I'm rebelling over being told what to do by sedition.
Seriously it's day 1 and there's very little analysis that can be done either of write-ups or players. I'm seeing and taking in though...
Mini Mafia - Town wins!
- Thread starter Gaurav_7
- Start date
I'm rebelling over being told what to do by sedition.
Seriously it's day 1 and there's very little analysis that can be done either of write-ups or players. I'm seeing and taking in though...
Sedition
Panel of Selectors
I've decided to give Manly a little more time 
I think I got my message across to everyone that I'm prepared to lynch him if he doesn't post, and I don't feel comfortable letting a lynch stand if I'm not watching closely.
I know accusing everyone muddies the water a bit for people looking back later, but if it encourages people to post when they wouldn't have otherwise, it's probably a good thing.
Interested to hear from PD again though since he's had some suspicions cast over him by someone other than me for once
I think I got my message across to everyone that I'm prepared to lynch him if he doesn't post, and I don't feel comfortable letting a lynch stand if I'm not watching closely.I know accusing everyone muddies the water a bit for people looking back later, but if it encourages people to post when they wouldn't have otherwise, it's probably a good thing.
Interested to hear from PD again though since he's had some suspicions cast over him by someone other than me for once
Sedition
Panel of Selectors
I'm rebelling over being told what to do by sedition.
Seriously it's day 1 and there's very little analysis that can be done either of write-ups or players. I'm seeing and taking in though...
Seeing, taking in, waiting for night when the game starts for you... Rather interesting that you say very little analysis can be done today, almost trying to discourage discussion. I seem to remember that in the last 2 games, a mafia could've been lynched on day 1 if people had put their set on the table.
Discussion is important; posting for the sake of posting isn't.
A mafia potentially could have been lynched on day 1 but it's high risk in a small game. Because we've started with 7 players and on day 1 we're not at MyLo but seeing as we only get one mislynch I'd clearly like to wait til we have more information before trying to get anyone.
A mafia potentially could have been lynched on day 1 but it's high risk in a small game. Because we've started with 7 players and on day 1 we're not at MyLo but seeing as we only get one mislynch I'd clearly like to wait til we have more information before trying to get anyone.
Sedition
Panel of Selectors
Hmm sharp. I'm sure that with all my activity and natural pro-town alignment that most are convinced I'm on their side. You, I'm not sure sure about, but we'll see.
Now that's a very scummy post...
hedger_14
ICC Chairman
As much as I still don't like barmy's fillerness (shut up, it's a word
), I have to agree there. Usually only mafia try to reinforce that they're town.And I don't think you're town much as well, and I'll reinforce my FOS on you.
FOS: Sedition
Sedition
Panel of Selectors
Isn't highlighting parts of someone's post one of the most scummiest things to do?
People will read enough of my posts to realise that I'm trying to help the town. Can't think of anything helpful you've posted so far, except maybe trying to silence me before others go deaf.
----------
Hmm well Hedger's back with the suspicion I thought you seemed alright after you responded earlier, but surely you can't both be mafia and revealing yourself this early. I'm inclined to think Hedger's read on me is still off and barmy is the mafia.
FOS: barmyarmy
People will read enough of my posts to realise that I'm trying to help the town. Can't think of anything helpful you've posted so far, except maybe trying to silence me before others go deaf.
----------
Hmm well Hedger's back with the suspicion
I thought you seemed alright after you responded earlier, but surely you can't both be mafia and revealing yourself this early. I'm inclined to think Hedger's read on me is still off and barmy is the mafia.FOS: barmyarmy
That means very little (and yes, I'll continue to highlight part of posts
).Of course mafia players are going to want to appear to be helping the town and day 1 is actually the best time to do that as there isn't really anything to talk about so views can't be used against you later.
I think you're far too keen to set yourself up as the confirmed townie trying to discover the mafia when there's no evidence at all that you are town. I've seen plenty of mafia players use the tactics you're using now. In your head you're probably thinking "I'm playing the same way as last time; that'll fool them."
By all means get discussion going but don't start making assertions or expecting others to follow them when you have nothing to base it on.
hedger_14
ICC Chairman
I'll always be there with suspicion. I'm wrong sometimes but usually, I'm not far off in my suspicions.
And also Sedition trying to push my suspicion away, just saying I'm off in my suspicions and again trying to put the suspicion back on Colin, although he's definitely not showing anything himself that he is town.
Anyway, I don't think there's too much else to discuss and I assume we're not going to lynch now so should we go ahead with the no lynch? The PR's should have enough to go into night 1 with some thoughts of who to check, and the longer we keep this discussion open, the more likely the mafia is of working out the PR's.
Although it would help if Manly was here...
And also Sedition trying to push my suspicion away, just saying I'm off in my suspicions and again trying to put the suspicion back on Colin, although he's definitely not showing anything himself that he is town.
Anyway, I don't think there's too much else to discuss and I assume we're not going to lynch now so should we go ahead with the no lynch? The PR's should have enough to go into night 1 with some thoughts of who to check, and the longer we keep this discussion open, the more likely the mafia is of working out the PR's.
Although it would help if Manly was here...
Sedition
Panel of Selectors
I don't expect anyone to follow my assertions at this stage, they will see them after I'm dead and confirmed town however.
I wouldn't continue to be suspicious if I didn't have anything to base it on, which is why I've left PD, Aditya, Hedger and Sim alone. I thought a player of your experience would have something to offer when the day started, but sadly not.
You've continued to be cagey, felt there was little to be accomplished today and made what I felt was a move to stifle discussion, now highlighting sections of posts. Plenty to be suspicious of above all others for me.
I wouldn't continue to be suspicious if I didn't have anything to base it on, which is why I've left PD, Aditya, Hedger and Sim alone. I thought a player of your experience would have something to offer when the day started, but sadly not.
You've continued to be cagey, felt there was little to be accomplished today and made what I felt was a move to stifle discussion, now highlighting sections of posts. Plenty to be suspicious of above all others for me.
hedger_14
ICC Chairman
Okay, well before it looks like I'm enjoying Day 1 of mafia games.
No Lynch
No Lynch
Ahoyhoy I'm here. Spent all day travelling yesterday so that's why I've not posted.
First thought: Sedition, C'MON MAN surely you're better than that?! Jheeeeeez!
My role is really terrible. (Mod: Can we roleclaim?) I will have no impact on the game whatsoever.
First thought: Sedition, C'MON MAN surely you're better than that?! Jheeeeeez!
My role is really terrible. (Mod: Can we roleclaim?) I will have no impact on the game whatsoever.
Similar threads
