Lord of the Rings Mafia - Town wins

[Highlander999]

Barney?

 

[Manly]

I am Barney Stinson.

----------

ANYway. FoS: barmyarmy

He was too quick to lynch Jack's ex for my liking.

 

[Highlander999]

Imposter!

----------

Lynch: Maney2k9
Reason: For stealing my identity

 

[barmyarmy]

Well played mafia. We have no clue...

 

[P Squared]

lynch: Treva's ex
Don't leave us with P Squared. His write-up almost got me lynched...

lol its not that hard to understand what I wrote. Like I said, more explanation after the game finishes.

 

[Sachinfan98]

Ok, so I log in to see a pressure lynch on me. Aditya, I did not see you posting too much although you were contributing(not too much) so I lynched you. And now, I see you going after me because I went after you. Can this get any worse? I actually did not mean much by that. Just a little vote to get some discussion going on.(to move on from Culli, as everyone has validated his claim.)You, on the other hand, straight away went on the defensive. You now have started attacking me. But since you have given a reasonable explanation(that contributing matters more than posting), I'm not lynching you for now.
---
I know I am looking suspicious to everyone. I haven't played this game before and I'm surprised to see I have survived till here. Yep, I saw a post by ARay saying that he doesn't know much about me. Maybe that's what you all think. I don't blame you guys for that, maybe it is faced by every newbie.
---
If you still don't believe me, check these posts by MaD

Well I was just trying to start some discussion

Unlynch: Mark

Lynch: SachinFan98

Hasn't posted yet

I had posted by that time.

How do you know about Zorax and Highlander? (not that there's anything on anyway )

These were the posts that he was attacking me on. Clears me? Why would MaD attack me(that too on day 1) if I was his partner? That would be stupidity.
I hope you guys understand.

 

[CG123]

My holidays start in two days, so I should be able to go back and do some analysis of the earlier play then. I've been rather quiet over the last 24 hours or so because I've got an assignment due tomorrow and one due on Friday to finish this half of the semester off.

Without going back and looking at day one and two I'm a bit stuck for ideas. We still haven't got much from Tom in terms of the game, although I guess he does have an excuse.

 

[hedger_14]

Ok, well I'll claim now so you don't keep suspecting me and focus on others who are also acting suspiciously.

I am Eowyn, Noblewoman of Rohan, Town-aligned. It actually has ?own in my role but that will probably because of the character changes that were occuring with the umlauted (if that's a word) characters.

I am the doublevoter, and that's my only role.

 

[BKB1991]

Sounds legit to me.

 

[barmyarmy]

Agreed. Eowyn is an important character as she kills the witch king. Hopefully hedger can do the same.

----------

So...
Unlynch: hedger_14
Lynch: chewie
Reason: another person I'd like to see a claim from.

 

[Chewie]

So you're just going to go round and get claims from everyone now?

I am Elrond, Lord of Rivendell

 

[Deleted member 13648]

As said before, hearing role-claims from everyone at this stage benefits the Town as we're still incredibly unsure as to who's Mafia aligned. I'm all for more role-claims.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Someone to update the first post please? Also, why the hell are we role claiming? I mean it's not like there are only 6-7 players left. We're about 15-16? This is pathetic.

As said before, hearing role-claims from everyone at this stage benefits the Town as we're still incredibly unsure as to who's Mafia aligned. I'm all for more role-claims.

So, that's the plan? I'm not going to believe Culli. I've a feeling he's a mafia. Why would role claims help the town at this stage? I'm not sure. Maybe, they will but only slightly. Whereas, they will be more beneficial to the mafia as they can kill who are supposedly going to be power roles.

Unlynch : Whoever I lynched earlier
Lynch : Culli

 

[Deleted member 13648]

How will role-claims help? Because we can determine which characters are most likely to be involved in the game & thus decipher who is likely to be Mafia.* If a Mafia claims a 'power-role' then I'm sure it'll be quickly picked up upon by the real character.

*Right now, I don't see a better method to approach it.

 

[barmyarmy]

I've only asked for role claims from certain people not everyone.
I had Elrond down as a probable - I don't see Arwen being in and Elrond not.
Unlynch: chewie