The Silence Of The Lambs Mafia - Endgame - SK (Sulaiman7) WINS

[surendar]

I find the bolded part interesting. Buffalo Bill was in found in Ohio by Clarice. This to me suggests maybe Crawford was sane, and that means perhaps the two-cop theory doesn't work, as for that, the write-up should have mentioned that Crawford was in Illinois. This suggests maybe Clarice isn't in the game, as Crawford knows what he's doing?

This means, I am with wrong target and that is why Clarice isn't mentioned on the spot. Which is true, because my target for investigation was PS last night.

Clarice is not a fake claim, we have had successive day write ups mentioning her as investigator.

Day 1 - If she has to enter the mind of killer, she has to challenge the madman.
Day 2 - You know, I have met a lot of detectives, but I must say I can't ever remember one as attractive.

So it would be waste of time to even think about Clarice being a fake claim or not existing one.

What do you think of doc having a mafia's name? I find it really hard to believe that name would be shared to another person if I investigate correct target. Doc getting the information at ease is of no use, in terms of game play.

What is Chilton going to do with Killer's name unless he opts to protect the killer knowing that I have investigated lector? I definitely find it very fishy.

----------

ETA substitute Bill/Lector for any of the "safe" claims to get who could be working together. For example Clare Martin could be a fake claim for Bill. Barney for Hannibal etc

This is the first point of yours that I agree. Barney is one of the safest bets that we really don't know whether it is fake claim or not. Agreed.

 

[Sulaiman7]

You said, my claim is not true during start of day. Now you jumped completely other-way. Did I miss any post of yours.

When did I say that's it is not true ? I was actually thinking of this to be a classic set-up that's why I said that that I am not too sure about your claim. I didn't say that you're maifa and this is a fake claim.

For example Clare Martin could be a fake claim for Bill. Barney for Hannibal etc

Let's take this into consideration, if Catherine and Barney are fake claims, then you think Miggs and Lamar are townie ? I don't see Ardelia Mapp being a townie if Barney and Catherine are fake claims, that's a fake claim too. What else do you can think of ? there's only 1 vanilla ? which there cannot be. Without vanillas, games go pretty unbalanced so I don't see this set-up to be vanilla-less.

Bill and Hannibal - they're never working together

If this is true then that would make only one mafia that's Bill, what will be Hannibal then ?

Analysing the write-up though:-

The head of the FBI Behavioral Science Unit found dead. His terminally ill wife would be uncared for now. WHAT was he is doing in Ohio though?!

The real cop reaches Ohio, this means that Yash the (head of the FBI Behavioral Science Unit) is a sane cop and Surendar is a paraniod/insane or something else kinda cop. If this' true then P_Squared is a mafia.

 

[ved_]

Wouldn't Hannibal be a SK then?

 

[thedon5]

Not sure where to go from here, we need to make a decision what we're going to do.

 

[hedger_14]

You listen to the town drunk.

And the town drunk says ... PARTY!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[Sulaiman7]

Wouldn't Hannibal be a SK then?

Might be because in the end he gets successful alone ?

 

[thedon5]

If there is an SK, the only way I think it's possible is if they only kill on even nights. But I think it's unlikely.

 

[barmyarmy]

I'm least convinced by Sulaiman. If I had to pick two players as mafia he would be one of them. The soft claiming point is a good one; it's like he has had someone prompting him along and helping him.
Lynch: Sulaiman

 

[thedon5]

Sulaiman plays this newbie card well. Last time he did it he won the game as Mafia. This time, I'm just not sure, and I'm not going to believe your claims that it isn't actually MyLo - you have to assume it is, and the way Sulaiman has been playing, I see him more as someone to target later on rather than now as we can't lynch him only for not having a clue and only due to a process of elimination.

After going through the write-up again, my suspicions of Zhuorb have cooled somewhat. Earlier I said I was pretty sure either you or Zhuorb was Mafia. So I'm keen to follow up my earlier inkling. Your gameplay has been un-Colin-like, and even your lynch post makes me think the same thing, as well as your insistence that we can make a mistake.

Lynch: barmyarmy

I am keen to see what others think, and also I am lynching you as I see it as the best option at this point in time - I can still be convinced to remove the lynch and lynch someone else by all means.

 

[barmyarmy]

I'm not going to believe your claims that it isn't actually MyLo

I'll quote the posts for you in a minute but I've said that we can't be sure it's MyLo but we have to assume that it is.

----------

If it wasn't LyLo (which we think it is) I would have less hesitation about lynching him off.
...
Especially because if there isn't a two person team of some kind then it isn't actually MyLo.

MyLo LyLo Shmylo...

----------

Well as thedon said on the previous page it's probably MyLo. Depends on the setup.

...

----------

Please explain. If you're town and we lynch you we lose...

That ought to be enough for now...

----------

Sulaiman plays this newbie card well. Last time he did it he won the game as Mafia.

I didn't follow the last game and didn't know that. In light of this it's quite surprising that you're giving him a pass here.

----------

Your gameplay has been un-Colin-like, and even your lynch post makes me think the same thing, as well as your insistence that we can make a mistake.

I seem to get told that every game regardless of my alignment...

I've always been a cautious player; especially in a setup like this where there are just too many unknowns and variables. I've not jumped on anyone since the day started. I've asked for other views, given mine and settled on the most likely person. I want to lynch correctly and I'm trying to minimise risk. Your sudden making-up-of-your-mind about me does make me feel like this is a mafia railroad job. Up to now you've not done anything scummy but I'll make up my mind on that based on how you proceed from here.

 

[Varun]

Vote count:

Sulaiman7 (2) - surendar, barmyarmy
barmyarmy (1) - thedon5

Let's say the day ends in 24 hours.

 

[surendar]

If I had to pick two players as mafia

Can we have this from all of us here on who we think as mafia(not just the suspects, but who you feel according to you as Mafia).

• Don has gone for Colin with suspect of Zhuorb or Colin
• I have gone for Sulaiman with suspect of Sulaiman or Colin
• Colin has gone for Sulaiman with suspects of Sulaiman/Don/Zhuorb

@Zhuorb; -
@P Squared; -
@Sulaiman7; -

 

[barmyarmy]

Yup, good approach I agree.

 

[surendar]

Your gameplay has been un-Colin-like, and even your lynch post makes me think the same thing, as well as your insistence that we can make a mistake.

This is the main thing I have found very odd in Colin right from Day 1 that I was highlighting as insisting/repetitive. I just wasn't sure whether it is his style of playing or he going really odd as I have not played with him before.g

With 2 cops + 1 doc - I also don't think there is a governor role in this set up. If Colin's claim is true,

2 cop, 1 doc, 2 Mafia, 1 governor, 1 vanilla townie? Highly unlikely of Varun keeping only just one vanilla townie in this set up.

 

[barmyarmy]

Edit: meaning asking everyone to do it rather than bigging myself up!

----------

This is the main thing I have found very odd in Colin right from Day 1 that I was highlighting as insisting/repetitive. I just wasn't sure whether it is his style of playing or he going really odd as I have not played with him before.

I get frustrated with people seemingly not reading what I'm writing and making the same points at me (especially when those points have little or no basis).
I suggest you go back and read some other games I've been involved in as town if you want to know if it's my "normal" style or not.