Lord of the Rings Mafia - Town wins
- Thread starter P Squared
- Start date
Spoobir
Thread of the Month March 2018
- Joined
- Feb 18, 2007
It should be pretty obvious to anyone that I attacked you because of that line in the write-up and stopped when PSquared said I was taking it "out of context". And it always seems in these games that lynching people means you are mafia, but not lynching them also means you are mafia so I don't even know what I'm supposed to say to your second "argument".
There are a whole bunch of people who did lynch him and haven't come under any suspicion whatsoever because they barely post, yet when I find something in the write-up which may help us find the mafia obviously I'm the suspicious one.
Lynch: Chewie
There are a whole bunch of people who did lynch him and haven't come under any suspicion whatsoever because they barely post, yet when I find something in the write-up which may help us find the mafia obviously I'm the suspicious one.
Lynch: Chewie
BKB1991
Panel of Selectors
Been busy so excuse the inactivity. Cant really say much the night has been analysed. I do admit Colin does seem one step ahead of us throughout the game so I wouldnt rule out him poisoning himself. But I guess that theory is not possible now 
Culli hasnt been a help, and I dont remember his roleclaim that much. Pro-town or not?
if not, who else can we go for?
Culli hasnt been a help, and I dont remember his roleclaim that much. Pro-town or not?
if not, who else can we go for?
Ok, I accept that you changed your mind after P Squared posted clarification. My bad.
I actually agree with you about the "inactives" however you weren't happy with us lynching off Yudi for that so I'm still not sure where you stand. In the absence of any other ideas my lynch stands for now.
Anyway I'll repeat what I said about bevab - seeing as everyone knows that he's Frodo he needs to tell us any info he has learned in his night role before the mafia come back for a second pop tonight and finish him off.
lol, I just realised MaD was killed on Day 1 and was mafia
Shows how much attention I'm paying to this game.
I'll FOS: hedger_14 as well for the post quoted above.
----------
I find this funny
hedger_14
ICC Chairman
Like I said, I haven't been overly active this game and been just reading over all of the pages quickly when I had been away for over a day and there was a lot to read. I understand why you and others are suspicious of me though.
Chewie
BCCI President
Hedger you understand that you haven't been inactive and that it is causing suspicion on you, but you don't do anything to remove any of this suspicion in your post by discussing what is happening in this game. Who in your opinion is suspicious, and what are your thoughts on Culli's role claim?
For me, the role claim seems pretty valid. With Theoden though, since he was initially under Wormtongue's influence, maybe the person who is Gandalf has to do something to him, otherwise he is mafia? Or maybe I'm just reading too much into what happened in the books/movie (I think I've got all that correct, haven't read the books for a while...)
For me, the role claim seems pretty valid. With Theoden though, since he was initially under Wormtongue's influence, maybe the person who is Gandalf has to do something to him, otherwise he is mafia? Or maybe I'm just reading too much into what happened in the books/movie
(I think I've got all that correct, haven't read the books for a while...)
I'm not sure what to make of Culli's roleclaim, he's one of those borderline characters that may or may not be in the game.
Other than Culli I'm most suspicious of Hedger and Tom. Both of them have been playing under the radar, and similar to what I said about Culli they seem to just be posting for the sake of it, Hedger's admitted he has been.
Like Colin said Bevab should probably post what he's been up to at night, because the mafia could continue to target him.
Other than Culli I'm most suspicious of Hedger and Tom. Both of them have been playing under the radar, and similar to what I said about Culli they seem to just be posting for the sake of it, Hedger's admitted he has been.
Like Colin said Bevab should probably post what he's been up to at night, because the mafia could continue to target him.
hedger_14
ICC Chairman
tbh, I haven't just been posting for the sake of it. Most of the time when I have posted, I have posted my opinions.
Well suspicious people, I thought Culli was mafia looking but his roleclaim seems legit. I don't get why he posted the "of course" bit and even his next post still made me wonder. I've thought Spoobir's played very differently than normal, and I am on barmy's side with that. Then again, I've played different than normal but yeah, he's just been too aggressive for my liking. He did it when he was my mafia partner and then afterwards said that he couldn't back off once he started. Of course he's probably learnt from that mistake but I don't know.
