Survivor Mafia - End Game (Town Win)

[Aditya]

What is your opinion of Yudi? I see that you have not commented anything on the issue.
I am curious to know what your current opinion is of him.

If I was not to lynch Sim, I would have lynched Yudi simply basically because he was saying to go for no one on day 1 where as I was saying that even if we are going to lynch someone, it should be a newbie because lynching a experienced member without a solid evidence isn't a great idea on day 1.

 

[Zohaib]

You really think if I was the mafia, I'll go after the person who was the most suspicious of me? Firstly, my net was not working and this isn't a excuse, it's a truth. I wasn't inactive for fun. Secondly, Afridirulez did look suspicious to me, he wasn't that active himself and so I asked him few questions. I didn't reply back to him because the topic was totally shifted and I was saving myself from getting lynched because I'm innocent and I was just saying that if Spoobir comes up townie after being lynched, we can lose a townie on day 1, which obviously isn't good. But some members went after me for this and said that I'm defending Spoobir, who I wasn't really defending, I was just posting my thoughts about lynching him.

Ok so you saying that you wouldnt kill AfridiRulez if you are mafia , and it seems like you didnt as there seem another role killed him , and the mafias probably did miss they attack because why would a mafia choose a no kill at night makes no sense. You intended to go with someone not suspicious of you and someone that you not suspicious off , trying to buy the town.

Then you say , you didnt reply to AfridiRulez , the reason is because you didnt want to get lynched , clearly makes no sense , if you are innocent you have nothing to hide so you should actually answer the questions. That leaves it , you might be mafia and you were scared of giving it away by answering the questions right?

Out of all people why Spoobir , why didnt you defend people like Yudi , bevab and myself when we were lynched , you call it posting your thoughts , then why couldnt you post your thoughts on those people(Yudi , Bevab and myself) they seem far more townie than Spoobir.Is it because you know Spoobir is mafia partner with you?

Unlynch : Sim

Lynch : Aditiya

 

[Aditya]

Ok so you saying that you wouldnt kill AfridiRulez if you are mafia , and it seems like you didnt as there seem another role killed him , and the mafias probably did miss they attack because why would a mafia choose a no kill at night makes no sense. You intended to go with someone not suspicious of you and someone that you not suspicious off , trying to buy the town.

As a mafia, I would never go for a very experienced player on night 1. Mafia's always go for someone who they are almost certain of killing, that is someone who is most certain of not being saved by the townies but the mafia's also make sure that they target someone who can be dangerous if he survives for too long. I've been part of the mafia team before and more often than not, this is the strategy that takes place.

Then you say , you didnt reply to AfridiRulez , the reason is because you didnt want to get lynched , clearly makes no sense , if you are innocent you have nothing to hide so you should actually answer the questions. That leaves it , you might be mafia and you were scared of giving it away by answering the questions right?

Answer the questions? Who asked me questions? Also, I didn't reply to him because I was saving myself from getting lynched, you said correctly I didn't wanted to get lynched and that's what everyone wants, more so if he is innocent. What I said was, I was posting in my defense and because of this I didn't reply to Afridirulez, as one often says something that gets him into trouble even though he is innocent.

----------

Out of all people why Spoobir , why didnt you defend people like Yudi , bevab and myself when we were lynched , you call it posting your thoughts , then why couldnt you post your thoughts on those people(Yudi , Bevab and myself) they seem far more townie than Spoobir.Is it because you know Spoobir is mafia partner with you?

Far more townie? How can I know you guys are townies? Spoobir is far more experienced then you guys and that's why I wasn't sure whether to lynch him on day 1 or not.

 

[Zohaib]

What has he done to make him more innocent and more townie?

----------

Except for his experience , you cant just use his experience as a excuse

 

[Spoobir]

Right since we have almost nothing to go on I'm gonna go with Abhas' gut on this one.

Lynch: Yudi

He seems most scummy to me and he pushed for no lynch on day 1 so can suffer the consequences for that on day 2. I don't know how close he is to being lynched but if he is town I suggest he roleclaims or something. We need something to go on.

 

[Varun]

Unofficial vote count

Aditya (2) - ARay, Zohaib
simsanta123 (2) - CG123, Aditya
Yudi (4) - MaD, Abhas, Varun, Spoobir

7 for a lynch I guess.

 

[Zohaib]

Right since we have almost nothing to go on I'm gonna go with Abhas' gut on this one.

Lynch: Yudi

He seems most scummy to me and he pushed for no lynch on day 1 so can suffer the consequences for that on day 2. I don't know how close he is to being lynched but if he is town I suggest he roleclaims or something. We need something to go on.

Just making it more worse for Aditiya as you completely just ignored the post from me or Aditiya , what im trying to say is that , Spoobir knows that if he mentions anything against Aditiya he might end up getting Aditiya lynched.

Im not sure how you guys cant see it , Aditiya defends Spoobir and then Spoobir turns a blind eye to my post , and Aditiya.

You will say whats they to comment on? , well Aditiya hasnt really defended himself well but he has time to defend Spoobir , im sure some experienced guy can build on to what I have said.

