I don't think Tait flopping is debatable. He will flop worse than a fish out of water on those wickets. As much as I love fast bowling, I can't stand Shaun Tait, he is a useless cricketer in the longer forms. Anyone who brings up his 2007 WC record is just ignoring the fact that he has become an injury prone, wayward and virtually useless cricketer in the longer formats since.
He really should be limited to Twenty20s, there is too much proper fast bowling talent in Australia to carry him along for the ride in the hopes that he bowls out the opposition in 2 overs.
Survive the 1st 2 overs of Tait and then it's easy runs.