Apart from that, as I said before, I'm suspicious of Sachinfan98 and also Mark a bit, but I think it's just the way he plays the game. So:
FOS: Spoobir
Well suspicious people, I thought Culli was mafia looking but his roleclaim seems legit. I don't get why he posted the "of course" bit and even his next post still made me wonder. I've thought Spoobir's played very differently than normal, and I am on barmy's side with that. Then again, I've played different than normal but yeah, he's just been too aggressive for my liking. He did it when he was my mafia partner and then afterwards said that he couldn't back off once he started. Of course he's probably learnt from that mistake but I don't know.
Apart from that, as I said before, I'm suspicious of Sachinfan98 and also Mark a bit, but I think it's just the way he plays the game. So:
FOS: Spoobir
Varun
ICC Board Member
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2009
- Location
- Delhi, India
- Online Cricket Games Owned
- Don Bradman Cricket 14 - Steam PC
Unlynch : Culli
Since all of you think his roleclaim his valid, I might as well unlynch him.
Where is Mark btw? Haven't seen him posting anything substantial for a while.
Since all of you think his roleclaim his valid, I might as well unlynch him.
Where is Mark btw? Haven't seen him posting anything substantial for a while.
Aditya
ICC Board Member
Yesterday was another busy day. Anyway, I'm not suspicious of Spoobir, agreed that he was aggressive towards Colin after night 2 update but just a few posts before, he mentioned the reason why he was aggressive towards Colin. To me, Hedger's play has not been up to the mark. He's a experienced player and it isn't like he's completely inactive, he has been active but hasn't helped the town at all. If he thinks that he isn't getting time to have a read at the last few pages then it might be a better idea to replace him. Lynching him will be completely stupid, what if he is a townie! We will lose yet another townie and that too a player like Hedger.
@Colin - Why do we need to put a pressure lynch on Hedger? He has been inactivity so the better idea here is to ask for a replacement for him rather than putting pressure lynches on him. He hasn't read the last few pages, he's just completely lost in this game. I don't see how he can defend himself at this stage, where he has hardly done anything suspicious - that's simply because he hasn't been active at all to post something suspicious or in favor of the town.
Anyway, I'm not suspicious of Spoobir, agreed that he was aggressive towards Colin after night 2 update but just a few posts before, he mentioned the reason why he was aggressive towards Colin. To me, Hedger's play has not been up to the mark. He's a experienced player and it isn't like he's completely inactive, he has been active but hasn't helped the town at all. If he thinks that he isn't getting time to have a read at the last few pages then it might be a better idea to replace him. Lynching him will be completely stupid, what if he is a townie! We will lose yet another townie and that too a player like Hedger.@Colin - Why do we need to put a pressure lynch on Hedger? He has been inactivity so the better idea here is to ask for a replacement for him rather than putting pressure lynches on him. He hasn't read the last few pages, he's just completely lost in this game. I don't see how he can defend himself at this stage, where he has hardly done anything suspicious - that's simply because he hasn't been active at all to post something suspicious or in favor of the town.
Varun
ICC Board Member
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2009
- Location
- Delhi, India
- Online Cricket Games Owned
- Don Bradman Cricket 14 - Steam PC
Wouldn't the one replacing him be lost as well?
Sachinfan98
School Cricketer
Ok, so Culli has claimed. I haven't got any LOTR knowledge so I am just going along with you guys.
Unlynch:Culli
---
hedger_14, you're quite right. Where is Mark? I think I saw a post of his a page or two before. But that didn't make much contribution to the discussion. Nad as for you being suspicious of me, I don't see any reason why.
---
1 more thing, who are we going to lynch this day? If we could know how much time is left in the day, then we could plan accordingly. We truly cannot waste this day.
---
I think that putting some pressure on Aditya seems good to me. He really has not posted that much, although most of his posts are contributing to the discussion. I'm suspicious of him because of that. I'd say 60:40 due to him posting something.
Lynch:Aditya
Unlynch:Culli
---
hedger_14, you're quite right. Where is Mark? I think I saw a post of his a page or two before. But that didn't make much contribution to the discussion. Nad as for you being suspicious of me, I don't see any reason why.
---
1 more thing, who are we going to lynch this day? If we could know how much time is left in the day, then we could plan accordingly. We truly cannot waste this day.
---
I think that putting some pressure on Aditya seems good to me. He really has not posted that much, although most of his posts are contributing to the discussion. I'm suspicious of him because of that. I'd say 60:40 due to him posting something.
Lynch:Aditya
Similar threads
