Best Fielder?

[nash007]

I think it is Kaif, cause Jonty said he reminds him of himself. Ponting is not quite the best becoz of his age, which is beyond 30.

 

[andrew_nixon]

I'd go for Ponting at the moment, but Kaif certainly is close.

Nobody will ever be as good as Jonty Rhodes though!

 

[nash007]

Yeah, if Jonty hadnt retired the question would be, who is the 2nd best?

 

[Sanju]

I think Yuvrag An d gibbs but i will go wid yuvraj.

 

[andrew_nixon]

Ponting as I said.

 

[SHAHZEB 007]

Definatly out of Kaif and Gibbs in my view. Gave it to Gibbs tho.

 

[imported_graham]

i say ponting as well and y not symonds?? :P
i no that jonty is good but i dun fink that he is dat good!!!
nad btw sum1 will come near as good as jonty, perhaps me, ehehe jk

 

[andrew_nixon]

No-one has ever been as good as Jonty Rhodes. He's the Don Bradman of fielding. You're probably too young to remember Rhodes in his prime, but in the 92 and 96 World Cups he was fielding like he wasn't human.

 

[imported_graham]

yeah probs but anyway how bout symonds, is he around as good as ponting??

 

[imported_graham]

yeah probs, but how bout symonds, he is around as good as ponting??
but do u eva fink their will be sum1 betta than jonty?

 

[andrew_nixon]

Symonds is a very good fielder for an Englishman not as good as Ponting but he's pretty good.

 

[imported_desmondk007]

Oy! Symonds in not an enlgishman!! :blink:

Anyway I think Upul Chandhana is right up there! Along with Gibbs who has the best style, Ponting is a bit clumsy sometimes, collingwood seems really dedicated! same with Kaif and Yuvraj. Symonds seems to have lost it....though his batting is max these days!

I'd also like to remind u of Roshan Mahanama who even Jonty said was better than him somewhat becuase of his ability to feild in any position!

Peace
D.T

 

[andrew_nixon]

Symonds was born in Birmingham, England. Therefore, he is an Englishman.

 

[Sanju]

Hey even ricardo powell is a very good fielder