Search results

This was the bit where I thought that Colin said if he took a mafia role he would turn up mafia when investigated. Hhhmmmm....

My win condition was as Colin predicted, I win when the antagonists are dead.

Naa there was a point when I was thinking about taking the lynch away after our discussion had died down, but when others entered in and started asking more questions suspicion re-appeared.

Well my mind is made up and my lynch now stays.

You originally said you could take the roles of people Well, Colin did say though that if he did he would turn up mafia, and he hadn't come up mafia. So he is pretty confusing. ---------- ETA: That first line shouldn't be there because I'm not sure if you actually did or not.

Ok, answer me some questions. 1. Do you have to know which player has a role to copy it? 2. If you were to take a mafia role, would you turn up as mafia?

No, but because he knows where the mafia immunity is he can go back to it the next night.

1. You're still not town though. You're still individual aligned or as people have inferred before, maybe cult. Considering you keep banging on about you're a townie who doesn't fit in. 2. But those people also turn out to be a hindrance come crunch time, and whilst you might be an aid in...

Last time I checked, the whole of the game was to eliminate all dangers to the town or 'protagonists' in this case. So being suspicious of me because I know your not a 'protagonist' and wanting to lynch me off is a pretty poor reason. You were allowed to give your case for why you shouldn't be...

All we have is your word for that. For all we know, you could just be saying that so that we can keep you alive.

But then when it comes to crunch time you will be against us, in which case you have a major advantage because of your power to capture roles, even though it doesn't all add up to me.

Well then so be it, be suspicious but come crunch time, I don't think you will still be wanting to help the townies so much hence why I don't think you should still be here.

Well you said if you took the killing power of the mafia, you would turn up mafia when investigated. In the end your 'ability' to acquire powers could come up to harm the town, and whilst you may not be against the town now, who knows that when we get down to minimal numbers you aren't going...

lynch: barmyarmy He might not be a threat now, but I don't think he is going to keep the mafia immunity forever considering he is the shape shifter. We have someone who isn't town, so lets take them out as early as possible.

But you said you could 'shape ████' so chop and change what you are. So whilst at the moment, you aren't a threat to the town you could become one. Who says you won't take the killing power tonight if you find it? ---------- That should say 'shape shift'.

See, this is where I think you could become dangerous. What about if you had taken Darth Vader's powers last night and can use them from now on? Assuming he was the Godfather, it would mean you and the mafia now have killing powers.

How have you already taken on the mafia immunity powers? ---------- Oh yeah, good point. Although, nothing wrong with there being two cops :p. Guess the sacrifice of Bevab has done it's job now.

Question to Zohaib, if you were the cop and hadn't investigated Bevab, why would you not believe him?

I think he is basically a modified survivor.

People seem fixated on the idea that just because Barmy and Tom both came up as anti-hero, they are cult. However, in most games we have had 2 individual aligned players so not sure why that shouldn't occur here. I do, however agree that there could be a cult so finding that could be helpful...