Lord of the Rings Mafia - Town wins
- Thread starter P Squared
- Start date
Gaurav_7
Executive member
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2010
- Profile Flag
- India
It has to be hidden, or it defeats the purpose. Hedger lynched AP last, so that too doesn't isn't really convincing. But, people say that claim is legit. So, I'll believe it for now. I think Culli has to be the one to go if there's anyone. I'm most suspicious of him.
Spoobir
Thread of the Month March 2018
- Joined
- Feb 18, 2007
I don't think one double voter in all the games I've played in has been hidden... Anyway it's a pretty easy claim to test so I'm not too bothered by it atm.
Here's a list of confirmed/guaranteed characters btw:
Frodo - Bevab
Sam - User2010
Merry - ???
Pippen - ???
Aragorn - ???
Gandalf - ???
Legolas - ???
Gimli - ???
Boromir - Maney2k9(or possibly cult)
Denethor - AngryPixel
Bilbo - ARay
Arwen - Yudi
Gothmog - MaD
Sauron - ???
Gollum - ???(green is individual)
So that's 15 characters that are either already confirmed or 100% guaranteed to be in the game because of how important they are in the Lord of the Rings universe.
Assuming there are 4 mafia it's likely the final two are the Witch King and Saruman(?), which leaves 3 characters unaccounted for. At the moment there are 4 candidates for those 3 slots:
Faramir - Zohaib - Vanilla
Elrond - Chewie - ???
Eowyn - hedger - Double Voter
Theoden - Culli - ???
This is just information for people who are unfamiliar with Lord of the Rings, if you feel I have I have something wrong in regards to likely/guaranteed characters feel free to point it out.
Here's a list of confirmed/guaranteed characters btw:
Frodo - Bevab
Sam - User2010
Merry - ???
Pippen - ???
Aragorn - ???
Gandalf - ???
Legolas - ???
Gimli - ???
Boromir - Maney2k9(or possibly cult)
Denethor - AngryPixel
Bilbo - ARay
Arwen - Yudi
Gothmog - MaD
Sauron - ???
Gollum - ???(green is individual)
So that's 15 characters that are either already confirmed or 100% guaranteed to be in the game because of how important they are in the Lord of the Rings universe.
Assuming there are 4 mafia it's likely the final two are the Witch King and Saruman(?), which leaves 3 characters unaccounted for. At the moment there are 4 candidates for those 3 slots:
Faramir - Zohaib - Vanilla
Elrond - Chewie - ???
Eowyn - hedger - Double Voter
Theoden - Culli - ???
This is just information for people who are unfamiliar with Lord of the Rings, if you feel I have I have something wrong in regards to likely/guaranteed characters feel free to point it out.
BKB1991
Panel of Selectors
Since we are not going much far, I am inclined to lynch out Maney
Spoobir
Thread of the Month March 2018
- Joined
- Feb 18, 2007
P
pcfan123
Guest
shouldn't it be witch queen
Spoobir
Thread of the Month March 2018
- Joined
- Feb 18, 2007
That sounds like a terrible idea... We have 4 people of whom at least one is guaranteed mafia and you want to lynch someone who is a long shot to be in a cult?
P
pcfan123
Guest
I've been put on mod approval so I'm outta here. Kill me, don't kill me I don't care. I'm Pippen the hobbit, vanilla townie.
see y'all around
see y'all around
Witch King is the leader of the Nazgul.
This guy:
That's the one I was after.
----------
But why? We've established already that I'm now Town after Denethor bit the dust...
Gaurav_7
Executive member
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2010
- Profile Flag
- India
The thing is, whether there is another cult leader after AP or the cult just died as the leader died before even he could recruit anyone. Normally, what happens in these games if the leader is dead? I'm not sure I've seen that happen other than here...
Varun
ICC Board Member
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2009
- Location
- Delhi, India
- Online Cricket Games Owned
- Don Bradman Cricket 14 - Steam PC
Nothing really can be said, it can be that Maney carried over his role, but then, the writeups haven't signalled anything like that..
----------
Do I need to claim as well? My role is insignificant so I don't mind.
----------
Do I need to claim as well? My role is insignificant so I don't mind.
Highlander999
ICC President
- Joined
- Apr 15, 2006
- Location
- London
Figure if we're doing role claims, I am: Treebeard, Ent, Town-aligned
I am very old, very wise and have great knowledge
About as far away from me as a person as you can get 
----------
Anyone else wondering if Colin has cheated and read all our PM's to see everyone's roles?
I am very old, very wise and have great knowledge
About as far away from me as a person as you can get ----------
Anyone else wondering if Colin has cheated and read all our PM's to see everyone's roles?
If I'd read all the PMs I wouldn't need anyone to claim...
Lot of info to take in.
----------
Ok. Very interesting as I said. I make it that there are 7 people (myself included who haven't claimed) and 8 definite roles. That means that someone who has claimed already has lied.
Let's focus on that rather than everyone else claiming.
The weakest claim for me is Tom's. He's claimed a minor character who appears briefly in one of the three films. His claim doesn't stand up well. I would have been suspicious of Elrond had Arwen not been in the game. One to watch rather than wholly accept.
Anyway my lynch goes to Tom. He may have been unlucky with his role but I reckon Treebeard is a weak claim.
Lynch: Highlander999
Lot of info to take in.
----------
Ok. Very interesting as I said. I make it that there are 7 people (myself included who haven't claimed) and 8 definite roles. That means that someone who has claimed already has lied.
Let's focus on that rather than everyone else claiming.
The weakest claim for me is Tom's. He's claimed a minor character who appears briefly in one of the three films. His claim doesn't stand up well. I would have been suspicious of Elrond had Arwen not been in the game. One to watch rather than wholly accept.
Anyway my lynch goes to Tom. He may have been unlucky with his role but I reckon Treebeard is a weak claim.
Lynch: Highlander999
Similar threads
