I agree with Howsie, he just fails to show up on the INT stage, in big games and against good quality opposition.
In 35 matches against AUS he averages under 28,
20 matches against IND at under 25,
15 matches against PAK at under 18,
17 matches against SL at under 17,
13 matches against WI at under 24.
In 5+ team tournaments he also averages under 25.
That catch just made me doubt him even more, I felt he did not have the greatest day with the captaincy either making some poor bowling changes.
Why should he be our captain in the first place when he fails to sign a INT contract because he wants to play in the IPL I'll never know.
Before people criticize me for my negativism against him I would just like to say I think he is a player with a lot of potential, he just has a long way to go if he wants to be remembered in my books.