Puddle Mafia 03 - Endgame

[Varun]

Disappointed. I had called for the tracker/watcher to claim more than enough, and he should have claimed last day. But I understand though, why he stayed quiet. I believe he tracked Sedition on Night 2 or Night 1, and Sedition figured he was the tracker.

I was putting Manly down as the SK, but there might be a mafia here. Last time, it was a Saulus so as to make the game balanced, so this time there might be a similar convertible player. Zhuorb and User come to mind, and I trust BKB and Aditya completely. So, it is either only the SK remaining (most possibly Manly), or the SK and a last non-converted mafia remaining or else the SK and a last converted mafia remaining.

What were your results BKB? I hope you didn't investigated thedon.

Manly, what does your role do? Did you follow that link I posted?

----------

Didn't read your post above. I don't believe you.

Lynch:Manly

----------

*investigate

I'm such a Grammar Nazi.

 

[Manly]

My initial role was more based on the fact PD knows I love a beer or 10, and it was a good way of making it so I can still have an interesting game rather than being stuck as vanilla. There was no roleblocking element despite what the wiki said, it was a way of explaining why I was without role initially.


I could take any role that was night killed, I could quite as easily have become Prostitute.

----------

What's a Saulus?

 

[Aditya]

I don't believe Manly, although I would like to know BKB's views first. Hopefully, he investigated someone else but not thedon.

 

[Varun]

My initial role was more based on the fact PD knows I love a beer or 10, and it was a good way of making it so I can still have an interesting game rather than being stuck as vanilla. There was no roleblocking element despite what the wiki said, it was a way of explaining why I was without role initially.

It seems to me more like you came up with this role because you were drunk, haha. So what actually the 'Town Drunk' role did? You say the roleblocking element wasn't there, so what's left?

Saulus (or the Vampire) is a role which on being night targeted converts into mafia.

 

[Varun]

My initial role was more based on the fact PD knows I love a beer or 10, and it was a good way of making it so I can still have an interesting game rather than being stuck as vanilla. There was no roleblocking element despite what the wiki said, it was a way of explaining why I was without role initially.

It seems to me more like you came up with this role because you were drunk, haha. So what actually the 'Town Drunk' role did? You say the roleblocking element wasn't there, so what's left?

Saulus (or the Vampire) is a role which on being night targeted converts into mafia.

----------

Oops, double post.

 

[Manly]

The town drunk was essentially a vanilla with a fancy name so PD could introduce my new role at a later time. There were no ways I could affect the game until I assumed whichever role I chose.

 

[Varun]

Still don't trust you, let's see what others have to say. Half of the players are still to post.

 

[ved_]

I guess I'm pretty much cleared, since thedon5 had marked me as town, I believe he investigated me and I of course did not go out. That leaves either Varun or Manly to be mafia, I have just 1 query. Why hasn't Aditya died yet? I mean isn't that really weird? I think that means it is almost autowin, because BKB can now continue investigating, with doctor alive and roleblocker dead.

Lynch:Varun

To get him to defend himself. I've been getting null reads from him at times, and strong town posts at times. He has been patchy, so I'd go with him for now.

 

[BKB1991]

I will help you there Zhuorb, hes town. Checked Varun last night. So yea if I die tonight, follow Varun.

Manlys claim is getting worse by the minute

Zhuorb can be cleared out because he was attacked by Sedition. Varuns confirmed. Leaves behind User and Aditya. User claimed survivor and at worst can be SK but I doubt that. Remember though we had two killers at one stage so we do have a SK and a mafia alive.

Think Aditya is the last mafia because his role hasnt been mentioned at all during the writeups and frankly no one else fits it. User could be the SK and Manly the last mafia but I doubt that because Users claim on the first would make less sense and Manly seems to be working alone in the game.

Either ways we got to kill one of Manly or Aditya in my view, because the other will kill tonight. (Think the SK is killing on alternate nights). And Manly fits the bill more than Aditya.

So lynch: Manly

----------

Users claim on the first day*

 

[Manly]

If you keep me alive I'll track User and see if he's an alternate-night SK like I believe he is, I'm almost certain that's the case, as I've thought more or less all along.

 

[Gaurav_7]

If you keep me alive I'll track User and see if he's an alternate-night SK like I believe he is, I'm almost certain that's the case, as I've thought more or less all along.

I think this is desparation. If you keep me alive...

Where is Aditya? The doc? Why hasn't any writeup suggested the doc then? And, why is he still alive? Why have mafia let him stay for so long?

I am suspicious of both Manly and Aditya. Manly's claim sounds suspicious. And, I am the survivor!

 

[Manly]

It is for the fact I'm half way to being killed... And how do you explain the two-death nights? I doubt there's a survivor AND a serial killer left.

----------

Not being funny, I'd rather now lynch User off as an unconfirmed Survivor and have one death overnight if he is the SK, than keep him and he picks two of us off.

Lynch: User

 

[Aditya]

I wouldn't say that me being still alive in the game doesn't shock me, although I shall mention here, Abhas wasn't exactly suspicious of me and even if he was, Colin was obviously a better chance to go after. As far as Sedition is concerned, I supported him throughout the game and hence him going after me would've been a extremely poor move on his part.

Lynch : Manly

 

[Manly]

I have to say, it's pretty frustrating that not a single person has (apparently) investigated or tracked me to clear me, given the suspicion you all have.

 

[BKB1991]

Was that the hammer, or do we need another one?