Lord of the Rings Mafia - Town wins

[CG123]

And Zohaib that's how it works mate, they posted their views on the game now because they want to gain the town trust that they are afraid of getting killed on night 3. They need to pretend townies but I don't need to do that. I'm a townie and there is a very little possibility of me getting killed in this night phase as I mentioned above simply because I'm not a THREAT to the townies until and unless I'm suspicious of one of the mafia members.

Well that's very interesting...

 

[barmyarmy]

Ok, looks a lot like I've been poisoned again and we know that Sam, the healer, is dead.
Bugger.
I may as well role claim at this point to try and help the town as much as possible before I die tonight.

 

[CG123]

@ Zohaib - Why haven't you lynched anyone in the last two days?

That seems rather strange to me. Your gameplay hasn't really been much help to the town, and your vanilla roleclaim is one of the weaker ones. I'm not really sure if it means something, but you also said Aditya's confidence was "scummy".

I'm not really sure where to go from here, so I'm going to go ahead and lynch you for the time being:

Lynch: Zohaib

 

[Deleted member 13648]

I haven't played that great to be killed by mafia's in this night phase. There are better players still left, how can I be killed when I'm not a threat to the mafia's? I'm suspicious of just one member at the moment, that is SachinFan. If he is mafia then obviously I MIGHT be killed in this night phase but as I'm not suspicious of anyone else, I don't see any possibility of getting killed. Also, you've been pretty quite in this game. I haven't really seen a great contribution from you in this game but yet you haven't come under the suspicion radar which is very surprising.

@6ry4nj - I don't see how you trust BKB. I don't trust him, he hasn't done anything that confirms him as a townie. As far as I'm concern, it's fair enough that you don't trust me. I haven't done anything special for the town as well so it's pretty obvious that you'd be suspicious of me but as I haven't done anything in town's favor I haven't done anything suspicious at the same time.

@Hedger_14 - Well, I do see some things getting cleared up but as I mentioned earlier, it could be just me. I'd post what has cleared up for me on day 4 and see if other members think the same.

--------

And Zohaib that's how it works mate, they posted their views on the game now because they want to gain the town trust that they are afraid of getting killed on night 3. They need to pretend townies but I don't need to do that. I'm a townie and there is a very little possibility of me getting killed in this night phase as I mentioned above simply because I'm not a THREAT to the townies until and unless I'm suspicious of one of the mafia members.

I'd like to here Sachinfan's thoughts on this accusation bolded here.

FOS: Sachinfan

In the meantime, I'll go along with the pressure lynch on Zohaib.

Lynch: Zohaib

 

[hedger_14]

Well I have always been suspicious of Sachinfan and that sort of puts a bit more suspicion on him. I don't know about Zohaib, wouldn't it be stupid to attack a townie that will be killed that night to put suspicion on yourself as a mafia? So for the time being.

Lynch: Sachinfan98

 

[Varun]

Aditya shouldn't have written up those long paragraphs of 'I won't be lynched.' I have no idea of whether he was bluffing or not, trying to save himself, but mafia might have felt so.

Another interesting arises here is, why Aditya was constantly gunning for the lynch of SachinFan98? I'd be more than inclined to believe Aditya was the cop, and probably found something about SachinFan, if it wasn't for the writeup - "he was sleeping peacefully in his bed." If he was cop, I see no reason why he wouldn't use the role.

We shouldn't lynch SachinFan blindly, it might be a big conspiracy against him, we all know how this game works.

The mischievous hobbit was feeling unwell, but he knew that there was no one left to save him, and so he must face his inevitable death. He was also looking for something. Something that the wise old man had. He went into the wizards room and saw the object he was looking for. Quietly he stole that object and went back to his room.

I can't make head nor tail of this. First it says he must face his inevitable death, then he visits the wise old man (barmy, right?) and steals the object, and....gets cured? Then how was it 'inevitable death'?

-----
Everything seemed to be happening to the wise old man. He was feeling the pain he had felt some nights ago again. And again it was a fellow wizard who had caused it.
-----

Barmy getting poisoned again, I anticipated it to be honest.

So, these are the ones I suspect the most:

1. Maney and Spoobir - I've been quite suspicious of both, and it seems both are working together. I still cannot believe Maney has converted to town. Why should he?

2. Sachinfan - I'm not quite sure, but it is very possible that he thought Aditya had something against him, and thus, killed him.

FOS : Maney, Spoobir, Sachinfan

Lynch : Maney2k9

Don't care if he's a vengeful townie, although I'm darn sure he's not.

Would still love others to make observations on the Day 1 and Day 3 day-time kills. I observed the data as well, but still no possible speculations.

 

[Zohaib]

@ Zohaib - Why haven't you lynched anyone in the last two days?

That seems rather strange to me. Your gameplay hasn't really been much help to the town, and your vanilla roleclaim is one of the weaker ones. I'm not really sure if it means something, but you also said Aditya's confidence was "scummy".

I'm not really sure where to go from here, so I'm going to go ahead and lynch you for the time being:

Lynch: Zohaib

I havent lyched anyone because to me those that were hammered seemed like obvious townies, and I am not in favor of getting rid of townies be them active or inactive

Yeah Sachin Fan is the most suspicious right now as, Aditiya may have had some sort of one night investigation which he probably used on the first night that is why he was gunning for a lynch, on Sachin Fan

Also, Sachin Fan probably found out where Aditya was going and decided to kill him before he let out the truth

These are all possiblities.

