Lord of the Rings Mafia - Town wins

[Spoobir]

How about an actual role claim from Tom rather than just a character claim? He uses a after saying he has "great knowledge" which seems to be a hint that he has some kind of role, I'll be very unimpressed if he claims vanilla now.

 

[barmyarmy]

@P Squared - so can Abhas replace bevab then?

 

[BKB1991]

I actually agree with you Colin, thats not a very strong roleclaim, but I wouldnt rule out him being in the game.

Personally, Spoobir asking for his actual role is actually quite interesting. Spoobir does seem to be playing a different role this time around.

FOS: Tom, Spoobir

 

[barmyarmy]

My FOS is also still on Spoobir but also moving towards sachinfan98.

 

[BKB1991]

why on sachinfan98?

 

[Bevab]

Where is Abhas? I thought he would replace me.

BTW, what did Spoobir claim?

 

[Zohaib]

What so having everyone role claim, well that's how I see it

----------

Where is Abhas? I thought he would replace me.

BTW, what did Spoobir claim?

He didnt claim, he is just trying to get people to let out their roles, which is honestly a mafia tactic

 

[Spoobir]

Honestly I can tell who's gonna have the power roles just from their characters so if I'm mafia I don't need people to roleclaim. I do however want Tom to claim if he has any sort of role because his character claim is weakest atm and a roleclaim will help me figure out if he's telling the truth or not.

And I'm not claiming unless we decide just to do a mass claim, so suck it.

 

[6ry4nj]

Might I be permitted to make an observation? Obviously I don't have any privileged info. I think it could be useful (to the town that is).

 

[CG123]

So we've had almost every man and his dog claim since I was last on...

I'm not really sure on any these borderline claims tbh, because like I think I've said before it's been a while since I've seen any of the movies. Like others have said it would be good to know if Tom has a role or not before I go ahead and lynch him, because Treebeard's role in the movies was pretty limited, and the other borderline claims all seem to be marginally stronger.

I wouldn't mind if you say what you want to say 6ry4nj, but I think from the game's perspective it's best that you don't. Get one of the mods to confirm this though.

 

[barmyarmy]

why on sachinfan98?

I originally thought he was just a new player but now I think he might be a very clever mafia.

----------

Might I be permitted to make an observation? Obviously I don't have any privileged info. I think it could be useful (to the town that is).

If Abhas doesn't want the role you can replace bevab. As Callum said whilst we'd love your input not sure whether we're allowed it.

 

[6ry4nj]

If Abhas doesn't want the role you can replace bevab. As Callum said whilst we'd love your input not sure whether we're allowed it.

No probs I'll def wait to see what PSquared has to say about it. Actually since it is only of benefit to the town, if it's as useful as I think it is, I'd better keep it to myself for 'game balance'

Although yeah I could probably do justice to a role no-one else wanted. This is the most entertaining mafia game of the very few I've followed.

 

[Varun]

Well, I have no idea on Tom, but why can't there be a less known character in the game? It isn't a reason to lynch.

 

[Sachinfan98]

Do I need to claim?Are we going for a mass-claim?
---
barmy, what makes you think I am a 'clever' mafia?

 

[P Squared]

Yeah you can replace Bevab 64ryunj