RoboRocks's Signature making Competition

[showhimmymotto]

heres mine

 

[surendar]

Thank u for entering

 

[RoboRocks]

Yes thank you hopefully more will enter.

 

[showhimmymotto]

hope my signature could help, do you know how i can link it to this thread?

 

[embi]

Easy, highlight the image code and press hperlink. Here is the code (remove two spaces):


[ URL=http://www.planetcricket.org/forums/showthread.php?t=19030][ IMG]http://i1.tinypic.com/s32grn.gif[/IMG][/URL]

 

[showhimmymotto]

thanx

 

[RoboRocks]

OK guys judging tommorrow, make sure you judge all the sigs.

 

[embi]

OK, we had 3 entries.

Entry 1 - Arghasen

Colour: 5 - Could have used a bit more. Too much grey.
Font: 10 - Not bad, but there are plenty more fonts to choose from.
Images: 18 - Very good, exactly what you wanted
Designs: 10 - The white strip is a good element, if only you'd stuck to it!

Overall: 43. A pretty average sig. Good choice of images and the animation works. Would be looking much better if you had used a bit more colour. And a side note, didn't detract from your marks but the image quality (or lack of it) was noticeable. Not that much, but these things matter. I would suggest exporting to .PNG in your image program.

Entry 2 - RabbleRouser

Colour: 18 - The thing in the background isn't quite clear, but it seems to work.
Font: 17 - Good choice of font, and I like the way you have used transparency.
Images: 16 - Two decent images, all you needed.
Designs: 14 - Its a pretty good design,does the job

Overall: 65. An excellent sig, would be proud of that. The way you have used images and font work well. The only slight discrepancy is the background. What exactly is it? Seems to work anyway. This sig is a good example that animation doesn't always make a good sig.

Entry 3 - showhimmymotto

Colour: 14 - Enough, but you could have used a bit more.
Font: 18 - Great uses of font.
Images: 12 - Unfortunately you've squashed them to make them fit
Designs: 18 - Good placement of all the England stuff around the edges with the pics in the middle, works a treat.

Overall: 62. Another excellent sig, rivalling RabbleRouser. The design was excellent and its only let down by those 2 squashed images...(not a huge amount but noticeable).

Overall the quality of the sigs was excellent. A few points here and there, but you can't get a perfect sig, can you? Another note, it does make it easier to judge if you upload your images to imageshack (see the option on new post above attachments).

Well done you 3 three for entering, hopefully there will be a bit more competition next week.

 

[RoboRocks]

arghasan
Colour: 3, use of color was poor, to much gray.
Font: 11 not the best use of fonts but not the worst.
Images: 16 Good use of images.
Design 16 Like how you have moved the text around.
Overall 46 Good use of images and animation, but use of colour was poor, should of defenatly had more bright colours and could of used better font.
A half bad, half good sig.

RabbleRouser
Colour 20; Colours blend in with the images.
Font 15: Text was suitable could of been more opaque.
Images19: Images go really well witht the design.
Design 17: Design is really eyecatching, looks great.
Overall: 71: Brilliant score. A great alround sig, the one thing to improve is the text to be more opaque. Well done.

showhimmymoto
Colour 18 The colour is good to match the rest of the sig.
Font 20 I like this font, its stands out pretty well.
Images 17 Images are a bit sqaushed, but the right ones to use.
Design 15 I feel the England logo in the background can be a touch more opaque.
Overall: 70 great sig, its a battle between you and RabbleRouser, let's see what the other 3 judges think.

 

[RabbleRouser]

Yay i'm winning so far!

The only slight discrepancy is the background. What exactly is it?

I was just playing about with the blur and chrome filters. It isn't really supposed to be anything

 

[surendar]

all the signatures entered so for luks good!!!!
I am not able to view the sig of Entry 1 - Arghasen. So I tell my opinion on other two!!!!

The best of the two according to me is:
Entry 2 - RabbleRouser
color: Pretty gud color combination....It can be given 19/20
Font: Transparency is the good idea!!!! It can be given 17/20
Images: good but sligthly can come up with more better images..(18/20)
Design: Great design (18/20)
Overall: The Best Design of the three!!!!

Entry 3 - showhimmymotto
Color : Could ve used more!!! (10/20)
Font : Good(12/20)
Images: Can work more in the selection of images(12/20)
Designs: Good(16/20)

Overall: Can make more attractive than this....But I really appreciate ur Gud work!!!

Well done all the three...Keep going with more signatures!!!! All the Best for u three in upcoming contests!!!!

good work ...Keep it up,RabbleRouser!!!!

 

[RoboRocks]

Surendar can you please put your overall scores in please, thank you.

Scores still to come:
Usy
Virendar Sehwag

 

[surendar]

RabbleRouser: 72/80
showhimmymotto: 50/80
Arghasen : I m not able to view his sig(No image displayed and its blank)

 

[RoboRocks]

Links works for me.

 

[showhimmymotto]

damn almost had it, so does this mean the losers cant compete in second round or what?