Also CCG, you said the last post of Adtiya was interesting, why do you say that?

 

[Varun]

Yeah Sachin Fan is the most suspicious right now as, Aditiya may have had some sort of one night investigation which he probably used on the first night that is why he was gunning for a lynch, on Sachin Fan

Why do you say one-night investigation?

Also CCG, you said the last post of Adtiya was interesting, why do you say that?

Because Aditya emphasize a lot that he wasn't a threat to mafia, and won't get killed, and ironically he got.

 

[Zohaib]

Why do you say one-night investigation?


Because Adtiya was gunning for a lynch on Sachin Fan from day 2 iirc

It would be best if we analyse his posts through out this game

 

[Aditya]

Whoa! Didn't see this coming really but damn I just said too much on night 3.

 

[Manly]

My vengeful kill now stands with Varun.

So if he's mafia and you kill me then you've gotten rid of one from each side.

 

[Varun]

Nice try. Don't you see Maney, you haven't even defended yourself in the slightest way? Saying that 'it's in my PM' or 'I did became a vengeful vanilla townie' is hardly relevant unless you contribute to our search of mafia instead of being silent.

And you are giving me cult creeps for a long time, and I have every reason to suspect those day-kills might be your doing.

 

[Manly]

I'm losing interest in this game at a huge speed so I guess it's best for all involved if I reveal all.

You were (in the majority) correct. I stayed Cult, but clearly with no other members, I was on a hiding to nothing, so had to try and claim town. However I do possess a vengeful kill on death. Which as I said sits on Varun unless the bandwagon doesn't generate any momentum, and goes on whoever hits me first.

 

[Sachinfan98]

Ok, this seriously is stupid. People are STILL having suspicion on me. Don't you guys understand that this is the perfect ploy by the mafia? They are killing two birds with one stone on this. First, they kill Aditya, because during the night, he FOS's me. Then he says that he might not survive the night because I would kill him. Now, if the mafia were to follow this, the tactic would bring me under the suspicion radar. And, their plan is working perfectly.I'm coming under the suspicion radar from everyone. That just isn't cricket.
---
I can make nothing of this write-up though, TBH. Maybe if some moment of brainwave occurs, I will speak about it.
---
No role-claim from me right now, I don't think there is enough pressure on me to claim.
---
Umm, so we have barmyarmy poisoned again - wth? Just keeping my fingers crossed so that a healing role goes to somebody.
---
Also, I think it is pretty obvious. The poisoner role isn't one shot, so the mafia are just going for barmy like mad. Does make sense though, because barmy is the biggest contributor and a BIG help to us. And, I think this also clears my suspicion that barmy might not be town because I doubt the mafia would take the risk to poison their member once again, even after the death of User2010. That would be a big gamble, unlikely to be made.
---
I have no FOS for now, and no lynch to be made too.

 

[barmyarmy]

Right I'm going to role claim and character claim. I want to start by saying that I think the write-ups have been very unfair and have given away both my role and character to anyone who read them properly.

He walked briskly with his staff in one hand. He wanted to meet the most mischievous hobbit among those in Minas Tirith, as he felt that the fool was up to something. And as soon as he reached his destination his suspicions were confirmed. The young lad was attempting to steal from a close friend of his. The wizard gave a stern telling off to the hobbit, and went back to his room.​

Oh, look Gandalf is the roleblocker.

The fat little person went about searching for the wise old man who had not been seen much during the day. The reason put out was weakness. As he entered the man's room, he saw him on his last breath, a victim of his own arts. The fat person quickly gave him the antidote and saved him from his death.

Oh. look Colin, who was poisoned, is a "wise old man". How many of those are there in LOTR?

Everything seemed to be happening to the wise old man. He was feeling the pain he had felt some nights ago again. And again it was a fellow wizard who had caused it.

Oh. look Colin who is the "wise old man", is a wizard.

Thanks write ups - you've been a lot of help...to the mafia who have now obviously poisoned me twice.

Night role info:

Night 1: I roleblocked BKB who is confirmed townie. Seeing as the mafia did something to him on night 2 they know already that he's the thief.

Night 2: Didn't roleblock anyone. Scared about killing the doctor.

Night 3: Role blocked sachinfan98. Someone still got killed and poisoned so he's not the godfather or poisoner.

Before I die I would like to make sure we lynch either a mafia or Maney. Here is my list of suspect roleclaims:

Elrond - chewie
Theoden - Culli
Faramir - Zohaib
whoever he ends up claiming - Varun

I would be confident that at least two of those are mafia.

Personally I'm going to say FOS: chewie, varun, Culli, Zohaib
Would like to hear a role claim from Callum and Varun. I'm satisfied sachinfan98 is clean for now.

My lynch is going on chewie. He has fewest posts of any player alive and all I'm seeing from him is comment rather than analysis.

Personally I think the town is now pretty screwed and I'm fairly annoyed that my character and role has been outed quite so obviously in the write-ups. I even had a kick-ass character claim ready