Lord of the Rings Mafia - Town wins

[hedger_14]

He hasn't read the last few pages, he's just completely lost in this game.

Not true, I have read the last few pages. I just skipped over the first few pages early in the game and in the end, I sort of just got lost cause I was missing some vital information about the way people have been playing. I do read over it and things stand out to me, such as Spoobir's over aggressiveness and Mark's lack of contribution.

 

[CG123]

1 more thing, who are we going to lynch this day? If we could know how much time is left in the day, then we could plan accordingly. We truly cannot waste this day.

No one knows who's going to get lynched atm. I think a few players activity has dropped down lately which is what some people are trying to address atm, because in order to get a better idea of who's mafia it helps to have everyone's thoughts on the current situation.

In terms of how long's left in the day, normally the people running the game will say something like 24/36/48 hours left when the activity starts to die down, very rarely here on PC has a set time being used, so you can't really plan.

 

[Bevab]

Well, my life is really busy, so could I get a replacement?

But one condition: Provided I win, I do get a share of the victory, okay?

 

[Aditya]

I think that putting some pressure on Aditya seems good to me. He really has not posted that much, although most of his posts are contributing to the discussion. I'm suspicious of him because of that. I'd say 60:40 due to him posting something.
Lynch:Aditya

I fail to understand this logic. Most of my posts are contributing to the discussion but you still want to put pressure lynch on me? Just doesn't make any sense. It doesn't matter how many posts you're posting in a day phase. The thing that matters is that whether the posts you're posting are helpful to the townies or not (that is obviously if you're a townie). To be frank, your play has been very poor. You must be careful when you lynch a member. Care to elaborate what do you mean by "60:40 due to him posting something"? When I have posted and as you say, my posts have contributed to the discussion, what more are you expecting from me? By your logic, it seems that you want me to post a lot but whether those posts are really helpful to the townies or not, it doesn't really matter. Is this what your point is? If it is and you're a townie, then you're not a great one. Lynching a member on his inactivity is fine but when he is posting and contributing to the discussion, still lynching him is what mafia's do.

@Varun - I say to replace Hedger only if he thinks that he's busy with life and cannot be active in the game. If a new member comes up at his place, it might be a little difficult for him to read so many pages but we're here to help him. At least the new member will be able to contribute to the future discussions but I don't think that we need a replacement now because Hedger says that he has read the last few pages. I was not aware of this. So, now what we want from him is to raise his activity. If he is a townie then it will be very beneficial to us as he's a experienced player and can be very useful to us.

 

[barmyarmy]

Well, my life is really busy, so could I get a replacement?

But one condition: Provided I win, I do get a share of the victory, okay?

Lol
Since you RCed Frodo on day 1 I really don't see you winning but I'm more than happy for Abhas to replace you.

----------

Any one else thinking we should get all the most suspicious characters to RC. Might help the mafia for roles but I think it will help the town more at this stage.
I'd like to see RCs for:
hedger_14
chewie
Spoobir
Highlander999
Varun

 

[P Squared]

Culli - 4 (SachinFan98, Chewie, CG123, User2010)
Chewie - 1 (Spoobir)
Hedger_14 - 1 (Barmyarmy)

With 16 alive it takes 9 to lynch.

Sacinfan you need to unlynch Culli first.

 

[BKB1991]

LOL at Bevab. I am lost for words

Might be too risky at this stage Colin, and I am surprised tou actually suggested this. I think what we could do is get a list of 20 possible characters that should be in the game. Because quite a few roleclaims are bordering inclusion in the gamr or not. It could however give mafia an option of roles to claim, but its less harmful than roleclaiming.

4 hobbits
Gandalf
Bilbo
Aragorn
Legolas
Gimli
Yudis character.
Smeagol/Gollum - individiual most likely
4 mafia - probable

Leaves behind 5 other characters. We should identify who these 5 characters are likely to be, so in future when people roleclaim we know what's the probability of those roles being in the game

 

[barmyarmy]

I came up with 30 possibles off the top of my head before the game started. I haven't listed them because I figured it would help the mafia claim.
We don't appear to have any more info about who is mafia on day 3 than we had on day 1. I reckon I know LOTR well enough to see through dodgy RCs.

 

[Deleted member 13648]

Culli - 4 (SachinFan98, Chewie, CG123, User2010)
Chewie - 1 (Spoobir)
Hedger_14 - 1 (Barmyarmy)

With 16 alive it takes 9 to lynch.

Sacinfan you need to unlynch Culli first.

He did, it just wasn't in bold.

 

[Sachinfan98]

Culli - 4 (SachinFan98, Chewie, CG123, User2010)
Chewie - 1 (Spoobir)
Hedger_14 - 1 (Barmyarmy)

With 16 alive it takes 9 to lynch.

Sacinfan you need to unlynch Culli first.

I unlynched, just that I forgot to bold it. My bad
Unlynch:Culli
Lynch:None
Aditya seems to have given a reasonable defense. I just didnt understand that posting doesnt count as much as contributing as I have seen people lynching inactive members in this game. Thanks for the advice

----------

Culli, quick to tell P Squared that i didnt bold it?

 

[Zohaib]

Well, my life is really busy, so could I get a replacement?

But one condition: Provided I win, I do get a share of the victory, okay?

Awesome the town gets Abhas now

 

[Deleted member 13648]

Culli, quick to tell P Squared that i didnt bold it?

Hahaha damn, you got me.

 

[Spoobir]

LOL at Bevab. I am lost for words

Might be too risky at this stage Colin, and I am surprised tou actually suggested this. I think what we could do is get a list of 20 possible characters that should be in the game. Because quite a few roleclaims are bordering inclusion in the gamr or not. It could however give mafia an option of roles to claim, but its less harmful than roleclaiming.

4 hobbits
Gandalf
Bilbo
Aragorn
Legolas
Gimli
Yudis character.
Smeagol/Gollum - individiual most likely
4 mafia - probable

Leaves behind 5 other characters. We should identify who these 5 characters are likely to be, so in future when people roleclaim we know what's the probability of those roles being in the game

Well depending on whether you believe Zohaib or not, 1 of those 5 characters is Faramir, one is Boromir (claimed by Maney) and one is Denethor (AngryPixel). So really there's only 2 townies/individuals unaccounted for and I agree that we shouldn't start openly speculating about them and give the mafia a bunch of likely characters for them to claim.

 

[Gaurav_7]

So, Culli's claim is valid? I'm not sure what to do.

I'm actually suspicious of SachinFan and Aditya. Both going after each other, then one posts a long post, the other is satisfied with it, both leave it. Just a hit in the dark though...

 

[Spoobir]

So, Culli's claim is valid? I'm not sure what to do.

I'm actually suspicious of SachinFan and Aditya. Both going after each other, then one posts a long post, the other is satisfied with it, both leave it. Just a hit in the dark though...

Of yeah I missed Culli in my post above. So that really only leaves one townie/individual character, assuming Zohaib and Culli are telling the truth of course. It's even possible there were 5 mafia though with a cult it's probably unlikely.