Survivor Mafia - End Game (Town Win)
- Thread starter hedger_14
- Start date
hedger_14
ICC Chairman
Well I have already said, if someone wants to replace him, they can.
Will try and read the write up in few minutes. Where do you think we go today then?
If we lose a townie today and tonight, then we're almost done.
User2010, ARay and Abhas are all very good players, so I know very little about any of them atm, i.e. town or mafia.
I'm not sure on p# or Varun either.
I'm guessing one of you or Yudi is mafia. With Yudi already having claimed it might be time for you to roleclaim, but then if we're going to go down that path I think we might as well just do a mass roleclaim, hence why I'm putting it out there.
If we lose a townie today and tonight, then we're almost done.
User2010, ARay and Abhas are all very good players, so I know very little about any of them atm, i.e. town or mafia.
I'm not sure on p# or Varun either.
I'm guessing one of you or Yudi is mafia. With Yudi already having claimed it might be time for you to roleclaim, but then if we're going to go down that path I think we might as well just do a mass roleclaim, hence why I'm putting it out there.
Aditya
ICC Board Member
I've no problem in role claiming, I can role claim any time. I was just wondering whether I should role claim straight away, or I should wait for other members to post their views? I'm not sure about Yudi, his role claim is confusing but no one has counter role claimed so we don't have any other option rather than to believe him for now. As you said, I'm not sure about User2010, Aray and Abhas either. We never know with P# too, what if he is mafia? He really hasn't posted much and so we have no evidence to be suspicious of him. I'd like to know his views on the game.
Don't roleclaim atm, just wait until some others post.
And the mafia were given fake roleclaims, so no ones going to counterclaim him even if it is a fake claim because they were given fake claims. I just can't see the winner of the series not being in the actual game, so the real question for me comes down to is she mafia or town.
And the mafia were given fake roleclaims, so no ones going to counterclaim him even if it is a fake claim because they were given fake claims. I just can't see the winner of the series not being in the actual game, so the real question for me comes down to is she mafia or town.
Abhas
Retired Administrator
- Joined
- Aug 6, 2004
- Location
- New Delhi, India
That's bad! After losing the cop, we lose the tracker, who could have helped us find the mafia.
At the moment, Yudi seems the most scummy, apart from p# of course, who hasn't been posting at all.
I don't think role claiming would help us a lot because characters are different anyway due to the fake claims, and since we don't know of any other role in the game, we are likely to be left with a bunch of vanilla townies.
From the writeups I had so far analysed only cop, tracker, doc, and role blocker. We might have a town blocker as well, considering the mafia role blocker's dead.
If we all agree to mass claim however, I'm happy to claim.
At the moment, Yudi seems the most scummy, apart from p# of course, who hasn't been posting at all.
I don't think role claiming would help us a lot because characters are different anyway due to the fake claims, and since we don't know of any other role in the game, we are likely to be left with a bunch of vanilla townies.
From the writeups I had so far analysed only cop, tracker, doc, and role blocker. We might have a town blocker as well, considering the mafia role blocker's dead.
If we all agree to mass claim however, I'm happy to claim.
Thinking about Yudi's claim it does make sense that she'd have that role, but at the same time there's every possibility she could be mafia. (By she I'm referring to the character)
The thing is I'm just so unsure on everyone else, which I'm assuming is the same with the other four or so townies out there considering no one is really coming forward with any decent information at this stage when we probably need it. But yeah, it's always going to be tough without the cop and tracker, because I assume they're are only two night roles we have/had that would help in finding out information.
The thing is I'm just so unsure on everyone else, which I'm assuming is the same with the other four or so townies out there considering no one is really coming forward with any decent information at this stage when we probably need it. But yeah, it's always going to be tough without the cop and tracker, because I assume they're are only two night roles we have/had that would help in finding out information.
Varun
ICC Board Member
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2009
- Location
- Delhi, India
- Online Cricket Games Owned
- Don Bradman Cricket 14 - Steam PC
Tracker dead, and a good player in MaD as well... that's not good.
