Mini Mafia - Town wins!

[hedger_14]

Mod: Can we roleclaim?

I'd assume so, lol.

 

[barmyarmy]

I don't expect anyone to follow my assertions at this stage, they will see them after I'm dead and confirmed town however.

I wouldn't continue to be suspicious if I didn't have anything to base it on, which is why I've left PD, Aditya, Hedger and Sim alone. I thought a player of your experience would have something to offer when the day started, but sadly not.

You've continued to be cagey, felt there was little to be accomplished today and made what I felt was a move to stifle discussion, now highlighting sections of posts. Plenty to be suspicious of above all others for me.

There is little to be accomplished on day 1 and no-one has really offered anything useful imo.
I've never tried to stifle useful discussion just tried to point out to you what useful discussion actually is.

 

[puddleduck]

Also, I find this post a bit scummy. Seems to be PD is eager to get a bandwagon on someone going, so could be mafia and trying to get an early lynch on a townie.

Well in both previous games I've made it very clear I'm a gambling man who would potentially condone a first day lynch. This of course depends on what people have said and I'd hardly want to be a tool for the mafia... or just a tool in general Since in both those games a first day lynch of my choosing would have hit mafia and my second day lynch/second day investigation hit mafia I'd suggest both you and Aditya either haven't paid enough attention to the last two games, or are mafia and both worried I'll out you two like I did previous mafias...

FOS: Hedger and Aditya

Massively leaning towards the no lynch though, as I thought I made clear in the post that apparently made me suspicious

----------

I think I'll find it hard to believe whatever role Manly claims seeing as I'm pretty sure the last game he played he invented a post restriction and stuck to it haha

Guessing he's gonna claim Granny or something

 

[Aditya]

Look Puddleduck, I didn't follow your first game so I don't know what you did in it. In the last game, your gamble did work and I was indeed mafia but it's not like your gamble is always gonna work. Your point makes no sense to me. The point here is, you should take gambles but it's totally unacceptable if you go after members even if you have nothing to prove that they are mafia, that's only done when you're mafia yourself. In the last game, my posts were scummy and hence you went after me. What about in this game? Who according to you has done anything suspicious, if anyone at all has.

So far you and Sedition are trying to go after Colin for no reason and trying to put him under pressure so that he commits a mistake. Seriously, both of you are sounding as if you're working together. Both of you, are looking for unnecessary reasons to lynch someone and hence you post that you'd even ready to follow a bandwagon blindly, which isn't something that you should do, bandwagons in mafia games are only done on day 1, when the game has about 15-20 players playing. Not in games where there are just 7 players playing.

 

[simsanta123]

I have no problem with everyone going for a no lynch, but putting pressure lynches on people often leads them to make mistakes, maybe become very defensive, or retaliating unexpectedly. I am very surprised and a bit concerned at Hedger's accusation.

Also, I find this post a bit scummy. Seems to be PD is eager to get a bandwagon on someone going, so could be mafia and trying to get an early lynch on a townie.

I know I'll come across as defending PD, but I strongly believe in that too. I have been reading mafia games on FM, (yeah, I've nothing much to do and pass my time reading about mafia), and in nearly all of them, the usual convention is to put random lynches on people, and then see how they react and see who jumps onto the bandwagon and then as the day goes on, the lynches become less random and more based on the above written stuff. Accepting that their days are 3 weeks, , so they have a lot of time, I see no harm in trying something of this sort here too, and see how much we can learn. Settle for a no lynch in the end by all means, but not without grilling a few people.

So for more effectiveness,
Lynch Hedger (Coz Foses are a bit mild.) for straightway accusing PD of something which makes not a lot of sense. If he is mafia, he would be found out very easily, if he leads a strong lynch on a later proved townie.

----------

Also, if we all do try to put lynches on people, we'll have to make sure they stay at L-2 max. We can't risk someone accidently or deliberately lynching off on a pressure lynch.

----------

Both of you, are looking for unnecessary reasons to lynch someone and hence you post that you'd even ready to follow a bandwagon blindly, which isn't something that you should do, bandwagons in mafia games are only done on day 1, when the game has about 15-20 players playing. Not in games where there are just 7 players playing.

I hadn't considered that point. It is true most of the games I read had more than 7 players. Still, we always have the no-lynch option in the end, if nobody is looking very scummy.

----------

And err..who is Colin?

 

[puddleduck]

Except Adi I haven't actually accused Barmy of anything really have I? I made a vague joke about potentially accusing him if he did explain things for Sedition. Not really sure why the aggression on your side, unless yet again you're feeling the pressure of being mafia and not doing a good job of masking it...

All I've said really is that in both previous games I've been certainly keen for a first day lynch but have accepted the sensible move of a no lynch (again I think you'll find I actually suggest a no lynch as well). I'm not ruling out a lynch though, and only a potential mafia would rule it out I feel.

