Chewie
BCCI President
Papa Smurf's suspicions on me are just that. Suspicions. He has no hard evidence for going for me, but he can't go for either of BKB or Chez because their roles are basically set in stone, so he has to find some reason to target me. I still don't see why you didn't lynch me right away - it's as if you're waiting for someone else to go first so you don't seem so out of place. I don't see how BKB could be anything else but townie because of his unlynchableness so that reason didn't really make sense.
Re Smurf being townie. Random lynch of Mark doesn't really mean anything. I don't really see how that can be a decisively town or mafia aligned move, it sits in the middle for me. I just find it a really weird thing for a townie to do. With regards to the User lynch, Smurf may have wanted all the glory for himself, and sacrificed his team mate. He could see that MaD was going hard for User, and figured that he was the cop. Because of this he knew that User was going to die anyway so he may as well jump on the lynch bandwagon early on so he doesn't look so suspicious.
As well as this, Papa Smurf has been the one who has consistently referred to MaD as the cop, even though MaD said that he wasn't the cop (and it was a fact that we had not definitively confirmed until MaD's death since he never role claimed). I find this move suspicious as well - Varun did it in the Simpsons mafia and he was mafia then.
I have been aggressive towards Papa Smurf for much of the game to be honest. He was always at the top of my suspects list, and was the main reason why I didn't lynch Callum - I didn't think he was nearly as suspicious as Papa Smurf was. This is why I lynched Papa Smurf straight away today. I've been going on at him for the past few days, and the death of Callum doesn't really change my point of view that Papa Smurf is mafia. Also I wanted to generate conversation since nothing seemed to be happening.
(I was online for 5 minutes this morning to read the important threads here. Read this one then logged out before Smurf posted that we were all online)
Re Smurf being townie. Random lynch of Mark doesn't really mean anything. I don't really see how that can be a decisively town or mafia aligned move, it sits in the middle for me. I just find it a really weird thing for a townie to do. With regards to the User lynch, Smurf may have wanted all the glory for himself, and sacrificed his team mate. He could see that MaD was going hard for User, and figured that he was the cop. Because of this he knew that User was going to die anyway so he may as well jump on the lynch bandwagon early on so he doesn't look so suspicious.
As well as this, Papa Smurf has been the one who has consistently referred to MaD as the cop, even though MaD said that he wasn't the cop (and it was a fact that we had not definitively confirmed until MaD's death since he never role claimed). I find this move suspicious as well - Varun did it in the Simpsons mafia and he was mafia then.
I have been aggressive towards Papa Smurf for much of the game to be honest. He was always at the top of my suspects list, and was the main reason why I didn't lynch Callum - I didn't think he was nearly as suspicious as Papa Smurf was. This is why I lynched Papa Smurf straight away today. I've been going on at him for the past few days, and the death of Callum doesn't really change my point of view that Papa Smurf is mafia. Also I wanted to generate conversation since nothing seemed to be happening.
(I was online for 5 minutes this morning to read the important threads here. Read this one then logged out before Smurf posted that we were all online)
You know you've got nothing concrete when you resort to these arguments. In fact, earlier on, whenever I posted something on my defence, your counter-argument was always, to paraphrase, "this is a coomon ploy we often see from the mafia". 
