Dinesh Karthik

[Chetan0304]

I dont care if you are he's fan or his wife looks beautiful or cute.

The only reason for his presence that we dont have any reserve keeper or do we? get someone from our domestic team.

No matter we are discussing our weak bowlers and fielders, we need to replace him, someone who's more deserving, i don't know who .

Have a look at his ODI career @ 23.40 average in 32 matches. Here

 

[SciD]

His wife ain't any bomb.

Robin should have been there.

 

[Cricketman]

Oh, snap. No you dii'dnnnnnnnn't.

 

[0601731]

i would have prefered kohli in karthik's place.

 

[Leggie]

They're right. Uthappa should be in instead of Karthik, he fits the purpose far better for ODI's.

 

[0601731]

They're right. Uthappa should be in instead of Karthik, he fits the purpose far better for ODI's.

uthappa hasn't done anything of repute to justify a comeback.

 

[naresh091]

Yup Uthappa is more inconsistent than Karthik or even Rohit Sharma.Atleast these two guys try to stay at the crease,Uthappa just throws his wicket away.And yeah as 0601731() said,he hasnt done anything that deserves him another chance.

 

[SciD]

Robin did well in Corporate trophy. Not well but pretty well.

 

[naresh091]

Yeah but Corporate trophy wasnt of that high standard.Moreover scoring in two games doesnt prove hes been consistent.

 

[deepuparayil]

I think battingwise Karthik is more intelligent than Sharma and Robin.

 

[icyman]

As a reserve keeper,you could look at Srivats Goswami or even at Pinal Shah.
If replacing him with a batsman is concerned,have a look at A Nayar.

 

[Chetan0304]

Get Nayar in the Pakistan game.

No more chance to Karthik, please

 

[Gary123]

I think title needs to be changed to 'Dinesh Karthik'

I think Wriddhiman Saha is a good batsman and a keeper seen his performance in the IPL.
He should get the chance as Karthik has got his chances.

 

[SaiSrini]

Wridhiman Saha seems to be a good bet if we are looking for reserve keepers who can bat. The guy bats well and I have heard that he is a very good keeper. Dinesh Karthik doesnt grab his chances and we cant continue with him for too long like this.

 

[Akash00]

Let Dinesh Karthik be there. He is currently out of form.