a replay is just silly, and pure hysteria (mind you, still pales in comparison to the furore over sydney 08)
I think a world cup ban for Henry would be appropriate (either the whole thing or 3 matches). players are prepared to do anything they can get away with to win, but I think a few more would be less willing to take the bullet if they missed out. in the grand scheme of things you have to consider this has probably cost irelands economy millions.