End Game SimKit Mafia - ASHUTOSH,MANISH, RUDI and ABDULLAH wins

[Ashutosh.]

Apologies for not posting on day 1. I did not come online on Sunday and Monday so I missed the day 1.

I have read all the posts and writeups and here is my outcome.

There are two possibilities -

(I am assuming there is a mafia godfather and two PGOs.)

1. Both paranoid gun owners did not arm themselves or they arm themselves but town PRs did not target them and Yash was killed by the mafia godfather.
2. Mafia godfather was role blocked and Yash had a PR and targeted one of the PGOs and that PGO armed himself.

If the third mafia is not the mafia godfather and has no special powers then Yash must had a PR and he targetted a PGO who armed himself which means he can't arm himself now.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Most probably Yash was killed by a PGO because the writeup says the mafia too were clueless.

I have my doubts on asprin & Rudi as of now.

 

[asprin]

I have my doubts on asprin & Rudi as of now.

Would it be fair to say I've my doubts on you too? The timing of your replacement is interesting. The night was already ongoing for some time. This gives me an impression that the night was an extended one because TV was waiting for Gokul to send his role - aka you most likely have a PR.

 

[Ashutosh.]

mafia too were clueless.

How does this means that Yash was killed by a PGO?

 

[RUDI]

Lynch: Parth D
@Parth D
Because why not?

 

[Sherlock Holmes]

How about not lynching @Parth D

 

[asprin]

How about not lynching @Parth D

So it took a lynch for you to take notice and post? Mind sharing what you think of the game so far?

 

[Sherlock Holmes]

I am still gathering my thoughts and will comment over it as I finalise it. Currently occupied in real life work hence unable to provide a big post.

P.s: i have been following the game since the beginning and taking a note of who is saying what

 

[Gaurav_7]

How does this means that Yash was killed by a PGO?

As I see it, mafia were clueless because Yash wasn't the one they ordered a kill on.

Would it be fair to say I've my doubts on you too? The timing of your replacement is interesting. The night was already ongoing for some time. This gives me an impression that the night was an extended one because TV was waiting for Gokul to send his role - aka you most likely have a PR.

Oh come on asp. You are too experienced a player to post that type of thing. And if you were really town, you surely wouldn't try and bring out a PR as there are more town PRs than mafia. I sense a foul play here.

Lynch: asprin

 

[Gaurav_7]

I am still gathering my thoughts and will comment over it as I finalise it. Currently occupied in real life work hence unable to provide a big post.

P.s: i have been following the game since the beginning and taking a note of who is saying what

Would appreciate if you shared your thoughts even in small posts..

 

[Manish.]

I am still gathering my thoughts and will comment over it as I finalise it. Currently occupied in real life work hence unable to provide a big post.

P.s: i have been following the game since the beginning and taking a note of who is saying what

Being Cop/Mafia examining the players approach silently ?

Your dp more looks similar to the above characters .

 

[Ashutosh.]

As I see it, mafia were clueless because Yash wasn't the one they ordered a kill on.

If Yash was killed by a PGO means that PGO had armed himself. That PGO did not order to kill anyone.

 

[Ashutosh.]

@CooldiPargi is online but not posting

 

[Sherlock Holmes]

Okay so from the looks of it I feel that the mafias have really tried to blend in together and disguise themselves well here.

Clearly only one person is dead right now that means role blocker was very sharp to block the right person. Then again it was mentioned that mafias themselves were shocked.

The balance of probability lies with the case that Yash was not an ordinary member here. And was victim of the paranoid gun owner.

Still can't pin point directly to a single person. Will continue my quest of gathering more clues and using it for a later period.

 

[Neptune]

Clearly only one person is dead right now that means role blocker was very sharp to block the right person.

Could have been a doc save as well. And yeah evidence does point to Yash being a paranoid gun owner but i wouldnt rule out the possibility of it being a standard mafia kill just yet.
Only way to know is if roleblocker or doc step forward but that would be pretty risky on night 1, will definitely make them a mafia target