The Smurfs Mafia - EndGame - Town Wins! (CG123, Hedger_14, BKB1991)

[Aditya]

Ah, Whatever I just started the conversation for the sake of conversation. Everyone was lurking behind trying to stay under the radar so that nobody suspect them.
You are counter attacking me so you can't be a mafia. A mafia would have diverted the suspicion on someone else, but you never know. The first round is gonna be guess work unless people talk.

Can you please explain this for me? When the game had barely began, how do you expect the members to be active?

FOS : AngryPixel

He looks very suspicious at the moment.

 

[Zohaib]

The way I see it everyone is just going to be suspicious on him , I think he should maybe role claim , but if he has a power role he shouldn't.
Role Claiming will help as it will be hard to make up a role for a newbie if he is mafia. If he isnt , it shouldnt be hard to role claim

@Bevab , What makes you say he is the Jester?

 

[Chewie]

Having a jester in the game is a surefire way for the mod to get hated by everyone Having said that, there was a smurf who would fit that description pretty well.

The thing is, that I don't think AP is the joker. He's not really doing things that would suggest to me that he is one.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Anybody sense Zohaib being too aggressive? Very different from all his other games?

AP is just new maybe. But, the interesting thing he said was Smurf giving someone a GF role whom we don't expect to be one. Actually, we just can't expect anyone to be any character as it's all random.

 

[Vedarshi]

Bevab,trying to defend AP?Ill take that as another potential mafia.AP is going nowhere and if he even is the jester,well atleast the town wont lose a man,he would be individual.Also,even if he wins,the game will continue.We can finally rest in peace if hes the jester.I will give him one more chance to defend himself.
FOS-Bevab,AngryPixel

----------

Also AP,in mafia you have to be suspicious of everyone till they are dead.P

 

[Zohaib]

Anybody sense Zohaib being too aggressive? Very different from all his other games?

AP is just new maybe. But, the interesting thing he said was Smurf giving someone a GF role whom we don't expect to be one. Actually, we just can't expect anyone to be any character as it's all random.

All my games have been different because I get a different role all the time

 

[MaD]

Very weird post by AP indeed, trying to find out who the Godfather is by observing the mod and thinking about who he would have assigned the roles to.... weird...
FOS: AP

 

[Bevab]

Bevab,trying to defend AP?Ill take that as another potential mafia.AP is going nowhere and if he even is the jester,well atleast the town wont lose a man,he would be individual.Also,even if he wins,the game will continue.We can finally rest in peace if hes the jester.I will give him one more chance to defend himself.
FOS-Bevab,AngryPixel

----------

Also AP,in mafia you have to be suspicious of everyone till they are dead.P

When was I defending AngryPixel? Seriously. A jester would waste us a day also if he is. So you'll rest in peace if he is a jester eh.

FOS: Vedarshi

 

[Zohaib]

Typical noob play

He is suspicious of you so you have to be suspicious of him.

 

[Highlander999]

Anybody sense Zohaib being too aggressive?

I agree, why are you trying to get someone to roleclaim on Day 1, maybe so the mafia can see who does and doesn't have the power roles?

 

[Zohaib]

I agree, why are you trying to get someone to roleclaim on Day 1, maybe so the mafia can see who does and doesn't have the power roles?

No it isnt that I came into this mafia game trying to get a different approach from my last games which is dont hide under the radar and be more aggressive. My role is also different.The other reason is because everyone is suspicious of AP , if it carries on like this where he isnt going to defend himself but instead try move away from the topic he will get lynched or hammered whatever it is.
So if he role claims and he is town then he might save himself from getting lynched. It isnt that I want to see who has a power role , I dont really care but all I want to do is see if he is town because right now he is playing under the radar.

To you find AP suspicious if so why?

 

[Bevab]

Typical noob play

He is suspicious of you so you have to be suspicious of him.

If you analyze his post properly he said that a jester is good for the town. A jester can confuse the town a lot and his lynch also wastes a day. So in what way is it good?

 

[Highlander999]

The other reason is because everyone is suspicious of AP , if it carries on like this where he isnt going to defend himself but instead try move away from the topic he will get lynched or hammered whatever it is.

That sounds a lot like to me you are jumping on the bandwagon, end of the day it is his first game and he is posting a bit light-heartedly in my opinion and I think he is trying to deal with the suspicion on him by laughing it off

So if he role claims and he is town then he might save himself from getting lynched.

And what happens if he has a power role? By you trying to force his hand (and I think that would be a very strange move from a townie this early on) you have basically given the mafia a target as until we have some proper evidence, trying to lynch someone because they're new is not very good play.

It isnt that I want to see who has a power role , I dont really care but all I want to do is see if he is town because right now he is playing under the radar.

But that directly contradicts itself as what if he is a power role the town has basically shot itself in the foot? I think it is always best to be on the cautious side on Day 1 when there is never any real evidence

To you find AP suspicious if so why?

At the moment I don't, I just think he is just new to the game, doesn't mean he isn't anti-town, but at the moment there is no evidence to suggest either way.

 

[AngryPixel]

I'm not gonna role claim on day 1 for sure. I just hope someone protects me Coz I'm in the crosshairs of everyone at the moment
IMO Zohaib,MAD,Vedarshi and Hedger looks like mafia members. Coz they are the one who have jumped to conclusion very quickly. Only a mafia member wont let a chance like this go away easily.

 

[P Squared]

Did you just say that you're waiting for someone to protect you? You are really acting very weird.