End Game Somewhere in Bombay.. mafia wins! Parth D & Ashutosh.

[Yash.]

The person role blocked was now free but couldn't understand why he was blocked and continued sleeping.

You are contradicting yourself here. You yourself said that there are two different roles, i.e. Roleblocker and Jailkeeper.

Thus, it seems to me that The person who was Roleblocked in the previous night was free, and the person who was locked into his house by the jammed gates, was a completely different person.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Lynch count:

Ashutosh (1) - Yash
Neptune (1) - Rudi

With 6 alive, it takes 4 for a hammer.

Not voting: @Parth D @Ashutosh. @Neptune @Manish.

 

[RUDI]

@Gaurav_7 The write-ups - do they contain clues or not?

 

[Neptune]

What even is a mafia Jailkeeper tho? What purpose does that serve for the mafia
Im finding RUDI very suspicious atm, he's doesn't usually just make up things out of thin air like this. I can see a roleblocker for town but since literally no one is claiming, it has to be nilay. Not thinking too much about the kill descriptions, going off solid evidence off Night Actions

 

[Gaurav_7]

@Gaurav_7 The write-ups - do they contain clues or not?

Yes they do.

 

[RUDI]

Not thinking too much about the kill descriptions, going off solid evidence off Night Actions

Yes they do.

@Neptune you should!

 

[RUDI]

I am the detective.

I asked for Ashutosh and TV and both returned as town for me by Gaurav

A Detective is an investigative role that determines whether a player has killed another player, either on the night it is used or on a previous night.

Detective

wiki.mafiascum.net

See now if you had said Cop, your investigations will be more believable.

The standard, Normal, variation of a Cop can investigate one player each Night; the target is not informed of the investigation. This Cop variant will return results of the form "Town" or "Not Town" (regardless of whether it is named "Cop" or "Seer"; both names are acceptable in a Normal); it cannot distinguish between players who belong to different anti-town and third-party factions.

I am sorry guys, but it seems like our whole confckulations are with the power roles claimed. There are no counterclaims because the setup doesn't have any in the particular roles. And both Neptune and Parth alluded to this " No counterclaims"

If checked out 9 player micro setups and having a 2 Mafia and 7 townies setup is very common. One Mafia goon normally have a PR while town is given a investigation role " Cop" which I believe to be asprin as he was wondering outside on night 1 when he was killed.

Jailkeeper as claimed by Neptune is often claimed by scum.

Personally, I think we have the following setup:
2 x Mafia's
(1 x Mafia role blocker)
(1 x Mafia goon)

Roleblocker

wiki.mafiascum.net

5 x Vanilla Townies: Nilay lynched -1
1 x Cop (asprin)
1 x Peacekeeper (TV)

A Peacekeeper can attempt to protect a target from kills and also block someone from performing a kill. A Peacekeeper will stop kills to and from a target player. A blocked kill is considered to not have been performed at all. In effect, it is a kill-specific Jailkeeper.

Peacekeeper fits the storyline perfectly.

For now I believe Yash was protected by TV, role blocked by the Mafia role blocker as they were unsure who stopped their killing on Night 2. Killed TV anyway just to be sure.

For me:
Mafia role blocker: Neptune
Mafia goon: Parth

The rest are plain old simple vanilla townies who (incl. myself) confused as hell.

In case you guys try and spin this as some hoax on my part, I didn't have to be so involved. I could have easily stayed off the radar.

@Yash. / @Ashutosh. / @Manish.

For now I believe Yash was protected by TV, role blocked by the Mafia role blocker as they were unsure who stopped their killing on Night 2. Killed TV anyway just to be sure.

Referring to Night 3 here

 

[Sherlock Holmes]

@RUDI you can ask Gaurav if you wish to about my role.

I was alloted a detective by him. And I had asked him in PM that what should I do with my role.

Just because you know fancy terms and terminologies about mafia doesn't give you the right to dictate the terms.

Soon the reality will be in front of everyone when the goons win the game. And then you will realise who is who.

 

[Yash.]

See now if you had said Cop, your investigations will be more believable.

I'd not dwelve into the terminology much here, as I've seen Detective and Town Cop been used interchangably here at our forums. (Hell, even I used the same terms in the first game I managed).

The main telling point towards ashutosh is the fact that he has also contributed almost nothing, (the reason why Rudi thinks of me to be mafia, but has happily cleared Ashutosh), and he has made two posts playing the victim card that the Mafia are trying to frame him, each post made after the death of a townie at night.

@Ashutosh. I didn't receive your response to this.
@RUDI What do you say to this?

 

[Ashutosh.]

The main telling point towards ashutosh is the fact that he has also contributed almost nothing, (the reason why Rudi thinks of me to be mafia, but has happily cleared Ashutosh), and he has made two posts playing the victim card that the Mafia are trying to frame him, each post made after the death of a townie at night.

Manish and you have also contributed nothing. Both of you have been very inactive. Can I know why you did not lynch Manish? His activity has been more suspicious than me.

I don't trust anyone right now. Everyone seems scum. I will read all the old posts again and will lynch the most suspicious person.

Right now, I know that there are only two mafias, not 3. Because if there had been 3 mafias then the game would have been over now because they are 50% of the population.

 

[Yash.]

Manish and you have also contributed nothing. Both of you have been very inactive. Can I know why you did not lynch Manish? His activity has been more suspicious than me.

I don't trust anyone right now. Everyone seems scum. I will read all the old posts again and will lynch the most suspicious person.

Right now, I know that there are only two mafias, not 3. Because if there had been 3 mafias then the game would have been over now because they are 50% of the population.

I should've bolded the part which I needed the response to.

he has made two posts playing the victim card that the Mafia are trying to frame him,

 

[Ashutosh.]

he has made two posts playing the victim card that the Mafia are trying to frame him

I said the truth. I am being framed. Manish tried to frame me once that's why I doubt him

 

[RUDI]

@RUDI What do you say to this?

I haven't pursued AK much as both Neptune and Parth both clearing him (if I recall correctly)

I'd not dwelve into the terminology much here, as I've seen Detective and Town Cop been used interchangably here at our forums. (Hell, even I used the same terms in the first game I managed).

The two roles are massively different from one another. Cop gets town or anti town on upon investigation where Detective gets if the person investigated killed someone.

Problem for me is mainly - things don't add up.

 

[Manish.]

I'm totally confused reading last few pages.

Parth went to check AK and got townie.
I'm a townie. Believe Yash to be a townie.

Though people commenting RUDI has been dragging everyone from day 1 and started to disclose the roles I don't see him as a scum.

This lefts out my choices with Parth, Neptune and an other one (unable to figure out who). On the other hand I don't convince with Parth's role claim and he visiting AK and comes out his role as a townie.

This may be a gameplay from scums partially targetting themself or they were using the made up roles to claim them. Don't want to take any risk lynching Parth or AK as of now.

LYNCH - Neptune.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Lynch count:

Ashutosh (1) - Yash
Neptune (2) - Rudi, Manish

With 6 alive, it takes 4 for a hammer.