Lord of the Rings Mafia - Town wins

[Zohaib]

Faramir, Captain of Gondor, Town-alligned

I am more commonly known as a Vanilla Townie

 

[Spoobir]

That's an interesting one, not guaranteed to be in the game but not an overly obscure character either. I'll believe it for now.

----------

I doubt he has any links to the cult either since Denethor hated Faramir.

 

[Aditya]

I believe Zohaib's role claim for now and the member who I'm suspicious of at the moment is, Tom. Alright that he lynched Maney but his play has been quite weird. In my opinion, he's taking the advantage of the fact that we all think that he's being aggressive towards Colin but we need to understand that he's not serious while he's lynching Colin (that's what I think) but the way Colin has reacted to his posts is also weird. Colin is being aggressive towards Tom and Tom is being aggressive towards Maney and Colin. The way Colin and Tom have played it makes me wonder whether they both are mafia and are trying to make the townies believe that they're not working as a team by lynching each other but not really being serious.

Fos : Tom and Colin

Yudi needs to be more active. To put some pressure on him to post,

Lynch : Yudi

 

[barmyarmy]

@Aditya - I haven't at any point lynched Tom for a joke or otherwise. If you re-read my day 2 posts I think you'll find it blindingly obvious why I'm not mafia.

 

[Manly]

...wouldn't at all surprise me to see Tom as mafia, though.

 

[Highlander999]

I'm getting suspicious of you Aditya as anyone would realise Colin is the poisoned one and I was only joking about lynching him in my last post because it is him! I reckon you are trying to stir trouble up here where there is no reason to. You seem to be trying to get rid of two of the more intelligent and useful townie members here....

I still reckon Maney is trouble for the town though

 

[Manly]

I'm getting suspicious of you Aditya as anyone would realise Colin is the poisoned one and I was only joking about lynching him in my last post because it is him! I reckon you are trying to stir trouble up here where there is no reason to. You seem to be trying to get rid of two of the more intelligent and useful townie members here....

I still reckon Maney is trouble for the town though

And you the third.

 

[barmyarmy]

That best be auto-correct again...

Bloody iphone. Sorry.

Faramir is a decentish claim. Fairly likely to be in the game; brave claim for a mafia.
I'll follow my earlier instinct:
Unlynch: Zohaib
Lynch: Yudi

 

[Aditya]

@Colin - I didn't say that you're lynching Tom, I'm saying you're being aggressive towards him. By aggressive I mean, you both are getting some discussion started but then nothing really happens. Tom is lynching you and keeping in mind that you're a experienced player, I expect you to provide a better defense than what you have. Well, most members agree that you're poisoned so I really don't think that you should/will be lynched. I'm just putting up my point.

@Tom - Do agree with you here, I'm being a bit too aggressive towards you guys and if you both are townies, I'm bound to look suspicious. By intelligent townies you're referring to Colin and? Please complete the sentence for me. On a serious note, I want some discussion to be started. Right now, there is nothing to discuss so it's better to get some discussion started rather than sitting quite and watching a boring test series between England and India. Oh well, day 1 is over due to rain.

----------

Maney thinks that Highlander is a "intelligent" townie, that is something suspicious, it really is....

 

[barmyarmy]

Ok here is some discussion. Lynching Maney2k9 isn't a good idea right now because we need to try and get the original mafia. Our aim should be to lynch Saruman or Sauron and I don't think Maney is either. It's a lazy lynch which could backfire as it lets the big guys off the hook and could rob the town of a important voter.
4 players are yet to lynch in this round; would like to hear their thoughts.
BKB1991, Culli, Zohaib, Maney2k9. Obviously 3 of those are under suspicion anyway and have been defending themselves.
I'm always wary of people who agree with me too often (especially now it's obvious I'm townie) so I have some suspicions still about Varun and Chewie.

That said if people are happy with Zohaib's roleclaim Yudi and Culli are next in the firing line. This might look personal because he criticised me but all I've seen from Yudi in this thread is "I haven't managed to read what was posted", "where was that, I missed that" and "I'm not really sure what to think". He's clearly no use to the town so I'd support a lynch on him.

----------

@Colin - I didn't say that you're lynching Tom, I'm saying you're being aggressive towards him. By aggressive I mean, you both are getting some discussion started but then nothing really happens. Tom is lynching you and keeping in mind that you're a experienced player, I expect you to provide a better defense than what you have. Well, most members agree that you're poisoned so I really don't think that you should/will be lynched. I'm just putting up my point.

Hardly our fault if discussion is slow. As Tom mentioned I do know him better than anyone else in this thread (and have actually met and played golf with him) so you're clearly going to see a bit more banter between us than you would other people. Tom lynched me on day 1 because he was worried about the damage I might do the town if I was mafia - a fair enough concern . I am still wondering if he's playing a double game but he's had the sense to read between the lines on my day 2 posts and stop lynching me.
Likewise I don't feel I need to provide a defense anymore as the mafia have given me an extremely powerful one. For all I know the doctor may already be dead or end up blocked (watch it Gandalf!) or be very very stupid and I'll wind up dead in the morning anyway.

----------

Maney thinks that Highlander is a "intelligent" townie, that is something suspicious, it really is....

Not suspicious just a poor judge of character. He got into uni today so we'll assume he's drunk.

 

[Spoobir]

Highlander still pushing hard for Maney... If you know something concrete because of role information you have received you're as well to just tell us because otherwise it's starting to look suspicious.

 

[barmyarmy]

Assume you're talking to Tom. I know nothing concrete sadly...

 

[Manly]

I'm about to go on the razz, so please disregard anything I may post tonight, as I won't be in control of my brain.

 

[barmyarmy]

You're Sauron you say?

Have a good night and congrats

 

[Spoobir]

I'm going out too... If I see barmy in Edinburgh I'll beat him up till he tells me if he's mafia or not.