Shane Watson or Murali Vijay??

[Prithvi]

Who is the best at OD, opening in tests and T20??

 

[piriyanth]

Murali Vijay doesn't even have a test half-century yet, so Watson is easily better than him in Tests.

In T20 I'll again go with Watson since he has better average.

 

[rahuldravidfan]

Shane Watson. He's a class act. Murali Vijay is still finding his feet in International cricket. In a couple of years, he can be one of the best players in the world, I say

 

[TumTum]

Just sigh...

 

[Biggy]

wtf is a 'Murali Vijay'?

 

[rahuldravidfan]

He debuted last year after Gambhir famously elbowed Watson

 

[TumTum]

Watson is a world class all-rounder whilst Vijay hasn't even done anything, even in domestic level, either in batting or bowling :doh

I mean seriously wtf???

 

[piriyanth]

Plus he only played one test match.:doh

 

[Gary123]

Useless comparison imo.

 

[TumTum]

'Sachin Tendulkar or God?' thread will make more sense then this one

 

[shravi]

Ha, way to miss the sarcasm. It's a dig at the Gautam Gambhir vs Phil Hughes thread... :sarcasm

 

[Gary123]

'Sachin Tendulkar or God?' thread will make more sence then this one

You have any other things to do rather than just driving Sachin in everything?

 

[nakul]

Wherever any Cricket Thread comes up There comes up a topic about SACHIN TENDULKAR which is unnecessary in my opinion.Just try and reply to the title of the thread instead of bringing Sachin into everything.

@ the topic: Watson would be the choice as Murali hasn't played much International Cricket

 

[Sartaj]

I didn't expect this from you Prithvi
Its Murali Vijay for God's sake!!!

 

[icyman]

WTF ? Stupid comparision.

Request the mods to close this thread as it totally meaningless.

On one side we have an established player whereas on the other, we have someone who just tends to fill in when needed.