 

[Aditya]

First of all, it's Aditya and to be honest the way you're going after me is very suspicious. How is Spoobir being experienced is a excuse, he is indeed more experienced then some other members here, about whom I really haven't said anything. I'm not defending Spoobir, I was just saying that he is a experienced player and he should not be lynched on day 1 because if he comes up as a townie, we would have suffered a big blow. Lynch him on day 2, I really don't mind as I don't know whether he is a townie or a mafia but to be very frank, he hasn't really done anything suspicious in my eyes.

 

[Zohaib]

It wasnt like Spoobir wasnt going to get hammered on day 1 , there wasnt any real discussion , have to go will talk later about it.

 

[Aditya]

It hardly takes any time to lynch someone, my all point was, not to lynch a experienced member on day 1. Members who have played with me in mafia games before would know that I'm not a fan of going for a no lynch on day 1 but I'm also not a fan of lynching a experienced member on day 1.

 

[Zohaib]

We will wait to see what the experienced members say?

 

[ARay]

If I was not to lynch Sim, I would have lynched Yudi simply basically because he was saying to go for no one on day 1 where as I was saying that even if we are going to lynch someone, it should be a newbie because lynching a experienced member without a solid evidence isn't a great idea on day 1.

i was rather referring to Yudi being confident that SK was the one who made the kill. Do you think it makes sense when given the write up really does not give an indication as to the alignment, the first post a person makes is this. What are your views on this?

Interesting.
I think its pretty obvious that the mafias missed their target and it was the SK who killed AfridiRulez.

First of all, it's Aditya and to be honest the way you're going after me is very suspicious. How is Spoobir being experienced is a excuse, he is indeed more experienced then some other members here, about whom I really haven't said anything. I'm not defending Spoobir, I was just saying that he is a experienced player and he should not be lynched on day 1 because if he comes up as a townie, we would have suffered a big blow. Lynch him on day 2, I really don't mind as I don't know whether he is a townie or a mafia but to be very frank, he hasn't really done anything suspicious in my eyes.

Okay, here is my question at what point does lynching an "experienced" member become viable?
You say here day 2, but then for other people it definitely could be day 3. For some people it could even be day 1.
The point I am trying to make is that experience should never prevent a lynch, whatever the day it is. If a player acts suspiciously its perfectly viable to get a lynch on him (regardless of experience).

 

[Near]

Right since we have almost nothing to go on I'm gonna go with Abhas' gut on this one.

Lynch: Yudi

He seems most scummy to me and he pushed for no lynch on day 1 so can suffer the consequences for that on day 2. I don't know how close he is to being lynched but if he is town I suggest he roleclaims or something. We need something to go on.

Eh, nice bandwagon. How about you actually post your thoughts on other players and help the town and not just bandwagon, eh?

FOS- Spoobir
Reason: Hasn't been helping the town, but had the time to bandwagon

Although, I do agree that Yudi's SK post is kind of a scumslip, I'm gonna wait for Yudi to put a defense since he already has quite a lot votes on

 

[hedger_14]

Thanks Varun.

Vote Count

Aditya (2) - ARay, Zohaib
simsanta123 (2) - CG123, Aditya
Yudi (4) - MaD, Abhas, Varun, Spoobir

I'm going away now until tomorrow night so I won't be on during that time, just to let you all know.

 

[CG123]

Still no post from Sim, so although Yudi is definitely up there in terms of who I want to lynch, I'm still going to stay of Sim. He's just deadweight atm, he hasn't posted in a while, and when he did post it added nothing to the thread. If he does post he will have a lot to analysis, so I expect he should post a decent sized post on his thoughts, and not just say like "Sorry, I was away" like heaps of others do after being inactive for a bit.

Back online after a while.

Reading through the pages, I see many are getting suspicious of me for gunning for a no lynch on day 1 and then being sure about a SK killing AfridiRulez.
The thing I said on AfridiRulez's death was because I am pretty sure that the mafias would target a relatively stronger player. I know the reason isn't much convincing, but that's the way it is. And the writeup indicating that someone missed his target makes me sure about the fact that the mafias missed their target.

On another note, I am still very suspicious of Abhas. He has been constantly targeting me throughout the game, which seems scummy to me.

FOS: Abhas

As far as Sim is concerned, he has been inactive for some days, but that doesn't implies that he is a mafia who is simply lurking. Would never like to lynch an inactive guy as I feel that everyone should be given some time to defend themselves.
I'm not an idiot to do so I were a part of the mafias.

You didn't answer my question, if you don't answer it next time you come on I'll probably jump on the bandwagon and lynch you.

@ Yudi - You got your "wish" on day one of a no lynch, so where shall we proceed from here, is it time to randomly attack some people some more, or shall we just do nothing today again as we can't be certain of anyone? (I'm being serious by the way, I'm just wondering what you think we should do)

Tbh I'm in the same camp as Aditya, probably looks slightly suspicious because we've both lynched the same person. On day one a no lynch is just a waste, but at the same time I'm not normally going to lynch someone like Abhas, that's just the way it is for me. Of course if he gives me some reason to lynch him I will, but I'm not just going to randomly lynch him like I do with other less experienced/new players.

That's partly why I wanted/want to know how Yudi would like the game to progress from here, because at the moments it's starting to get to me at his reluctant to lynch anyone without being sure they're mafia.