PC Graphics Maker Championship Season 8 | Final Round - R#10 Results + Season Summary!

Which is the best entry?


  • Total voters
    15
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
Loving entry 6, marvelous execution! the text is perfect, the shape behind it of the same colour of the kit makes it look even great! the blurring and smudging is nice. What I love in it is the innovation. :thumbs
 
I would loved to read the thoughts from the panelists on the entries.
 
Here are my thoughts. Not considered in the final panel ratings.

1- Perfect entry, loved the BG and textures around the arms. I'd give it a 9.5

2- Like the effects on the boot an on the text. A sans serif text would have looked much better, and a bit more enchancements could be done. A different stock shoud have been used. I'd give it 6.5

3- Good idea and effects. But the stock seems really LQ. Too many focals and the text isn't special. 5.5/10

4- Overuse of textures,but neither Rizwan nor I had time to remove them :p I'd give it a 7/10 (might be partial :p)

5- Decent use of splatter but using a clipping mask over it would have elevated it to a next level. 4/10

6- Great use of smudge, great effect and good text. 8/10

7- Looks decent. Needed better texts,and a few textures around Messi's body. A lot can be improved. I'd give it a 4.5
 
2- Like the effects on the boot an on the text. A sans serif text would have looked much better, and a bit more enchancements could be done. A different stock shoud have been used. I'd give it 6.5

The problem is there ain't too many good stocks available from Eusebio and Muller's hey days.
 
Entry 2 deserved better in terms of votes imo. It was a great entry - good use of effects in the black and white stock with the lighting effects, and also the golden boot and the text. A few things though - the separate photos on the left and right could have been blended in with the background rather than being just 'floating' there. Also the overall focal point could have been a little smaller and in the center. Great effort from both of you! :thumbs

Thanks dude BTW CONGO
 
Wow,those results didn't shock me,although I also think that e2 deserved much more.That was a great effort by the makers.

The next round topic seems favourable :p
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Top