FOS: Aditya

 

[Aditya]

It's not exactly a rule that we can bandwagon only in games in which 15-20 players are playing. Though, going for a bandwagon on the very first day of the game, in a 7 player game doesn't sound right to me. I can only see the mafia's doing so because they know who they don't want to lynch but as far as townies are concern, even a single wrong lynch can change the whole game around.

Haha, Colin is Barmyarmy.

----------

Pressure? Are you kidding me? I don't see myself being aggressive in this game either. If I was being aggressive, I'd have lynched you which I haven't. I've just put a fos on you and Sedition because I feel both of you are working as a team. My suspicious is more on Sedition than you. It has been Sedition who has looked for more reasons to lynch someone or the other but then your point of following a bandwagon does go along with his point. Alright, I might be judging you wrong here, so tell me what do you think of Sedition in this game so far?

 

[Gaurav_7]

Vote count

Hedger (1) - Sim
No Lynch (1) - Hedger

48 hours from now for the day to end.

 

[puddleduck]

Alright, I might be judging you wrong here, so tell me what do you think of Sedition in this game so far?

I think he's been like he has been in the last game, which is to say accusatory I fully agree with pressure lynches and potentially even a bandwagon if I feel they have the right person, however he hasn't really hit on anything yet, and hell, even a bandwagon lynch on Sedition would be pretty amusing. If only because he's so desperate for a first day lynch ha

----------

I'll join Hedger in actually submitting a No Lynch as well. At this point there's little to go on, but perhaps enough to start figuring out who might be guilty of what depending on what goes down tonight.

Got an early idea as to who might be mafia, but the list is currently 6 people long, so not very helpful haha

 

[Manly]

I'll go along with a NO LYNCH as well, there's not much to be gleaned from Day 1s, just people mudslinging (if that's even a term).

 

[Sedition]

Funny how people are jumping to defend others rather than letting the accused do it themselves I was hoping we'd hear from PD and Sim before the day ended, and I'm not surprised that neither are all that suspicious of me so far.

Aditya's definitely scummy every time he posts, but I have more of a town vibe from him this time. Obviously he's going to be a little more conscious though.

Out of barmyarmy & Hedger, one, if not both is definitely mafia. So if it comes down to the final 3, and one of these guys remains, lynch'em

 

[hedger_14]

Since in both those games a first day lynch of my choosing would have hit mafia and my second day lynch/second day investigation hit mafia I'd suggest both you and Aditya either haven't paid enough attention to the last two games, or are mafia and both worried I'll out you two like I did previous mafias...

So you're fos'ing me for using meta of your own play from a previous game.... And even though I shrug it off like it's nothing, it's nothing I can defend myself from since you actually don't have anything on it, more like you're fos'ing for the sake of it.

the usual convention is to put random lynches on people, and then see how they react

Not to mention the amount of claims that normally come out day 1 and half of them town, so while the final result may be the killing of a mafia, the rest of the mafia will know 2-4 other roles from people who have been pushed on day 1 and forced to claim, which does help the mafia in the long run.

So really, lynching me for pointing out what is a scummy post doesn't make sense. Not to mention, barmy pointed it out first yet you've said nothing. So maybe you and barmy for a team?

And you seem to have been very quiet today, and just seemed to use Manly's inactivity as a cover to not post much at all. But anyway, nl now. There's enough for PR's to go on and really forcing out claims with the likelihood of a resulting NL is stupid so yeah.

 

[simsanta123]

Well..if we all are going for a no lynch. Then fine, No Lynch from my side also.

So really, lynching me for pointing out what is a scummy post doesn't make sense. Not to mention, barmy pointed it out first yet you've said nothing. So maybe you and barmy for a team?

And you seem to have been very quiet today, and just seemed to use Manly's inactivity as a cover to not post much at all. But anyway, nl now. There's enough for PR's to go on and really forcing out claims with the likelihood of a resulting NL is stupid so yeah.

I didn't notice that barmy too said the same thing. My apologies.

Anyhow, I never used Manly's inactivity as a cover. I have posted a couple of times and I usually post longer posts than multiple smaller ones. And how have I grown very quiet? Time-zones...i was sleeping for the last 8 hours or so.

But still, we have had quite a bit of discussion considering its day 1 and thats good for the game.

----------

oh..
Unlynch Hedger
No Lynch

 

[Gaurav_7]

Vote count

No Lynch (4) - Hedger, PD, Manly, Sim

It was a long day for the town as everyone wanted to know what others feel and there were accusations everywhere. However, most of the people thought it was fair to keep everyone alive at this early stage. It was decided there wouldn't be a lynch for today and it was night heading their way.

It is now Night 1.

You have 24 hours to send in your roles.

I won't mind people posting at night but, I hope it doesn't go overboard.

 

[hedger_14]

Spam to piss off User