Well firstly I'd just like to put this out there, while Hedger is cleared of being mafia, there's still and outside possibility that he could be Gollum. I can't remember if you said/there is a reason why Eowyn would be the double voter, but normally the double voter is one of the more prominent characters, so I'm just putting it out there that Gollum could be the double voter as an individual.
In terms of the play yesterday, I don't think Tom done himself a lot of favours. I have however been in the same situation as him with a crap character (ARay's mafia where he deliberately gave me a different name to put everyone off, also I was a vanilla townie), and you really don't have a lot of cards to play in terms of what's infront of you in order to try and prove your innocence, because of your character and your role. However as a vanilla townie he should have probably tried to stay slightly more active, because as one that's how you can be helpful to the town's cause.
In terms of Colin and Spoobir I think they may of been slightly too aggressive towards Tom, but with nothing else happening it was a gamble that probably had to be taken. I don't think Spoobir's played that great, but he does has a strong claim which leans heavily towards him being town. On Colin's in his first game I just don't think he would have played this way if he was mafia. Most first time town players are relatively quite and unhelpful, while most first time mafia players try to stay completely under the radar, which he hasn't done. IF he was mafia they could have given him some sort of license and poisoned him for that reason, but with User as a confirmed townie I think that almost clears Colin.
In terms of who I'm most suspicious of, that's tough because there's still still a couple of characters claim (who've been borderline), who all seem to carry the same amount of chance of being in the game from my perspective (and it doesn't help when like five people have names beginning with "E" and are all around 5 letter wrong). Culli's plays being strange at best, while the likes of Mark who has a strong claim has been very little help. I'm not really sure what to make of the likes of Zohaib, didn't he claim vanilla with a borderline character, kind of the easy route out for mafia. Although there's bound to be a few vanilla's in such a big game, and with little suspicious on him I assume who he claimed was verified by the others.
Btw do you have those vote charts Colin, and if you do could you post all three here so we can analysis them together.
Also in the future can we get the final vote count with the write-up.
In terms of the play yesterday, I don't think Tom done himself a lot of favours. I have however been in the same situation as him with a crap character (ARay's mafia where he deliberately gave me a different name to put everyone off, also I was a vanilla townie), and you really don't have a lot of cards to play in terms of what's infront of you in order to try and prove your innocence, because of your character and your role. However as a vanilla townie he should have probably tried to stay slightly more active, because as one that's how you can be helpful to the town's cause.
In terms of Colin and Spoobir I think they may of been slightly too aggressive towards Tom, but with nothing else happening it was a gamble that probably had to be taken. I don't think Spoobir's played that great, but he does has a strong claim which leans heavily towards him being town. On Colin's in his first game I just don't think he would have played this way if he was mafia. Most first time town players are relatively quite and unhelpful, while most first time mafia players try to stay completely under the radar, which he hasn't done. IF he was mafia they could have given him some sort of license and poisoned him for that reason, but with User as a confirmed townie I think that almost clears Colin.
In terms of who I'm most suspicious of, that's tough because there's still still a couple of characters claim (who've been borderline), who all seem to carry the same amount of chance of being in the game from my perspective (and it doesn't help when like five people have names beginning with "E" and are all around 5 letter wrong). Culli's plays being strange at best, while the likes of Mark who has a strong claim has been very little help. I'm not really sure what to make of the likes of Zohaib, didn't he claim vanilla with a borderline character, kind of the easy route out for mafia. Although there's bound to be a few vanilla's in such a big game, and with little suspicious on him I assume who he claimed was verified by the others.
Btw do you have those vote charts Colin, and if you do could you post all three here so we can analysis them together.
Also in the future can we get the final vote count with the write-up.
We're getting somewhere is what I'd say....
