Lord of the Rings Mafia - Town wins

[CG123]

So do you steal their role, and then are you able to use that role on the next night?

 

[BKB1991]

Once a night you will still an item from your chosen person, revealing something about their role. More commonly known as the Thief.

This.

 

[CG123]

Ok, that makes much more sense than what I was thinking.

 

[6ry4nj]

Lolz at Culli posting a pic of Sauron. It now appears 'confirmed' that Zohaib, SachinFan and Culli are (probly not in order) Sauron (mafia killer - godfather?), Saruman (mafia poisoner) and Gollum (likely alternate day SK). With Culli staying the most 'under the radar', would we say he is the scummiest? We need to get rid of a mafia killing role ideally...so...

Lynch: Culli

Or is that giving too much away?...

I have made some assumptions, but only the minimum that had to be made.

 

[Deleted member 13648]

I don't particularly agree that I've been the most 'under-the-radar'. I've been given such a weak character that I'm struggling to prove my worth to the Town without any real power. However, I do feel like I've raised some good points about a potential Mafia player despite all this. I'm not your man, fella.

 

[Varun]

I'm ?omer, town aligned, and vanilla townie. I hinted it back when Colin was lynching people based on their weak roleclaims.

I have tried my best to analyze the posts, and post my arguments, the only thing I can really do.

And I don't believe both CG and Zohaib can both be survivors. It's just so unlikely, with AP and Maney being cult aligned as well.

Maney is wavering his statements again and again, day before yesterday, he was a vanilla townie, yesterday, vengeful townie, today, cult with a one-shot kill. What next? My lynch stays.

@Colin - If I was mafia, I would have initiated your being killed as soon as User was dead, rather than poisoning you and waiting.

----------

Though I'd still be more than happy to change my lynch if we spot a mafia, as I much I feel Maney is a threat, I don't think he is mafia.

 

[barmyarmy]

Lolz at Culli posting a pic of Sauron. It now appears 'confirmed' that Zohaib, SachinFan and Culli are (probly not in order) Sauron (mafia killer - godfather?), Saruman (mafia poisoner) and Gollum (likely alternate day SK). With Culli staying the most 'under the radar', would we say he is the scummiest? We need to get rid of a mafia

As I said in my post sachinfan98 cannot be godfather or poisoner.

You might be right about Culli though.

----------

@Varun - Eomer is a good claim but it would have been a lot more credible if you didn't already know every other character on the game.

----------

Reckon should push out roleclaims from everyone here, Chewie has been different, Hedger and Culli have been unconvincing townies, and the rest are hard to read. Mass roleclaim is the way to go.

Hedger has proved he's the double voter.

You guys gotta try and save Colin till the end. I am gonna die soon, so back him out hes defo townie, plus hes got some common sense.

I think we're both screwed seeing as the doctor is dead.

----------

I don't particularly agree that I've been the most 'under-the-radar'. I've been given such a weak character that I'm struggling to prove my worth to the Town without any real power. However, I do feel like I've raised some good points about a potential Mafia player despite all this. I'm not your man, fella.

That's how vanilla townies operate. It's not a worthless or powerless role. Being less likely to be night-killed as a vanilla you have to play a strong game to ensure the town won't lynch you. I'm 70% convinced by your roleclaim but I don't think you've really been any help to the town and saying that it's because you're a vanilla doesn't really cut any ice (get it?).

----------

@Colin - If I was mafia, I would have initiated your being killed as soon as User was dead, rather than poisoning you and waiting.

I'm sure you realised that, as Gandalf, I have immunity from one night kill. It doesn't apparently apply to being poisoned...

----------

Yeah, if Mark's not being active at all then I'm more than happy to replace him and get this sorry excuse of a Town back into the game

His mod preview has expired so check with him first I guess.

 

[6ry4nj]

As I said in my post sachinfan98 cannot be godfather or poisoner.

Yeah I saw that after I posted - bummer! He still could be Gollum/SK though. Either way it's high time we got a claim from him.

And yes I could be right about Culli, but you could also be right about Chewie. He's been too too TOO quiet! I'll join your bandwagon if nothing happens with mine.

What do you think about Varun? He has been pursuing Spoobir somewhat irrationally, while largely avoiding casting suspicion on the major suspects. Was my confidence of him wishful thinking?

That said, I think we really have to pick someone scummy to lynch. Ben and Callum have scummy role-claims (bizarre to think that claiming to be Shelob can get someone off the hook!) but I don't think they're mafia. SachinFan isn't either - not a killing role anyway. Zohaib perhaps? I can't decide...

 

[Deleted member 13648]

Okay, I appreciate my trolling wasn't taken in the best interest by the Town & I apologise for that; me and my damned sense of humour! I'll keep analysing people & their movements to try and suss this out for us all.

 

[barmyarmy]

@6ry4nj - I totally agree with you about Callum's roleclaim but he has been giving pro-town vibes throughout the game. Bit strange for him to then claim as an individual.

----------

I'll keep analysing people & their movements to try and suss this out for us all.

You can start by analysing chewie, varun and Zohaib for us.

 

[Sachinfan98]

Yeah I saw that after I posted - bummer! He still could be Gollum/SK though. Either way it's high time we got a claim from him.
SachinFan isn't either - not a killing role anyway.

WTH is that supposed to mean?
---
I am asking this for the last time - SHOULD I CLAIM?
Are we going for a mass-claim right now?
---
Still no FOS on anyone(from me). I think we should wait and see how the day unfolds rather than just hurrying and hastily lynching off a townie.
---
BKB, are you hinting that you are poisoned? Or is it barmy? I'm confused because BKB just said that his time is almost over in this game so I think he might be poisoned. But I think it is barmyarmy(80%) - If anyone has got a healing role please heal.

 

[Aditya]

Please guys, my name is Aditya not Atidiya.

 

[Sachinfan98]

Lord of the Rings Tours 6-13 day Lord of the Rings Tour All inclusive - book online http://www.newzealand.com.au
I just saw this in the ads part just below my post

 

[barmyarmy]

WTH is that supposed to mean?
---
I am asking this for the last time - SHOULD I CLAIM?
Are we going for a mass-claim right now?
---
Still no FOS on anyone(from me). I think we should wait and see how the day unfolds rather than just hurrying and hastily lynching off a townie.
---
BKB, are you hinting that you are poisoned? Or is it barmy? I'm confused because BKB just said that his time is almost over in this game so I think he might be poisoned. But I think it is barmyarmy(80%) - If anyone has got a healing role please heal.

It looks like both BKB and I are poisoned. Irrelevant anyway as the healer/doctor was killed by the SK.
In terms of 'mass-claim' you're the only one left... I don't have any suspicions of you so you don't have to claim as far as I'm concerned. I do worry about your grasp of the game based on your posts though.

----------

Please guys, my name is Aditya not Atidiya.

I better correct your headstone then.

 

[Sachinfan98]

'I do worry about your grasp of the game based on your posts though.'
What does that mean?
---