Mini Mafia - Town wins!

[hedger_14]

Christ, being the cop in the last game was fun, I already knew stuff

lol, if you go look at WWE mafia, you'll see I disagree. It just put me off as I thought the godfather was clear and the confirmed miller actually turned maf so I was relying on reports and we kept lynching off townies -_-

So I prefer to not be a power role anyway. Bullet Proof is the best though, considering I usually get killed at night (Well I've never been lynched as town and I only have like 1/2 wins as town...)

 

[puddleduck]

lol, if you go look at WWE mafia, you'll see I disagree. It just put me off as I thought the godfather was clear and the confirmed miller actually turned maf so I was relying on reports and we kept lynching off townies -_-

So I prefer to not be a power role anyway. Bullet Proof is the best though, considering I usually get killed at night (Well I've never been lynched as town and I only have like 1/2 wins as town...)

I'll be honest, that's pretty funny haha. So I guess the very real prospect in this game does exist then that if there is a Godfather, it was in fact him the cop investigated last night? In fact, could Users writeup have said that the Cop hit the Godfather but it turned up Town (failed). The doc protected the Cop (success), and the Mafia targetted the Cop (failed)?

 

[Aditya]

I find this to be a suspicious post because it doesn't engage other than to accuse other people and divert suspicion

I was just replying to Puddleduck, he was saying that out of the remaining members who at that time had not posted, he said that there could be possibility of the 2 mafia's being from the three members who have not posted. I just stated the point that obviously there is also the change that there could be 2 mafia's from the members that are posting. I wasn't accusing anyone or trying to divert suspicion, I was just replying to Puddleduck's post because he had just posted about one possibility and not the other.

 

[puddleduck]

One of my worries so far, is I've been so convinced that Barmy is town that he may be slipping through the cracks for day/night in terms of lynches, and will be aware that he can then start killing off the people as the roles make sense. Not to mention everyone in this game has now played before, so I have the feeling his gloves are off so to speak.

 

[barmyarmy]

My gloves are definitely on. It's freezing here. 5oC in May.

 

[puddleduck]

No one in Scotland wears gloves without being chased across the border. He's definitely lying

(Yeah, it's bleeding cold today, not fun ha)

 

[Sedition]

Hopefully this isn't premature, but having gone over the possibilities, and the fact almost everyone is heading down the wrong track, I feel my information for today and tonight will put us in a very good position, though not perfect. And yeah I'm sacrificing myself again, something which seems foreign everyone else.

I am the Jailkeeper. I both protect AND block my target's action. Because of this, results can't always be certain, however I took measures to make sure I was confident in what my result meant.

Ending Day 1, my main suspicions rested on barmyarmy and Hedger (as I posted before the close), but also Puddleduck, whom I avoided accusing so I didn't look a raving lunatic again and also to help protect myself from him.

Of these 3 people, the main scum to me was Hedger, and if you reread the thread, specifically mine and Hedger's banter, you will see my reasons. He was also the least likely person of these 3 that the mafia would kill, since he had suspicion cast on him from myself, Sim and PD before the close of day. Mafia is going to want to keep such a person around.

I gave a greater chance of barmy and PD being town, so targeting them and getting the blocked result would leave me undecided. Also, if barmy is town, I thought he was a decent chance of being killed for experience reasons and my suspicion would no longer be on him.

So, my target was Hedger and if the kill was blocked, there would be no doubt in my mind that he's mafia. Lo and behold, the kill was blocked. From the write-up, "Someone's popular... only one had the correct effect". My belief is that Hedger was targeted by both the cop and myself, however the cop's result was incorrect because Hedger is the Godfather.

What happens now? Cop should definitely not claim, to leave the mafia guessing. We lynch Hedger and tonight I will most likely target Puddleduck and if the kill is not blocked, he's clean. The cop will do a search on someone other than PD and confirm them as town/mafia.

The mafia have 3 options:

1. Don't kill anyone - Gives us a free cop search and I can still target PD the following night.
2. Kill me - The cop gets a result, and we know PD is clean because the kill wouldn't have succeeded with me targetting.
3. Kill cop - This would probably be the best move imo, which is why he shouldn't claim and leave them guessing. If the kill succeeds on the cop, PD is clean and I get to target another person the following night.

Now if there's a third party, I could be really screwed, but I feel we won't get anywhere today if I don't clear up what I know.

----------

Sorry, I meant to bold certain names and stuff and forgot Can I edit?

----------

I see you're the first to come along and see this revelation Hedge.. Not so clever now are we?

 

[hedger_14]

He was also the least likely person of these 3 that the mafia would kill, since he had suspicion cast on him from myself, Sim and PD before the close of day. Mafia is going to want to keep such a person around.

That's where I stand to disagree. PD's suspicion didn't even seem that much, sim's barely made sense and it was just you, who is probably maf. So there's a good possibility mafia would kill me.

And I also soft-claimed a power role yesterday, to bring the kill so even if you are jailkeeper, you probably protected me from the kill.

Also, if I was mafia, the smartest move of mine would be to have claimed guilty on you as cop. As I am 90% certain I could have gotten you lynched after that, and continual suspicion.

----------

So you're either jailkeeper and protected me from the kill or you're the mafia roleblocker.

----------

And mafia know the cop if Sedition is maf, since he roleblocked the cop most likely, so that's probably why he doesn't want cop to out, so he can kill him at night.

 

[Sedition]

I think we've both posted enough for others to decide, you can continue grasping at straws, but I'm not interested in scumtalk.

 

[hedger_14]

lmao, and you're the most scummiest player here, apart from maybe Manly who isn't posting at all.

And all I want to say is that if you are town, you are retarded and maybe should learn to scumhunt first before starting to play mafia games.

 

[barmyarmy]

Jailkeeper can be both a town and mafia role.
Are there any scenarios whereby both sedition and hedger are town? Don't want to give a free kill to the mafia here.

 

[Manly]

Be with you soon chaps, just reading about 6 pages!

 

[Sedition]

If you're trying to hammer in the point that you're town by calling me retarded then that's pretty lame. Maybe you should've claimed cop if that's what you are, because I don't see any other possibility..

 

[Manly]

I've had a read, and it's fair enough to be suspicious of me, but I was having a wander around my old school, saying 'ahoyhoy' to all the old teachers. But that's by the by.

The fact that we're all still alive is a bonus, obviously, and the write-up, as you've all pointed out, there was one "correct" effect, and I've no reason to disbelieve what Sedition's said about jailkeeping hedger, just as there's no reason to disbelieve hedger's defence, if you get me.. How wonderful for anyone reading along!

I don't have a post restriction, I'm going to come straight out and say that I am a vanilla townie, hence the lack of impact I'll be having on the game. Literally all I can do is listen to you all and vote accordingly when I've been convinced either way.

Hedger: post 116, what did you think I am?


Anyone any questions for me?

 

[puddleduck]

Hmm... very confused now. Interested to hear what Manly has to say now though. Need to think about Seditions claim a bit, as this is either a very honest move or an incredibly good lie.

----------

I can't help but feel Sedition and Manly might be mafia together. That said, this is an important lynch, and a mislynch could still be ok.

I think I'd need Barmy to help me out here! I'm pretty much prepared to lynch any of them since it seems we're still in a fairly good position. This chat leads me to believe Barmy definitely is town. I'd almost suggest lynching Manly, just because as a vanilla town claim he could well be the least felt loss if he is actually town. Willing to bow to your opinions on this though as I've made quite clear so far, I don't really have anything in this game