will just die out due to lack of activity).
Day 1 ends with a no lynch.

Night 1, Afridirulez dies. Abhas makes an interesting post stating that Mafia failed in their lynch -[ even though there is no evidence to suggest any alignment] (my opinion he is just speculating and he said so himself later on when I asked him about it)
However Yudi ended up posting "it is obvious that serial killer was the one who did the killing" (like I said there was nothing to indicate the alignment, a post such as his could mean he made a mafia slip)

Yudi and aditya end up in a debate on how to play the game. Blaah blaaah. Then Yudi makes the most curious post which the entire town follows. Its called hypocop where everyone posts if someone is townie or mafia. Apparently its supposed to hide the cop and allow him to openly talk about his investigation. But now that I think about it, it might actually be bad idea since it might help mafia narrow down who the real cop might be.
So yudi in a way might have actually played something brilliant and we might have possibly given the cop out in a silver platter to the mafia. Ofcourse these are all my guesses, I really cannot be sure about a lot of the stuff, but I am trying to be as detailed as possible.

As for my gut instincts, I feel safe to trust CG and MaD's opinions. Both of them have given a pro-town vibe for me. But then again I cannot be too trusting since it is a mafia game. But I feel they are more likely townie than anyone else really.

And now we are pretty much without any direction at day 2.

 

[Varun]

Unlynch : User

I'm out of any opinions. We just don't have enough activity. I'm annoyed, where the hell is P#? He's just made 9 posts.

 

[Bevab]

Really? You're so sure that Sim was a townie? Or are you trying to cover him up?
Unlynch: Spoobie
Lynch: Bevab

I'm not covering sim because I myself have been against him nor did I say that Sim is a townie. TBH, you have been very aggressive towards certain players from the beginning of the game.

Still I'm feeling that you're townie.

Unlynch: Yudi

Lynch: Abhas

Reason: A cop normally does not get a result as serial-killer and even though its only hypocop, I feel he is hiding something.

 

[Aditya]

I'm just not sure who to lynch, no one really look suspicious to me.

@Yudi - You might have missed my post where I wanted you to share your thoughts on Abhas and CG. You were suspicious of Abhas on day 1, are you still suspicious of him?

 

[Varun]

A cop normally does not get a result as serial-killer and even though its only hypocop, I feel he is hiding something.

So, basically how do you know the cop in this game is a 'normal' cop? We basically don't even know if he's getting his results in the town/mafia/individual or pro-town/anti-town format.

 

[MaD]

I think you guys are being way too soft here, we NEED to get aggressive
Your response doesn't answer my question - How can you be so sure that User is a townie and will help us uncover the mafia?

 

[Bevab]

Ok I agree that I did do a mistake over there, I was overjoyed that User was joining in the game so due to that I forgot that he was replacing Sim, a very suspicious character.

Ok, like you said its time for some aggressive game-play. Abhas is obviously hiding something. He needs to speak up. There could be 3 theories here:

1)He has a powerful role and is a townie
2)He has a post restriction
3)He is anti-town

One more lynch can pressurize him a bit I guess.

 

[Abhas]

Hah! Lynching me for the farce called hypocop? I honestly didn't like the idea of this in the first place, and if its going to be hypothetical, I don't think I should make it easier for the mafia to say something that they can use to track the real cop.

Regarding your possible theories, Bevab,
1) I am town, but I'm not looking to prove it to anyone at this point of time.
2) I do not have a post restriction. I have been terribly busy with university, being my last month (15 days actually before my final-final exams start) before I close this chapter of my life. Ofcourse, having registered in this game, I should've kept that in mind, but honestly, now I can't miss the bus here just because of a game.

3) Umm.. I'm sorry, was there any other possibility left? Either I'm town, or i'm anti-town. Wow, you narrowed it down perfectly!

I wonder why you're focusing on the fact that I may have a power role? This time you've targeted me, next, you'll target some else with the same theory.. Mafia would be the most interested in knowing what roles which townies have. I can't see a town-motive in your move.

FOS: Bevab

That said, my lynch candidate is still Yudi. I'm really not happy with his hypocop move, that too at the very beginning of the game. His reluctance to take a stance is also a bit eye-raising.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Alright, read a little bit of the discussion. This game is going no where though. Yudi started the hypo thing. Was that really needed? I mean at this point of time when we're going no where, was it helpful? No. It won't just help us immediately.

Also, I feel there is something different regarding Varun's play. He doesn't seem town, I feel this. I don't know. I'd also like to know who were the people going after Sim (then). Might as well get some more clues.

I'm also suspicious of Aditya. He says, if he would have been mafia he wouldn't have killed AR. While, the night writeup actually indicates (I feel), AR was killed by SK.

 

[Bevab]

You have convinced me for the time being.

Unlynch:Abhas

The mafia are surely enjoying this day. They freely should have found out the cop, and more is to come for them due to this hypocop thing.

This day has been really useless.

Now basically I won't target all players with the same theories, its just a stupid thing to do as I want to help the town to win.

Now if there is a bus-driver in this game, claim!!!!! I'm assuring you that it'll clear a lot of confusion (only if he is there).

 

[Zohaib]

Sorry about not posting much yesterday , had to attend a wedding.

----------

You have convinced me for the time being.

Unlynch:Abhas

The mafia are surely enjoying this day. They freely should have found out the cop, and more is to come for them due to this hypocop thing.

This day has been really useless.

Now basically I won't target all players with the same theories, its just a stupid thing to do as I want to help the town to win.

Now if there is a bus-driver in this game, claim!!!!! I'm assuring you that it'll clear a lot of confusion (only if he is there).

Mate , as I said before , it is best if you dont, it is a power role

to me it seems like you trying to find all the power roles to target them.