T.J.Hooker
Panel of Selectors
- Joined
- Feb 10, 2005
- Online Cricket Games Owned
Bit harsh on Ballance. He has gears which certainly Trott did not have. Can see your point though. You wouldn't want a team full of 'em (unless you're an England ODI selector and then apparently you do).
To an extent it's also the fact that accumulating is basically like camping in an fps. You're making the game as easy as you can possibly make it for yourself, and just waiting for your opponent's mistakes. Players who look to take on the oppo with imaginative, entertaining cricket are actually making the game much harder for themselves, and they usually need to make more runs to catch selectors' eyes because creativity and imagination are viewed with suspicion.
So when considering Cook vs KP for instance, there's a huge gap in ability. If Cook had spent his career trying to play like Pietersen and Pietersen like Cook, I'd guess Cook would probably not have made it past club level and Pietersen would have added 10 runs to his test average.