Whoa..lot of discussion in just an hour. Nice.
Anyhow, starting from the night post, (And I might end up repeating some things, coz I?m quoting and writing as I go)
Someone's very popular!
The roles were used. One had the correct effect while others not. The town were pleased as they were all alive. However, some of them were pretending, definitely!
Many roles on one person seems obvious. And only one of them had the correct effect, which could be the doctor, since we don?t see a night kill.
That means that that doc knows someone who is innocent and the cop knows someone who is innocent or guilty.
If the cop has a scum result he needs to roleclaim as the doc can protect him tonight.
The cop could have got an innocent report otherwise I don?t see how only one role was successful. But then is getting an innocent report not successful? It?s a fine line and User could have taken some liberties maybe.
Remember that this isn't classic setup so there could well be a different PR, and even not a cop, so that logic probably doesn't really apply.
Yes, that?s true. Hadn?t considered that. But a mafia game without a cop would be very unusual wouldn?t it?
And the one role being successful probably indicates that cop got an inno report, or maybe was roleblocked.
Oh, same thing. Couldn?t have been roleblocked tho coz then he would also have been successful.
And I think Sim could be 2nd maf. He, just seemed to jump on Sedition's accusations on me, which didn't even use much logic so he could well be buddying to try and get suspicion on me.
Actually I was supporting PD, I don?t know if Sedition also accused you. And it was more of a pressure lynch as I was working on getting some discussion going.
About the godfather thing though - As I said yesterday, I felt starting at day gave us an advantage we didn't have in the previous two games (just a personal feeling from a noob, did you not get that or aren't you town?).
Thereby I felt either the town were weaker than the standard setup, or the mafia were stronger. If we do have a cop along with our doc, then I feel the mafia must have a godfather.
I'm a noob and this thread has exploded with a lot of stuff I'm not understanding and I can't contribute anything until I hear from guys I suspected were also town (Aditya and Sim).
Likewise though it's my reasoning for having you as potential mafia due to the fact you were the first to decide mafia could be a different setup, which as someone else new to all this, I don't really know how you came to the conclusion unless you were part of it.
I am a bit suspicious of Sedition. In a couple of posts he has implied that the mafia could have a godfather, which though in itself is not surprising, yet his later posts saying he is a complete noob, seem a but fishy as to the thought process of a newer player. Hiding behind your inexperience is not something beneficial to anyone.
Hedger, barmyarmy, and PD all have done a fair bit of analysis and are giving me town vibes, whereas I haven't read a lot from Aditya and Manly so can't comment on them.
Right now,
FOS : Sedition.
