I didn't ask from you Pranav dear.I asked it from KBC
I think there must be a poll for this,I have explain the problem which I have if there are less people who are having the same problem then ok fine make render as a judging part GMOTW.
A complete piece of graphics doesn't always show a complete detail of a render,your bad render may work for you if you cover it with good texture and etc etc.
So for me render and graphics are different field.
Even from the pranav signature who can tell that it was a smooth cut or not but you have made the whole signature so well.
So judging a render from a whole piece will be foolishness.
There may be another idea that all GMOTW participants also submit there render with there work but again the thing is same a elite render may not be the best graphics maker and a elite graphics maker may not a good renderer so if we judge them all,we are mixing talents and most of the time a render will be disappoint because he cuts an image so well but couldn't able to convert it into a master piece and will lose both his render and graphics.
You may have an example Ahad,he is an elite renderer and will be a top gun in an only render competition,but on merging it with graphics his rank may fall.
Hope all of you will be able to get my point.