hedger_14
ICC Chairman
Remember that this isn't classic setup so there could well be a different PR, and even not a cop, so that logic probably doesn't really apply.
Mini Mafia - Town wins!
- Thread starter Gaurav_7
- Start date
Remember that this isn't classic setup so there could well be a different PR, and even not a cop, so that logic probably doesn't really apply.
Yup, it could be a town roleblocker who prevented the kill in which case he can claim and we can get the godfather.
I've been thinking of this as a classic setup but even if it isn't I still think the cop should claim. Possibly there's an individual in the game or something.
I've been thinking of this as a classic setup but even if it isn't I still think the cop should claim. Possibly there's an individual in the game or something.
puddleduck
Chairman of Selectors
Further, it says only one role was succesful, so Barmy, how exactly have you decided that both the cop and doc were successful?
hedger_14
ICC Chairman
dat post edit barmy 
And the one role being successful probably indicates that cop got an inno report, or maybe was roleblocked.
And the one role being successful probably indicates that cop got an inno report, or maybe was roleblocked.
I was assuming classic setup and no-one died. As hedger says there may be a roleblocker.
hedger_14
ICC Chairman
and btw, if we mass claim, and there are cop cc's and doc in uncc'd, then doc dies at night and we're nowhere and the only clear is the doc's save.
dat post edit barmy
And the one role being successful probably indicates that cop got an inno report, or maybe was roleblocked.
I wrote doc instead of cop and changed it very quickly. Shouldn't have done, sorry...
Having a mafia godfather and roleblocker is quite a common setup. However if the mafia blocked the cop then they know who he is and the town don't so all the more reason to claim.
----------
If someone CCs cop then great, we know one of them if mafia. I know this is a non-classic setup but we're still in the strong position that we can actually mislynch. I'd just rather mislynch based on good information rather than guessing.
hedger_14
ICC Chairman
yeah, I saw it change, haha. And I think you added something about the individual or that might have been there in the first place.
puddleduck
Chairman of Selectors
I don't really understand why Sedition is so sure about this whole must be a "godfather" thing. Personally I think he's had more direction in his accusations this time, so I can't help but feel that he could even be the godfather if there is one. Or coming up with some kind of new mafia setup to distance himself from it?
User also said "someone is popular" which I guess means a lot of roles occured on one person with blocks, counter blocks and whatever?
User also said "someone is popular" which I guess means a lot of roles occured on one person with blocks, counter blocks and whatever?
Nah, just the one-word edit
----------
Well I've never heard of a mafia setup without a godfather.
Sedition's play I'm putting down to inexperience. He's been so aggressive in his posting that if he had actually picked on the right people he'd probably be dead.
puddleduck
Chairman of Selectors
Although Barmy has now suggested while I was typing that a godfather is actually normal in these types of games, which means I'm now basically useless haha as I have no idea what a godfather and the other power roles can do or might be. Bugger, I'm lost haha
hedger_14
ICC Chairman
Yeah, I think that's probably what happened. So there could be a chance doc saved town, who was investigated by the cop and since mafia killed that player, that player was popular
And godfather is a mafia who turns up town upon investigation. It really makes cop close to useless in such a small game, since you just have to scumhunt, and you can potentially clear the godfather.
And tbh, I think cop should claim. I find it so much easier when there's a clear, and knowing that person is actually telling the truth, rather than agreeing with someone and then later realise he could well be mafia and change your own perspective on the game often.
Reading this again it does imply that the cop actually failed. The one that had the correct effect has to be the one that prevented the kill. I would assume doctor unless someone claims otherwise.
The plural is also interesting. How did one succeed and more than one not?
If we had a mafia roleblocked who had blocked the cop hie role would have succeeded as well as the doctors.
I can't quite imagine the series of events and roles that could produce that sentence (unless User is using artistic license).
puddleduck
Chairman of Selectors
Nah, just the one-word edit
----------
Well I've never heard of a mafia setup without a godfather.
Sedition's play I'm putting down to inexperience. He's been so aggressive in his posting that if he had actually picked on the right people he'd probably be dead.
So is classic mafia a different game to this then?!? Oh dear god, I feel like I've turned up to school naked haha I'm pretty baffled at the moment. Both the last two games had just 2 mafia members right? So am I now to believe that even the mafia aren't set up how I had assumed?
Yeah, I think that's probably what happened. So there could be a chance doc saved town, who was investigated by the cop and since mafia killed that player, that player was popular
That would mean that the doc and cop were successful though whereas the write-up implies that only one was.
Similar threads
