Survivor Mafia - End Game (Town Win)

[Aditya]

As far as expanding that post is concern, my point was that Aray and Yudi were the only two members who didn't go for Bevab. Now, surprisingly Bevab went for Yudi, now the confusing part is, whether they both wanted to confuse us as Bevab was the only one to go for Yudi, knowing that if he gets killed Yudi is out of the suspicious list or this was a tactic between him and some of his fellow mafia members to make sure that once Bevab is killed, Yudi is put in the suspicious list. Both are the possibilities, I'll have a look at some of Bevab's and Spoobir's post to see if I find anything useful.

 

[Varun]

It is 5, right?

6. I mis-calculated there.

 

[CG123]

Well, the mafia godfather and the SK might appear town as well. Might. Thus, it's still an uncertainty, although you have shown brilliant commitment to the game, one can never be sure.

True. IIRC Hedger did hate that rule though when he was cop, so I don't think we would have implemented it in his own game.



I'll wait for Yudi to post his thoughts before I proceed with a lynch.

 

[Aditya]

http://www.planetcricket.org/forums/2126762-post410.html

^That is a very interesting post. Yudi was inactive and when he was back he saw that Bevab is getting lynched and changed the topic and said that he feels that Bevab and I are working together. Yudi also defends his move to defend Bevab, to get out of the suspicion. Obviously, he was looking to save his fellow mafia mate from getting lynched earlier in the game. Another interesting thing is that, when I was saying that we must not lynch a experienced player (Spoobir), Yudi was not ready to accept this, he said that I must have my theory clear between lynching a inactive member or a noob but obviously I was just bringing up the point that Sim has been very inactive and I was always in favor of lynching a noob then lynching a experienced member on day 1. Think yourself guys, how would it had been if we all would've lynched Spoobir (the cop) on day 1? Yudi was saying that I'm defending Spoobir but the truth is he didn't wanted a noob in Bevab to be lynched on day 1 and obviously why would he want Bevab to be lynched? He was his fellow mafia mate after all.

Yudi, you still haven't posted your views on Abhas and CG, I've asked you earlier as well, maybe you missed my post. Are you still suspicious of Abhas, like you were on day 1? If not, why are you not suspicious of Abhas any more? What about CG, your thoughts about his game?

 

[CG123]

Now I'm not a mafia and second of all Aditya said what was right to him, so yourself causing unnecessary confusion clearly shows that you're not a townie. And secondly I basically was busy to reply to Aditya's posts.

(from Bevab in response to Yudi)

Why would Bevab try to take Yudi down with him if Yudi is also mafia?

 

[Aditya]

That's most likely a tactic, similar to a tactic used by Papa_Smurf and Zorax. What if Yudi told Bevab to say that, so once Bevab is killed Yudi is more than likely to be safe because of that post. Like you CG, your thinking is valid, why will Bevab say that because that just gets Yudi under suspicion but at the other hand, we also think that what if Yudi is innocent. I'll just wait for Yudi to post his views and then get forward with this.

----------

Hedger, will you be replacing P#?

 

[Varun]

Aditya, do remember that Papa_Smurf was a usurper, and thus he took the great risk. If he wasn't, he wouldn't have blatantly accused Zorax.

 

[MaD]

darned we lost like the most important role, i'd rather lose 2 people than lose the cop...

Lucky we got Bevab, good thing I kept my lynch on him

I'm sure we'll be able to get something lookin through the thread

 

[Aditya]

I'm seeing that as a discussion between two mafia members. Papa_Smurf wanted Zorax to be killed (mafia god father) to have any chance of winning but and as I was also a mafia in that game along with these two, I know that the tactics that were discussed were, they'll always go after each other so that once a member is killed, the other could be safe.

 

[AbhishekS]

Damn! This is ridiculous. Good that we did the hypocop as Spoobir would have died tonight even if the hypocop wouldn't have taken place as the SK also went on to kill him.

Need you guys to expand on these posts asap please.

I think it was pretty clear to identify the guy about whom I was talking in that post. I was talking about Aditya. I felt that Aditya and Bevab planned to take me down, but now I feel I was wrong.

Firstly, Aditya defended Spoobir and now that Spoobir has turned out to be a cop, I am little less suspicious of Aditya. Another thing which struck my mind is that in a game of 13, there possibly won't be more than 4 mafias. And so the mafias won't be risking 2 guys from their alignment to attack me. Had they attacked someone like Abhas or ARay, it would have been meaningful, but I am not that strong as a player for whom the mafias would risk 2 guys

Before this night, I had decided that I'll be lynching Aditya straight away in the day phase, but Spoobir's alignment and role are making me reconsider my strategy.

The only thing which is making me think negatively on Aditya is the manner in which he has approached this game. He has been extremely aggressive towards me since the start of this game and has constantly been saying that Bevab and I (Yudi) were working together.
But I personally feel that we both were having the same thoughts earlier and felt that the other was working with Bevab to take him down. Its not that Aditya is out of my suspicion list, but I'm not that suspicious of him now as I was earlier.

Yudi, you still haven't posted your views on Abhas and CG, I've asked you earlier as well, maybe you missed my post. Are you still suspicious of Abhas, like you were on day 1? If not, why are you not suspicious of Abhas any more? What about CG, your thoughts about his game?

No, I am not suspicious of Abhas right now. I was getting suspicious of him earlier as he didn't seem to be playing in his normal way (due to exams or whatever reasons).
On Callum, I would say that the cop (Spoobir) has almost confirmed that he is a townie. I think I believe the report and feel that Callum indeed is aligned with the town and is not a godfather. He isn't a confirmed townie as yet, but amongst all the guys alive, I'm least suspicious of him.

 

[hedger_14]

Anyone want to replace p#? I can't be bothered looking for someone but if someone wants to, I'll replace them.

 

[P Squared]

I don't think I can, can I?

 

[Chewie]

You won't be able to if you were in the game before, or are me. Cos I've seen the roles.

 

[hedger_14]

Nah, sorry P. And yeah Chewie, of course you can't

 

[CG123]

Not sure what to make of this (if anything):

@CG123: Thanks for the lynch.

FOS: Bevab

Thanks for the lynch? wtf why would you thank someone for a lynch

Lynch - MaD

Taking first day lynches too seriously.

----------

I meant first day banter.

Bevab made a retarded post, so MaD had all rights to FOS him, and then Sim comes out and says that. Could possibly be a noob mafia mistake, as I'm not sure if Sim's been mafia before. Makes it a bit a bitch to try and work out though, because Sim's no longer in the game.

He was also very quick to unlynch MaD when I became suspicious of him early on, as ARay pointed out.

FOS: User (Sim)

Bevab was keen to get rid of Varun on day one, and then switched to p#, both because of inactivity. I have no idea on the alignments of both Varun and p#, but Bevab could have just been looking for some early town lynches early on if they're town.

On day one mainly based on Bevab's play I'd say at a guess that's it's more likely that Yudi would be mafia compared to Aditya, but that all depends on how deep they were playing, i.e. they may have been doing stuff so that later on it clears them up, like FOSing fellow mafia members.

----------

Scrap that last paragraph, just went over Bevab's posts again and he FOSed both Aditya and Yudi.