Mini Mafia - Town wins!

[hedger_14]

I'm still unsure if he is just inexperienced or whether he is trying to trip us up by playing a very similar game to last time but this time as mafia.

I didn't overly read last game but at least last time, his accusations seemed legit. This time, he seems to be trying to play the same game but since most of it is for the sake of it, he can't give any evidence.

You just can't help cherry picking other people's posts can you Hedger? I'm a noob and this thread has exploded with a lot of stuff I'm not understanding and I can't contribute anything until I hear from guys I suspected were also town

Again, no defence, just trying to deflect off my suspicion as either being the fact I'm maf or town and I'm wrong in my accusations. I could well be wrong, but you aren't doing to make me think otherwise.

 

[puddleduck]

Looking back at the start of the thread, and User said roles won't be revealed on death. Does that change anything gameplay wise Barmy? Like Sedition has said, to be fair to him, having started to feel comfortable in the past 2 games I am now kind of lost as well. So, the fact that even a death won't give us the role, surely means claiming is potentially dodgy? Or does it make it more important so we can figure it out while they are alive?

Urgh, this would be a lot easier with a mafia thread and already knowing that 5 of you were town. Mafia is clearly easier, I'm bored of being a good guy haha

 

[Sedition]

I didn't overly read last game but at least last time, his accusations seemed legit. This time, he seems to be trying to play the same game but since most of it is for the sake of it, he can't give any evidence.



Again, no defence, just trying to deflect off my suspicion as either being the fact I'm maf or town and I'm wrong in my accusations. I could well be wrong, but you aren't doing to make me think otherwise.

My accusations seemed legit last game, yet you thought I was mafia? Didn't you also say we should move on from what happened last game? Someone's not getting their story straight.

You've gone after me from the beginning and jumped to barmyarmy's defence all too frequently, saying my accusations are baseless and yet casting the same at me? Seem to remember to trying to throw suspicion barmy's way in the end once it came your way from Puddleduck, Sim and myself.

 

[hedger_14]

Looking back at the start of the thread, and User said roles won't be revealed on death.

That awkward moment when I didn't realise that. Is alignment still revealed on death? Otherwise, this is ---- since we can't look into lynch patterns and as I have an idea that if one person is maf, then so will the other, no alignment revealed on death won't help.

 

[barmyarmy]

Alignments will be revealed so if someone claims and is CCed we'll still know if we got the right person.

----------

@hedger - I assume alignment will. I've never played a game where not.

 

[puddleduck]

Ah k cool. So it will say Town aligned or Mafia aligned? It just won't say whether they were Doc or Cop or whatever the hell the mafia is in this game

 

[hedger_14]

My accusations seemed legit last game, yet you thought I was mafia? Didn't you also say we should move on from what happened last game? Someone's not getting their story straight.

You've gone after me from the beginning and jumped to barmyarmy's defence all too frequently, saying my accusations are baseless and yet casting the same at me? Seem to remember to trying to throw suspicion barmy's way in the end once it came your way from Puddleduck, Sim and myself.

I thought you were maf cause I was sure it was one of you/puddle, and puddle juts seemed more townie and I hadn't seen you play before. And lol, I only brought up last game cause barmy mentioned it.

I don't think I've defended barmy at all tbqh. He's town imo which is why I haven't pushed on him but I definitely haven't been defending him.

Alignments will be revealed so if someone claims and is CCed we'll still know if we got the right person.

Good, that makes it easier.

----------

Seem to remember to trying to throw suspicion barmy's way in the end once it came your way from Puddleduck, Sim and myself.

And sorry, that post doesn't make sense (grammar wise), so could you re-word that.

 

[puddleduck]

Well it's a good thing Barmy is alive as I'd be even more confused. I also feel he's given the only particularly strong town vibes so far. Which is interesting, as he's also probably the person I'd most want to not trust.

 

[Sedition]

Seem to remember you trying to throw suspicion barmy's way in the end once it came your way from Puddleduck, Sim and myself.

 

[hedger_14]

Seem to remember you trying to throw suspicion barmy's way in the end once it came your way from Puddleduck, Sim and myself.

No, I would disagree. I haven't tried throwing the suspicion, I defended myself and I've put suspicion on you - which was the reason you started fos'ing me in the first place..

And puddle fos'd me? I don't remember that. I might go reread.

 

[puddleduck]

Damn right Hedger, ain't trusting you, ain't trusting nobody... except Barmy at the moment, as he seems town

 

[Sedition]

Yes, do some reading. It might help calm your frenzy. I see you were the first to mention this roleblocker thing that has caused a lot of confusion. Do you know something? Did you block someone or were you blocked?

 

[puddleduck]

Fancy quoting it Sedition to make it relevant? I happen to think any of the people who decided roleblockers etc might be involved first may have done so off the back of being assigned the role. Likewise though it's my reasoning for having you as potential mafia due to the fact you were the first to decide mafia could be a different setup, which as someone else new to all this, I don't really know how you came to the conclusion unless you were part of it.

 

[hedger_14]

It might help calm your frenzy.

lol, this is a frenzy? Pretty sure I've been making a calm argument, rather than rageing at you and trying to put it on you that you are mafia no matter what and nothing will make me change that view.

And no, I don't. But mafia roleblocker is the most common mafia power role along with godfather on here.

----------

And Aditya's been viewing the thread for a while

 

[Aditya]

Well so far Sim, Manly and Adi are the only 3 not to have posted. I would assume that one of them must be the cop as no one has cast any suspicions. That leaves the rather strange thought though that unless both mafia are the other 2, then at least one of them is already posting.

What if, none of the above three are mafia and instead, the mafia's are already posting? That could be a possibly, right? I wouldn't read too much into these tactics, I'd just say that it's great that mafia failed to kill someone, good job to whoever the doc is. As someone already posted, this does mean that there is a doc in this game and not two cops.

It's about time Manly posts something useful. Manly has been on the suspicious side but in all the games that I've played with him, he usually is a little suspicious so I cannot judge him but again, he needs to be more active and Sim too. Sim, hasn't done anything suspicious except for lynching Hedger who he later unlynched after Hedger provided a defense but I'd like him to be a little more active in the discussion, he has somehow not been very active but still has got away with the suspicion.

Aditya's definitely scummy every time he posts, but I have more of a town vibe from him this time. Obviously he's going to be a little more conscious though.

That's what Sedition posted just before the end of day 1. Sedition, if you could explain, how have I been scummy in this game and yet how am I also giving town vibes?