Gaurav_7
Executive member
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2010
- Profile Flag
- India
Video Game Mafia - Game Over: Maney and Spoobir Victorious
- Thread starter MaD
- Start date
Colin, you seem to be back-tracking a lot here on your earlier claims, all under the pretence of you don't actually under your character. Under normal circumstances, I would have lynched you off.
This isn't normal circumstances, though. MaD is being a total bastard here, by giving a super powerful townie role to a non-townie person. I do think that you were genuinely a bit confused, and your role is not one we can easily lynch off. If we do, we would be playing right in the hands of the mafia.
My gut instinct says to lynch you. But logic dictates to keep you around.
Lucky for you, I like the sound of logic
I got the role when I was still on holiday and read it very quickly on my phone so I was ready to start the game. That, and as you said, MaD is playing bastard mod. Hopefully this will all become clear eventually...
Dr. Pepper
Chairman of Selectors
Everything happens when I'm at school.
I'm struggling to understand this suspicion on me. I've analysed every write up and I was the first to bring attention to the shape shift thing, which happened to become very relevant right now with Colin originally claiming to be a shape shifter (but then back tracking on that claim).
I didn't defend Bevab so I have no idea where you got this from. Look back at my posts and point out where I supposedly did that. As for playing a "silent game", I'm at school when the game really gets going so I get home and have around 10 pages to read. Obviously if I was at home I'd post throughout the discussion but I've only been able to give my insight at the end.
Tbh, I'm finding your play quite suspicious Aditya. You attacked Zohaib aggressively (although to be fair, he dug himself a hole), he claimed cop but you still weren't convinced, you plucked the idea that I tried to defend Bevab out of thin air. This was also whilst Colin had a lot of pressure on him and it was a bit off topic from the conversation that was going on at the time.
------------
Colin seems to have uncharacteristically slipped up a few times. First bring attention to the fact he didn't know that townies were called protagonists, then saying he was a shape shifter then later claiming he never said that. Also he took a while to fully explain his role. Could be that he was making it up as he went along.
From what I've seen in previous games, P Squared always seems to play "under the radar". I'm not that suspicious of him and I think that a claim like Lara Croft is very likely to be in the game.
I want to go back to what Themer said after Colin slipped up about protagonists.
Now I think that the mafia would be aware of protagonists as it would probably say something like "you win when all the protagonists are dead" in their PM so that leads me to believe that Themer is individually aligned and therefore cult. His reply to the question on him afterwards was a joke I think which makes me even more suspicious.
He was the player I was most suspicious of anyway as I didn't like the way he seemed to be bandwagoning constantly but I didn't say anything as I wanted to observe his play for a bit before jumping to a conclusion.
I'm struggling to understand this suspicion on me. I've analysed every write up and I was the first to bring attention to the shape shift thing, which happened to become very relevant right now with Colin originally claiming to be a shape shifter (but then back tracking on that claim).
I didn't defend Bevab so I have no idea where you got this from. Look back at my posts and point out where I supposedly did that. As for playing a "silent game", I'm at school when the game really gets going so I get home and have around 10 pages to read. Obviously if I was at home I'd post throughout the discussion but I've only been able to give my insight at the end.
Tbh, I'm finding your play quite suspicious Aditya. You attacked Zohaib aggressively (although to be fair, he dug himself a hole), he claimed cop but you still weren't convinced, you plucked the idea that I tried to defend Bevab out of thin air. This was also whilst Colin had a lot of pressure on him and it was a bit off topic from the conversation that was going on at the time.
------------
Colin seems to have uncharacteristically slipped up a few times. First bring attention to the fact he didn't know that townies were called protagonists, then saying he was a shape shifter then later claiming he never said that. Also he took a while to fully explain his role. Could be that he was making it up as he went along.
From what I've seen in previous games, P Squared always seems to play "under the radar". I'm not that suspicious of him and I think that a claim like Lara Croft is very likely to be in the game.
I want to go back to what Themer said after Colin slipped up about protagonists.
Themer said:
Now I think that the mafia would be aware of protagonists as it would probably say something like "you win when all the protagonists are dead" in their PM so that leads me to believe that Themer is individually aligned and therefore cult. His reply to the question on him afterwards was a joke I think which makes me even more suspicious.
He was the player I was most suspicious of anyway as I didn't like the way he seemed to be bandwagoning constantly but I didn't say anything as I wanted to observe his play for a bit before jumping to a conclusion.
Aditya
ICC Board Member
I don't know why but at the time I made that post, I did feel that somewhere you did support Bevab for a second but as I mentioned in the post, I wasn't going too deep into this as I hadn't looked back at the old posts.
There we go, you yourself say that my aggressiveness towards Zohaib was fine so that ends that topic here and where did I didn't believe Zohaib's claim? I posted that his claim seems good to me and not that I'm not convinced with it. I also unlynched him at that time and lynched Colin. Now, I don't understand where did that come from.
That's what I wanted to hear from you, the reason behind your inactivity. I completely understand the difference between the time zones problem. I understand your inactivity now.
There we go, you yourself say that my aggressiveness towards Zohaib was fine so that ends that topic here and where did I didn't believe Zohaib's claim? I posted that his claim seems good to me and not that I'm not convinced with it. I also unlynched him at that time and lynched Colin. Now, I don't understand where did that come from.
That's what I wanted to hear from you, the reason behind your inactivity. I completely understand the difference between the time zones problem. I understand your inactivity now.
Dr. Pepper
Chairman of Selectors
I've re-read your posts from then and I missed what you put after he claimed. I got a little mixed up (I did have to take in 10 pages of information
)----------
I'm going to re-read the write-ups and try and make sense of them with the role info we have now.
Dr. Pepper
Chairman of Selectors
I think this was Highlander who the cult tried to recruit.
~
Darth Vader (Bevab) roleblocked here.
~
This I definitely think was Highlander. Someone drained his power and therefore someone else must've taken over from him.
This is Barmyarmy and backs up his claim.
Congestion is an interesting title and I think something can be inferred from this. Maybe it means more than one person used their role on the person who the killer tried to kill. Makes sense as it seems they were saved.
~
I have a theory for this bit. The doc tried to save Highlander but Highlander's power had already been drained from the mission before and he was going to die anyway. I think that someone has taken Highlander's role.
Gaurav_7
Executive member
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2010
- Profile Flag
- India
I don't think that's the case.
I actually put this part in one of my posts.
Here it is -
User2010 said:
Ben has a weird role.
Discuss.
Aditya
ICC Board Member
I know this might sound completely weird but this is crazy mafia run by MaD. Can there be any possibility of the cop being from the mafia side? I don't really know how you guys are gonna react to this post but I actually find this interesting. Think yourself, first a mafia claims as cop and then again maybe a mafia claims as cop to clear the mess that they made at first and maybe trying to see whether there is a cop on the townies side as well. I obviously don't know whether this can happen but this does seem interesting and this is crazy mafia after all.
Similar threads
- Poll