I'm ready for a mass role-claim but not sure if that will be helpful, especially since the mafia have fake role claims. For now, Yudi, obviously, is my prime suspect because of the mention of 'she' in the night role which might very well be Yudi's claim, although I'm not sure. p# is next, a deadweight, if he's town, the mafia probably won't kill him, thus it's like one less town for us. If he's mafia, he could be very well that 'she' or 'he', for he most probably didn't use his role - and I am sure that none of the mafia is normal goon. I am still in two minds about him, though.
I'm not actually suspicious of Aditya, he has played a bit scummy, but for some reason I'm not suspicious of him as much as I am of others. No idea whatsoever about User2010 and Abhas.
Based on my above analysis,
Lynch : Yudi
I'm ready for a mass role-claim but not sure if that will be helpful, especially since the mafia have fake role claims. For now, Yudi, obviously, is my prime suspect because of the mention of 'she' in the night role which might very well be Yudi's claim, although I'm not sure. p# is next, a deadweight, if he's town, the mafia probably won't kill him, thus it's like one less town for us. If he's mafia, he could be very well that 'she' or 'he', for he most probably didn't use his role - and I am sure that none of the mafia is normal goon. I am still in two minds about him, though.
I'm not actually suspicious of Aditya, he has played a bit scummy, but for some reason I'm not suspicious of him as much as I am of others. No idea whatsoever about User2010 and Abhas.
Based on my above analysis,
Lynch : Yudi
Gaurav_7
Executive member
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2010
- Profile Flag
- India
I don't really know much about Survivors so no idea about Yudi's claim. Fake claims have made it difficult. I though wonder why would someone who was in Villains in real would be town in the game. P#, is he inactive? I mean right from the start? If yes, we might actually get him out as either way he isn't useful to us.
FOS : Yudi
Lynch : p23456789
FOS : Yudi
Lynch : p23456789
Near
Club Cricketer
OK, Since I guess it's time for me to claim, I'll claim. I'm Stephanie LaGrossa, one of the most popular players and known for being the last Ulong Player. Thanks to my popularity my vote is taken more seriously or in other cases I'm the Double Voter. And since, I still don't believe Yudi's claim at all:
Lynch: Yudi
Lynch: Yudi
I might be up for mass claiming. But given that mafia have been given fake claims will make it rather hard especially for people like me (with no survivor knowledge) to figure out whether a character claim is legitimate or not.
What I am rather afraid off is that mass claiming might narrow the field even further and allow the mafia to figure out the remaining power roles.
As for lynches, I still feel Yudi might be a strong lynch candidate. But I wish to ask him a few questions.
Yudi, What are views of p# and aditya? Who do you think is the strongest lynch candidate?
What I am rather afraid off is that mass claiming might narrow the field even further and allow the mafia to figure out the remaining power roles.
As for lynches, I still feel Yudi might be a strong lynch candidate. But I wish to ask him a few questions.
Yudi, What are views of p# and aditya? Who do you think is the strongest lynch candidate?
Abhas
Retired Administrator
- Joined
- Aug 6, 2004
- Location
- New Delhi, India
Brilliant.. You say you're the most powerful member with a double vote, so what do you do? You decide not to vote at all!
I don't believe the claim. CG will need to help us out of this one.
----------
I looked it up wikipedia, and it says that she was a part of the Palau game, but in heroes vs villains, she was voted out 2nd, so she was hardly powerful.
Lynch: p23456789
I'll wait for CG to come up with an analysis of his claim.
Aditya
ICC Board Member
Lynch : p23456789
I prefer that we get rid of P# first, because he has been inactive from the starting of the game and he's really not helping us so even if he comes up as a townie after being lynched, it wont make a difference because he really hasn't contributed anything useful. If he comes up as a mafia then there could not be anything better than that.
I prefer that we get rid of P# first, because he has been inactive from the starting of the game and he's really not helping us so even if he comes up as a townie after being lynched, it wont make a difference because he really hasn't contributed anything useful. If he comes up as a mafia then there could not be anything better than that.
